Few simple questions

ankit111 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Friends, we hv heard a lot of logics and arguments in the defence of JAGO and Anandi, few of thm clearly influenced by the personal liking, entertainment and chemistry, but as we all educated person and hv ability to think and differentiate rit and wrong (i hope) so my simple question is :
keep aside r personal liking, ur favourite actor, chemistry, geography or phisyology. keep aside entertainment value, who is boring and who is entertaining. forget tht this s serial and think tht its happening in real somewhere around u (and such things happens in real life). think abt the envioroment in which these events happened and just tell,
will u support such adultery cases?? will u support Jogia action?? will u support Gauri reaction and action?? will u not feel for Anandi, ony becoz she is boring??? will u support JAGO, becoz they hv chemistry or they r bringing TRP (thts why i asked to forget tht this is serial)??
only request not create imaginarry situation with IF and BUT. just on the basis of wht hs been shown and not wht sd hv been shown😆

Edited by ankit111 - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

55

Views

5.9k

Users

23

Likes

257

Frequent Posters

intruderfast thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

well of course not 😆he lied for god sake 4 yrs 😡to both the girls and i have major objection in hiding the truth from a , if he would have confessed it to her 4 yrs back , anandi ke 4 yrs waste nahin hote

cmon 4 yrs is a big big time
(though i still will partly blame her for not continuing her studies )
and reg g yes i would feel for her even then😆right now i feel the most for g ,uskii life kaa tai tai fish ho gaya hain yaa i know she choose all this but still she is in such a big mess and its all due to his illegal pati fault
and yes would have felt bad for a
vasuja thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
I would blame Jagya mainly for all this...And if the person who newly married jagya behaved like gauri, I would have sent her to psychiatrist.

In case of Jagya it is the case of pure cheating.He did every thing consciously just avoided bothering about the consequences

In case of gauri she is a fine girl. Just muddled in her head and conphused or else she will never continue to be in the same mess... two sessions with a good psychiatrist, will fix her head... She is not a criminal, but the past has affected her and had made her insecure...If she is made to understand the situation by a proffessional she will get out of the relationship in a jiffy.

Well my sympathies will be for Anandi and i would have wanted her to file the case against Jagya and send him to jail. then continue her studies move on and have a wonderful life..

.Prometheus. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
If I took what has happened in the serial for real value, i would place the blame 65% on Jagat 30% on Gauri and 5% on Anandi

Jagat manipulated and lied throughout his relationship with both the girls to get what he wanted, and is continously deceiving both of them even now. He will do just about anything to get what he wanted

Gauri should not have married Jagat, she should have gone to the family to find out the truth, got Anandi and Jagat divorced if that was true that Jagat did not love Anandi, she willingly enaged in a relationship with a married/attached man (legal or not).

Anandi saw changed in Jagat's behaviour and decided to look over it, she should have stood up for herself from the beginning and looked into the matter, rather then sweeping it under and always covering for Jagat.

I dont support in Jagat or Gauri in one way or another, they are truly being selfish at the moment and thinking only about themselves, they change their decisions so suit their wnats and desires and seem to twist everything that happens to make themselves look like the victim

Anandi is being too submissive, i feel for her turmoil but she needs to act against the mistreatment she has suffered and not be a doormat.
ankit111 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
as per my POV :
Jogia - No justification, he need punishment for his act. he is a habitual liar and selfish person and he need a lession. he deserve neither of girls😡

Gouri - She certainly need a psychiatrist. very unpractical person, who need guidense. she hs some basic problems which need to be cured.

Anandi - seeing the envioroment in which she brought up, she is very practical, sensible and selfless person, who put other interests before herself. we may criticize her, becoz we live in more advanced society, but atleast from her action she only harm herself and not others⭐️ ofcourse i wd wish her to forget this selfish person and move on, keeping the basic value inside herself. she cherished very rare quality, which absent now a days👏👏 and i wd wish success for such person, which can do a lot good for the society. her success will be not good for herself only but for the whole society⭐️
tanvismile thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
I never said what hapend with anandi is right ,definitely when its a serial we r forced to see the other sides too.In real life we dnt see the other of story.but i never said j the way he did was right.
fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
i fully blame J for the state the entire family and G is in. but at the same time this isnt bal vivah for G so shes to be blamed as well.

when she was a kid she never knew the boy is already married etc etc and she was rejected as well soon enough which caused so much of problems for her. but that was her parents and singh familys mistake then. but now shes totally sensible (well at least shes expected to be) and even then repeats the same mistake what her parents did once upon a time.😕

Considering A's background shes quite mature and sensible. she has been handling this place and DS so very well since a young age that they r thoroughly impressed with her. If DS is impressed with someone then there has to be something in that person. 😉

as abt her moving on...well it was J that got attracted to someone else not her so it will take her loads of time to digest the whole fact in. shes just a normal human being.

