Raman's guilt and Ishita's losing hope...*UPDATED* - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

140

Views

18.6k

Users

46

Likes

1k

Frequent Posters

nb.neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#31
I m yet to watch the episode. But I can see whats in store.
This is pathetic. After humiliation, slaps, getting thrown out shagun still has the power to reign. She still has the power to make an entire family of educated professionals dance on her tunes. She has no home, no job, no character yet she is easily destroying lives of others.

She surely isn't a mother. A mother doesn't trade her child to take some sort of revenge.
-kri- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: Wings-of-Fire



You misunderstood me! I wasn't saying that you were using the word logic or calling Ishita unrealistic. I was saying that what you think is her mistake- she has absolutely no clue about that. She has no clue about anything that's going around her or anything that's coming out of her mouth!

Ishita should acknowledge Raman's importance in her life irrespective of Ruhi- this is a logical statement, won't you agree? What I was trying to say is, right now, she doesn't get that. She doesn't get anything except the fact that she's about to lose her kid. And I'd disagree with you once again on calling this attachment unhealthy- it's not. If it is, then every mother child relationship is!

Yes, Ishita is a strong woman! In fact the stronger one between the husband wife duo- but even Superman has his vulnerability. Ruhi is Ishita's Kryptonite!


Yes, Ishita is not at fault but mistake is a mistake. When Ishita starts understanding the situation, she'll be a different person and i'm waiting for that person.

I think the way we look at love is different. I always see it as one's strength... When it is becoming weakness, i am seeing it from different perspect... Nothing else...

I'm waiting for strong Ishita yaar...
nb.neha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#33
For all the times Raman has shouted at ishita, yelled at her, blamed her ishita was not at fault. She was blamed for no fault of hers.
Today if ishita is blaming him, yelling at him then she has a solid reason. She does has.

I hope this drama doesn't gets dragged for an indefinite period now.

I don't feel like watching it. What compells me to watch is performances of the actors.
Edited by nb.neha - 10 years ago
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#34
post updated...I was allover the place..
baarish27 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#35
Too many emotions were running.. seeing Ishita even I felt helpless.. Her each word was justified.. N when she say to Mihika why r u talking as if giving condolence ..n she says to every one soo jao ..every thing is f9..was soo touching ..my whole family had tears in their eyes..could feel aashu ka rishta hai...😭😭
shadeslayer thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#36
Res.
Gan, the first and the last collage broke my heart. The pain of a Father and the pain of a Mother- breaks my heart.
Back after I watch the Epi.

Edited---------------------------------------------------------------------------

It was too emotional for me. So I will just say the few things that i loved about the epi- If I go to analyze anathing- I might start bawling again- and I need to get back to my studies.

- Ishita and Raman's feelings were soo Raw- so real- once again- Hats off to the actors for a convincing portrayal of two distraught parents.

- Ruhi's innocence- The Ruman moment- took my breath away. It reminded me of one of my fav scenes of this show- The one where little Ruhi goes and tells "Dhule Uncle" not to marry her Ishita Aunty and take her away from her. Dunno why- It just did.

- Ishita's reaction to Raman- Expected- who else is the distraught mother who is about to lose it all blame. And as far as her words- "Ruhi hai toh hum hai" are concerned- The way I saw it- She just reminded him that they came to be coz of Ruhi- which is nothing but the fact. Bas.

- Ishita's tears and the Flashbacks- Too many feels. Can't say no more lest I lose it.

Last but not the least- Shagun- A heartless mother who is ready to destroy the happiness and peace of mind of BOTH the children she is sooo proud to have borne- for a petty thing like Revenge. Do i consider her a Mother? No- She does not have one maternal bone in her body.

P.S- Loved the use of the other cast members- Especially Bala, Vandu, mihir and Mihika. Reminded me of my good old Vintage YHM. #Buckle Up guys #This Is going to Be a Bumpy ride #We are with you Puttar and Missus


Edited by shadeslayer - 10 years ago
Anuhyaa thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#37
Raman holding Ruhi and realizing the depth of his mistake is so beautifully done. No one can beat Karan in those scenes. I don't know how he does that but he cries differently for different scenarios...

Unexpected, but Mihika and Vandu's scene brought tears to my eyes ...Somehow I connected with the sisters anguish there , and when Ishita went to Shagun and when she spoke about Ruhi she completely undid me...

Today Ishita was borderline psychotic and she lashed out on everyone and everything.And she also became Raman in her anger and grief, she hurt the one person she loves most.
But in any of the scenes I didn't find her overboard , I found her reactions, feelings and emotions to be so real.
And at the end when she was in denial and lashed out on all of them, I felt sorry for them all...In a way all are hurting but all of them put aside their pain and where thinking about Ishita...they all became Ishita there ...
and her every action and every word increased Raman's grief...and to shoulder it all alone is even more painful...

