Silver Lining in a Cloud

btalwar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Hello All 🤗... I see that soon the forum is going to drown in the flood of sadness due to recent upturn of events or rather the lacks of any events in Ishraland. So, the eternal romantic in me decided to act optimist and look for the silver lining in a cloud 😳.

To begin with, I will like to revisit YHM from the beginning and start with the character sketch of Ishita and Raman, followed by their misconceptions about each other.

Ishita: A strong independent woman who has faced a bitter heartbreak and yearns for companionship at heart.

Raman: A victim of adultery in marriage, who has long ago accepted defeat from his lonely heart and is a ghost of his real self. A self proclaimed loner and a woman hater who has shunned every relation in his life including relationship with his innerself.

Misconceptions of Raman about Ishita

Raman initially perceived Ishita to be a gold digger who was using his daughter as a baton to get into his life and eventually dig a hole in his deep pockets. Later on, he also mocked her as a desperate woman who wanted to fulfill her yearning for a child by snatching away his daughter from her. Even after they got married, the misunderstandings galore continued and Raman continuously blamed her time and again about being the reason for the rift between father daughter duo.

He clearly had trust issues with his woman. While, his anger during the land deal was a first glimpse of it, his questions about their non-existent relationship in front of the entire family during Param fiasco was a clear proof.

The trust issues clearly continued during Amma accident track as inspite of his sane mind reminding him day in and out to tell the truth to his wife, he purposefully withheld it.

Misconceptions of Ishita about Raman

Ishita initially perceived Raman to be an irresponsible father who thought that every problem in the world could be solved by money. Further misunderstandings between them led her to believe that he is an MCP who does not respect women rather any relationship for that matter. He is an insensitive prick who can stoop to any level to gain what he wants.

Ishita also had trust issues with her man. The very fact that she was reluctant to share her plight when Param abused her with him was the biggest example. When she figured out that Simmi was staying with her husband in Delhi itself, she took the matters in her hand and never thought of sharing this problem with Raman.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In short, both of them have opened a huge Pandora box of misunderstandings and trust issues.

Let me bring their exact ante-thesis into the picture .. Vandu and Bala. The normal couple, who talk, love, fight, live, communicate together and most of all trust each other. Vandu sharing her apprehension of pregnancy and Bala sharing his apprehension of the additional financial burden with Mihika's marriage are subtle yet big examples of normalcy.

So, how do the CV's make this eccentric non-trusting couple of Ishita and Raman into a normal trusting couple like Vandu and Bala.

The only feasible option is to close each and every issue one by one until there is nothing left between them to create any more rift and love can finally blossom.

The CV's have been intelligently closing each and every issue by giving beautiful subtle examples. Let me quote some issues which have been beautifully closed:


1. Gold Digger Ishita: While Shagun settled only for a 5 carat ring, Ishita was happy with the small ring crafted by Ruhi. Recently, Ishita settled for a cheaper saree because she felt that the designer one is too expensive.

2. Ishita using Ruhi to satisfy her yearning for a child: Time and again, it has been shown that although Ruhi completes Ishita's life, she has much more to offer in return. She brought the father daughter duo together and is a major reason for a stable and grounded parenting to the child.

4. Ishita trying to create a rift between father and daughter: This has been dealt many a times, few instances being, Ishita made Ruhi praise her father in school, Ishita made sure that the relationship between the father and daughter duo was never affected despite their misunderstandings during Param fiasco and later on during Amma accident when Raman was favoring Shagun.

4. Raman, the irresponsible and insensetive father: Raman has come a long way from being an apprehensive parent to a sensitive father. The same Raman who was reluctant to hug his daughter passed his daughter's trust test with flying colors.

5. Raman, the heartless man who vouched that everything can be bought from money: The raw side of Raman, who went to any means so that his son accepted him as a father is enough proof for Ishita to break her myth that Raman Kumar Bhalla can get whatever he wants from his money.

6. Raman, the Insensitive prick: This part was dealt most beautifully. Small hints like Raman's sensitivity towards the culture of his in laws, his respect for them was a beautiful and subtle proof of RKB with a heart. The biggest example yet again is his children and his yearning for them.

Phew ... so all the issues mentioned above have been sorted out from the Pandora Box. If you notice, there is just one issue which is left and is common for both of them. Trust.

Before some of you begin to ask, trust has been established between them ... examples like Raman finally admitting the truth about Adi in front of Ishita, Ishita opening up about Subbu for the first time with Raman, Ishita and Raman coming up together to sort out Param's issue and so on and so forth, however, let us pause for a while.