When daactarni G after knowing that J fooled her for 5 yrs still agrees to marry him then what A's fault who has always considered this family as her own and J as her husband to still love him. doesnt mean that shes weak by any means. and shes got the whole family behind her which surely makes her stronger.😉
cjs369 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

obviously in real life its always the other woman who is blamed for breaking the marriage ... but one never knows whats actually happening in their personal lives ...

as far A/J/G type situation in real life ...I wud definitely want to slap J for what he did ... this selfish selfcentered guy never gave a thought to anyone but himself ... he is not worth it at all ... such a person cannot be loyal and fair to anyone ... tomoro for some other selfish reasons he might decieve G too ...
Anandi shud move on with her life and never look back at J ...
as for G , she seems equally selfish and deserves J...I am sure life will teach her a lesson in future for what she did to another woman A ...
tiny15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
@ankit gud quesns!!i agree wid u that here fault lies only wid J &G & not a bit wid A. i completely agree wid u on all 3 ckt's analysis. A is behaving like any village gal wud've behaved though bcoz of her educn she sumtimes raise voice against sum evils like that "bal-vivah" of kids!!
and in this case its purely & clearly a case of adultery & selfishness!!
i agree G is not just selfish but need a psychatrist also!!even this thing'd happened in real life i wud've supported A type gal.
i know such a real life e.g of my frnd. this frnd of mine was muslim. h egot married 2 a Hindu gal & that gal sort of even got converted as they changed her name though he was liberal in many ways.later on they'd a son. after that i wasn't in mucgh contact wid him bcoz i got busy in my carrer but after 4-5 yrs.we once i called him his bro took the phone & told me that he got married 2 sum1else & again a hindu gal & also left the home. i was shocked 2 hear that how cum he do this 2 his 1st wife who left everything 4 him but cudn't ask him as i don't've his contact!! and i was really furious wid him. then one day on orkut i got his scrap but under sum hindu name so i think he might've created this ID 4 net only & called on the no. he'd given there. then he told me whole story that his 1st wife has done many bad things 2 him & isn't of gud nature or human being. though i asked him so many times but he didn't tell me.i asked him then why he married her at the 1st place wen he knew all this. he told me that sum lawyer'd told him 2get married 2 her oderwise he wud b booked under false rape case. but here also i fail 2 understand then how cum he put up wid his 1st wife 4 4-5 yrs.??and now his parents'd disowned him from their family & he himself got converted 2 hinduism!!i don't know the story of him & his 1st wife's divorce or life which made him do such things!!
though i'd told him that i"ll defntly ask him why he did this 2 his 1st wife. an di don't know that if his 2nd wife fall in luv or married him knowing hes married or after a rift occured btn him & his 1st wife then married him!!
he'd told me that his 1st wife isn't gud human being but still i can't trust him completely as i'd met her & only met bcoz of him only but i can't absolve of him of his faults or mistakes or sins!!i get clear pic of this only once wen i"ll meet him prsnlly & know both side's story. but till in my view he'd done a sin 2wards his 1st wife!!hes not ready 2 tell whole story 2 me atleast on phone!!
but in case of J &G where each & every thing is clear i will defntly put blame on J & G & more on J!!
sorry 4 such along post but cudn't resist 2 tell this a s its almost similar !! an dthanx 4 evey1 who'd read this & put up wid it!!😊😊
chulbuli7 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
In REAL Life, chances are that Jetsar villagers would have have first painted JaGa's face with Black paint (Just like they did to Phooli when she was caught writing romantic letters to herself), and then, given a ride on a Donkey, and finally, lifetime ban on entry in Jetsar.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".