I liked the fact that Bala in yesterday's episode and Vandu in today's were acting maturely and trying to find some real solutions...

I dont know where they are taking this but I just want them to keep the episodes realistic ...
remya1990 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#38
Gan, beautiful, heart touching and emotional collage.
The episode was a power packed one with showing the differences of the two mothers at its heights.
Who is the real mother is never a question here. It comes up when Shagun utters it. But it makes that woman more disgusting.
At one end a mother was begging for her child. At the other end a woman was making the worse of her children to make herself safe, herself important, herself predominant.
Ishita was shattered to know that she was going to lose her child. She was in a trance...don't know what to say, what to do. The very first time she knew about it, she knelt down before Shagun. That's what a true mother does...the ego, the self respect...every thing she gave away. She stood bare in front of Shagun.

Shagun on the other hand, never dropped a tear, when she was losing her child at the court twice before. Even now,losing Adi is nothing to her, more than that, getting Ruhi matters. She now very well know that with Adi or without Adi, the relational status of Ishita and Raman are same. It can't make any more differences. So she tried on Ruhi. The epitome of the relation of Raman and Ishita, precisely marriage. She very well know the crisis would arise and Ishita would do anything for Ruhi...anything. And that made her not to tell that if you give Adi to me, may Ruhi be with you. If she wanted her beloved son to her as she claims, she can easily solve it. she can tell them no to ask for Adi anymore, if so, you should give Ruhi. But she has herself planned everything in taking Ruhi, and bestowing Adi to them. She without a tinge of sadness, is ready to give a son...the only person on earth (apart from her mother) who loves her unconditionally...who has never left her alone, who fought for her.
To revenge upon a woman, who claims herself a mother to her daughter, who loves her daughter unconditionally...she is simply letting go of the loving child of her.
On the other hand a mother, who is mad at every thing knowing she is going to lose her child, never tells that take Adi, we don't need Adi and will never ask for, we need only Ruhi...the love of her life. Because she know the pain of children. She know the result of being abandoned. She knows what a child needs. She is the true mother to the children. She here needs both of them...to love them, to nurture them. But, she can't afford to lose one for the other.
As per Shagun is concerned, she thinks that if Adi is with her, Raman would beg...will give every thing ...and if Ruhi is with her, she can undoubtedly bring Ishita to her knees. And she has succeeded in it. She then laid out a condition of exchanging... A mother who knew her husband's son does not love do not approve for this. She needs both the children. A true mother at heart.
We know, now she can become a mother...her husband gifted her the reports in their anniversary... Shagun asked her to make a child of her own if she needs, knowing that she can't. Did that question changed her attitude...No. She tore away the papers sitting beside her husband...she tore away her in born ability. A true mother at heart. A mother, who has 10 children will always yearn and cry for the lost child. If she has everything in the world...still...she will yearn for the lost child.

I wonder if Shagun knew that Ishita can become a mother, she would not have dared to take this step.
Regarding Ishita's reaction to Raman, its up to the mark. Its no about questioning their relationship. It about telling him that he is the cause of losing her. For her family everything is perfect with three of them. She was the one who became a wife because she wanted to be a mother to Ruhi. If she was the biological mother of Ruhi, and something happens because of Raman, she will definitely split out those words again. Every mother would, i guess. Its not about blaming, its not about avoiding , its not about misunderstanding, its not about the value of one person or the other...its just the fear of losing a perfect family...which she has created...its the fear of losing all the happiness that holds you to together. She yelled at him as a wife and mother, to her husband and father of their child.

"A mother's love for a child is like nothing else in the world.
It knows no pity.It dares all things and crushes down remorselessly
all that stands in its path."
Agatha Christie.
This is the case with Ishita.
Regarding the onscreen, Divyanka was to the T. How can a woman act like that...that too not being a mother...ohh I wonder. I love her more for this. And KP, as you said, having barely any dialogue, he was excellent in his work. And Ruhi...wow !!!

I don't know Gan, How much right I have written.
Its again a rambling after drenching in to a wonderful,emotional and heart drenching episode.
Once again, am in love with your collages Gan.


Edited by remya1990 - 10 years ago
RaimaV thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#39
I wonder if she would have said same things to Subbu! No married woman tells her husband that their relationship exists because of their child! It's completely news to me! Ishita in a way justified Subbu's stance-- you need a child to love your spouse!
Dmug thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#40
Res yet to watch the episode will unres later!! The emotional ride continues!! And we r surely gonna gwt drenched!! Lovely collages Gan!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".