I agree, all the issues mentioned above do ensure trust, however, please notice that this newly formed trust is displayed only inside the confined spaces of their bedroom ... does anyone else apart from them knows about this changed equation?

Remember Raman trying to get cozy with Ishita in Holi to show off to Shagun or calling Ishita in the night from Mumbai. All this was a fiasco to show off his better life to Shagun.

When Param had mocked Ishita about their non existent relationship between them, instead of countering Param on the face, Raman had questioned Ishita in front of the whole family. He had clearly stepped out of the "Inside the Bedroom" limits of this relationship.

How do CV's close the biggest pending issue from the Pandora Box?

Bang on .. the master plan of CVs.

Let us now go back to the scene between Ishita and Param where she went to meet him and invite him back to Bhalla house. Param openly mocked her relationship with Raman and infarct actually demeaned her that she can never be good enough for Raman. He mocked about their "Inside Bedroom" equation.

Quoting Shagun's incident, When Ishita went to confront Shagun for Ruhi's abortion issue, Shagun had yet again mocked her and treated her as AAYA of her children; someone who means nothing to Raman. Yet again, "Inside Bedroom" equation.

Masterstroke.

Now, let me come to the actual reference of the silver lining. Both Param and Shagun have been living in the misconception that Raman and Ishita are two disjointed souls who are there in a marriage of convenience for the sake of Ruhi; what they are absolutely not prepared for is the fact, that these two souls have unknowingly bound to each other and are no more two but one single strong soul ready to fight any evil.

So, against the popular wave, I for once want Ishita to fall into the trap of Param. Param will apply his usual tactics to demean Ishita and expect the same show of annoyance and disinterest from Raman.

However, am sure, this time what he will get is a husband fighting for a wife ... and though Raman will be angry from Ishita .. it will be out of worry and not out of mistrust ... and that will be a big jerk to Param.

Shagun ... apply the same logic here ... Raman does not need to force Ishita into anything or get cozy with her to show to Shagun that he has accepted Ishita has Mrs. Raman Kumar Bhalla, his gestures, his talks, his eyes will be a give away, so if Shagun enters Bhalla house, she will be in for a real shock to know that Ishita is no longer the AAYA of her children, but the wife of her ex-husband as well.

Both these issues will close out the biggest and last issue between them and of course shut everyone's mouth. Trust in front of others. What goes inside the bedroom stays inside and is no more an exhibition for others, and anyone who tries to enter this No Entry zone will find two joined hands ready to fight against this evil.

Leaving you all with the quote which actually made me think about this piece.

"To be trusted is a greater compliment than begin loved."

cheers

Bhanu.
Edited by btalwar - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

4.1k

Users

17

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

_Dipsi_ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Lovely Bhanu... i am sure getting Param back and now with sbs update on Shagun returing to The Bhalla house there is bound to be some drama...some tearjerking episodes ahead...some Mu's etc etc
i really hope that Cvs handle things in a matured way n showed us that Ishra relation though not yet physical but there is definetly a emotional bonding between them
Colt.Pixy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
superb post bhanu. I don;'t have problem with shagun and param but for perv entry ishita s character is ruined with chhee on T, and we have got least ishra scenes with pathetic editing that s main problem
Veeann thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Very well analyzed Bhanu.
I love your optimism and the way you have analyzed every strand of the complex Web that is Ishra.

True, this Web is very entangled. and unraveling it will be neither easy nor a job for the fainthearted. But then our Ishra are fearless and will fight as intensely to be together as they did to stay apart. Can't wait for that to happen, lekin yeh intezaar bahut mushkil hai.

Thank you for reminding us of the bigger picture here. Much needed dose of optimism.

As my hero would say- "Picture abhi baaki hai mere dost."
Thank you Bhanu👏
-RisingAsh- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
OMG ! Bhanu amazing post n very beautifully written ! I loved the way u proceeded things... Start frm the beg, the small yet enouf analysis of their characters n then their misconception abt each other..tht being handled so beautifully till nw..
I agree they hav to do sm more to boost up the trust they hav for each other..

Superb post once again! :)
Lata_ishra thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Amazing post Bhanu...😊
its true all the misunderstanding has been cleared between them but only trust is there so i guess this track is for that then we can see realization in them about their love for each other...i had positive thoughts from starting of the track but only annoying thing is less ishra scenes...but thats ok if we get gud output from this track then i will tolerate this as well..
btalwar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: _Dipsi_

Lovely Bhanu... i am sure getting Param back and now with sbs update on Shagun returing to The Bhalla house there is bound to be some drama...some tearjerking episodes ahead...some Mu's etc etc

i really hope that Cvs handle things in a matured way n showed us that Ishra relation though not yet physical but there is definetly a emotional bonding between them



Yup, I at least have high hopes for this track despite the lack of Ishra scenes for a while ... I think CV's will make up for them later on.
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Superlative Post Bhanu ...
I agree everything has to be resolved between the 2 for their relation to progress ... Just for the sake of discussion ...

