how can the judges do that!!

hey

ok! im dunt watch this show but in one of the promos, they showed aadesh scolding a guy n saying do naav pe pau nahin rakte or sumthing like tht.....

then, i thought i would watch the epi...to see wht the case was...n when i saw it, i was utterly disgusted by aadesh's behaviour! jus because tht guy who sang jeene ke hai chaar din, was an engineer, he got mad n said .... then why do u sing?😕i mean, he dosent have the right to say tht!!! does this mean tht a person who wants to have a singing career, or a person who cums for their auditions....shld have no life but jus music n singing!!!!not even a degree...i mean, whts sooo bad if the guy is an engineer! this aadesh seems to have a problem with evrything!!! also, he told to him...ek kaam chal raha hai toh use chalne do...gaate kyun ho n tht kinda rubbish! i mean, cant he jus politely say that that guy shld go back to wht he was doing!!! but no! he has to give his expert advice n say dunt sing!!!

n then, the great aadesh says to tht guy "ye sangeet hai, mazaak nahin hai, ye tapasya hai"!!!! now wht is aadesh??? sum saint??? 😆 wht tapasya has he dun? 😆 lol! he thinks hes one of the greatest composers in the world!!! duh! apart from shava shava from k3g and bagban....hes done nothing tht he can be soooooo haughty about!

sorry if i hurt anyone...or nething....but i jus said tht the judges cant say comments like "dunt sing" "why do u sing if ur an engineer"....singing can be a passion for anyone...n they jus cant disrespect the people who wait for hours and perform for them...

i think these people r trying to attract audiences by such silly publicity gimmicks! its sooo bloody obvious tht the judgement is biased...n the aadesh tries too hard to look n act angry but it cums out to look soooo fake! u can tell hes acting and fibbing!!! lol....😆 😆😆 sumtimes he luks like hes copying anu malik from II...

newayz....hope he stops doing such silly stuff in the future and appereciates the abundant musical talent we have in our country...👏

I totally agree with you. Totally disgusting and uncalled for behaviour by Aadesh. Also it was not fair and really insulting to the singer in question.
I also didnt quite think much of Abhijeet's remarks to him and the way they cut him off.

Seriously...apart from Shaan as the host and Jatin-Lalit, I am not at all impressed with this show esp in terms of calibre and integrity.
My opinion...no offense meant.

yeah i second that too. what is he trying to say - that engineers and doctors should not sing?! it was totally uncalled for and ridiculous. I was pretty mad. Anywhoo, i think a show with the following would be niiice :::

Shaan as host ( although Aditya is really cute and doing well)

Mentors:
Vishal - Shekhar
Jatin - Lalit
Bappida (very very encouraging)
Ismail Darbar
Someone new ... A R Rahman maybe??

I only watch this show because some of the the singers are really really good. I especially liked the Sikh guy from Haryana. Excellent voice.

Some of these judges think that they can say anything and get away with it because they are in charge. I mean come on, for god's sakes, please show some respect and consideration for all those people who have come out to audition and have waited for hours just to sing about 4 lines from a song and you simply tell them...you are not the voice of india. Fine. But at least tell them politely rather than just rudely telling them off.

As for Aadesh's behaviour, it was totally uncalled for. The poor singer, who came to audition must have waited for hours in the heat and then the poor guy gets stage fright and asks for some time to recover. He gets his wish and then when he comes out to sing he sings jeene ke hai char din, Aadesh just cuts him off and asks him to sing a soft number. When he sings a soft number, he sounds totally different and Abhijeet tells him that he was looking for the audience's sympathy. Come on...!!!!

aadesh is newly crowned king of the world - don question his power 😆 😛

power or no power. His behaviuor is simply bullshit. Look at the judges on Indian Idol. All 4 get along so well and even if they tell the participants something, they tell them nicely. Right now without Anu Malik (Get well soon) all 3 are getting along so well.

Aadesh is an idiot and so is Abhijeet. In SRGMP Little champs, you should see how Abhijeet behaved with Bappida. He was so rude to him. Come on dude. Show some respect for god's sakes. Bappida is way older than you, way more experienced than you and has been singing since you were in diapers. So go get a f**king life.

smarie pants, I totally totally agree with you. 👏

Would have loved to read the same post with correct english (sum, dunt etc.,) I mean, I can see you know your english very well. Your grammer is right. I dont know about others, but to me its always a pleasure to read something in right english.
Its a different thing, if someone does not know english. But knowing and not wanting to type a few letters here and there is another thing. Does it save a lot of time, that people want to write that way ?

it is another drama. this abhijit n alka all the time fighting which bore me a lot. this is not the right age 4 tat. n coments of adesh n abhijot. how they stop people in middle of singing n start insulting people. it is not a fault to hav a dreem which later on drive people to go forward. their comments, behaviour nothing is constructive n goes against humanity. n wat a level of patient they hav. i think it is near abt 00.00009%

I think the Drama is too heavy for music lovers. Gajji please do something

Originally posted by: Nilsat

I think the Drama is too heavy for music lovers. Gajji please do something

i think gajji is very pleased himself right now what with his show starting on 18th may bringing down the trps of a powerful franchise music show from 2.7 to 2.1.and the other front runner from a trp of 4 to 3.4 in just a week(ending 25th may-source indian television .com)
SVOI jumped from a dismal 2.1 to 2.6 . in second position and it is only in its audition rounds...i am waiting for the june1-2 delhi ratings..i think it will be very interesting!i see the gap closing very soon(4 : 2.1 then 3.4 : 2.6....)