Originally posted by: PreRish-Kabir
I mean maybe so but the message on the poll is factual its literally what's shown in the show, so the message isn't anything incorrect and at this point this knowledge needs to be attributed to this whole discussion because why should Akshara go back to Abhimanyu, especially after what he's done and continues to do.
Also Akshnav only exists due to what Abhimanyu did that day and if we do a poll in an unbiased way forgetting the sins of Abhimanyu and Abhinav's good deeds then Akshnav literally has nothing to go off of, there would be no reason for them to really be together as they would not have any story, this poll is about the story and should Akshara stay with Abhinav or go back to Abhimanyu and hence a little backstory is required to judge it in accordance to how the audience want the story to go based on the past.
Originally posted by: umawanderer
I understand... And I am happy to see that many people want the story to go in a non-toxic direction.. Was not a YRKKH3 fan let alone Abhira fan..
But.. These are facts.. but there are other facts like he was willing to abort the kids if Ak was put in any danger.. etc..
It's just these facts were not necessary.. A simple question would have been nice.
Or they could have put all the facts.. as some facts have a partial narrative problem.
P.s Not defending Abhomayu.. just was not happy with the poll question.. loved poll result.
EDIT: I am editing this in as I cannot post it in regards to Uma's previous post due to the newbie post limit:
Sure Abhimanyu has done some good things and should be commended for them, but hes done more harm in my opinion. I personally don't think the question affects much as the poll didn't go into detail about what happened and is a very loose interpretation of what happened that day, what happened was far worse and is undefendable. I also feel that you see a true persons colour when you face tough times together, do they run? stay and fight with you? or blame you? 3 very important things happened on white day that makes Abhimanyu Birla undefendable to me.
1. Akshara lost one of her children trying to save Neil and believed she lost both and was under extreme stress and sadness due to the miscarriage.
2. Abhimanyu blamed her for not only Neil but the kids death (the very kids he was willing to abort if something happened to Akshara) and this could've been forgiven had he apologised, maybe not even as quick as Abhinav but apologise no matter how long it takes and he still hasn't apologised to her directly yet.
3. Abhimanyu blamed Akshara for Sirat's death. This for me is also another reason why I can't defend any of Abhimanyu's actions. Sirat dying had affected Akshara extremely badly, and for Abhimanyu to weaponise something that had affected her so deeply against her after she miscarried is vile.
Sure you can remember Abhimanyu's good things but in comparison to the good he has done, he also did something far worse that counters all the good he has done and I know you are not defending Abhimanyu, I'm just stating my thought process on why the background knowledge is fine.
Edited by PreRish-Kabir - 2 years ago
10