On the trust issue .. heres a thot ... param accused Ishita of trapping him .. he showed conclusive proof that of SMS'es from her phone to prove that Ishita was the one coming on to him ... then he also had an insight on the marriage equation of Raman & Ishtia which was ONLY BETWEEN THE TWO of them
Now if u visit the scene when Ishita is asked to leave the house .. SHE LOOKS BACK AT RAMAN .. she wanted him to stand up for her .. in her mind .. she knew RAMAN knew she was INNOCENT .. even when everything pointed against her ...

( digressing a bit .. but this look back of Ishita's i have always believed thats the look he described when he spoke of Sonali Kotnis .. the big eyes . the tears , the long flowing hair .. the eyes which entreated support & the eyes which showed him how much she felt for him)


Similarly the very next morning .. raman walked up to Ishita at her place & left his daughter with her .. signalling very clearly that he was with ISHITA ... this was BIG from a man who detested adultery & was a victim of it .. he fought tooth & nail not to loose Ruhi to Shagun as she was an adulterer ...
He goes out of his way to prove Ishita innocent .. & does it with elan ...

Now lets look at Ishita .. according to her during the accident track Raman was "in love with Shagun"which was prompting him to take her side ... even after all this .. she stands in court & asks her lawyer not to question him .. as she knew he was not with Shagun ... there was complete trust that the man will not cheat on her .. but he according to her .. he was fighting a loosing battle with his heart ... note all the instances when she is confused about the fact that why Raman was still so in love with Shagun ..
During the accident track note the no of times Raman wants to tell Ishita the truth ..his drunken bout .. all alluded to the fact that he wanted to tell her .. he was given a swear by Shagun on Adi .. but he broke that swear .. the moment he felt his swear to protect Adi was actually harming him & the first thing he did was run to Ishita to spill the beans ... Trust was what he had when he told her U r the only one to HELP ME .. be my strength ..

IMHO Trust between the two was established a while back ... the problem is they are not able to LET GO OFF THEIR PAST BAGGAGE ... he does not trust himself in LOVE ... & she considers herself HALF A WOMAN NOT WORTHY OF LOVE ...

The "chee" ( while i have lambasted it a million times ) if u delve into it its clear ... a woman who considers herself half a woman ... is always scared of Physical Intimacy ... she will always hesitate to come close physically .. since physically she feels she is NOT COMPLETE ... physical intimacy will be the biggest barrier Raman will have to break to become one with Ishita ...

If u see the scene with Ruhi when she asks them about how babies come .. Ishita's reaction is SAD .. she is sadened that she will never be able to give Raman a kid ... but Raman is shy & embarrassed since their relation had not progressed there .. their reactions were completely diametrically opposite to the other ...

Their problem is crossed wires ... hence the writers always show them working in silos ...they need to get their wires joined ... The param track .. this is the first time they are working together .. even though it started with her moving without his knowledge .. but at least they are working together .. thats how this track is important to the romance track ...

This track .. which we fondly call the Romance track ... romance for these two is over coming their past inhibitions .. letting go of their baggage .. the moment they do that .. they will be able to accept each other fully ...

Edited by redwine1 - 11 years ago
btalwar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Colt.Pixy

superb post bhanu. I don;'t have problem with shagun and param but for perv entry ishita s character is ruined with chhee on T, and we have got least ishra scenes with pathetic editing that s main problem



Zeno ... all I can say is, life is always not black and white. It is sometimes grey as well. I said it in LU yesterday that Ishita Param war reminds me of a saas bahu planning and plotting, however, the bigger picture is something different. I think that all these mini tracks are infact paving a way for something big ... at least I want to think it this way.

It is true that Ishita is a JKR and an intelligent woman. While, I was pretty vocal about my dismay over Ishita's decision to meet the same man who almost raped in the middle of the night in a deserted street, I somehow still agree with her decision.
When you live in a family, you sometimes accept certain things with a pinch of salt. That is how life is. Param is that extra pinch and he had to somehow come into the family. Even if he is unmasked and removed from Simmi's life in future, he will still be the biological father of Ananya, just like Shagun is to Adi and Ruhi. So, you cannot remove him at all. The best way is to tackle him. I think the CV's need to concentrate on the treatment pretty soon.



kumi007 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Very well said.. 👏👏 Happy after reading this and waiting for the silver lining.. 😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".