Sonu & SLB need to get their ears checked

I hate it when they are constantly putting down Geet and Amit. I was so glad to see Shreya standing up to them today.

Geet was way better than SLB's Nimriti who murdered the classic Sawan ka mahina yesterday, Deewana wo murdered Dil kya kare today and Sajda matas who screamed and screeched Bahan ke darmiyan and Suno sajna.

Geet was also better than Sahiti who murdered both Lata numbers this weekend.

I have just had it with these two high and mighty arrogant judges

Ya actually Geet & Amit are good singers. They too make mistakes but why do Sonu & SLB have to be soo critical more towards them. Why cant they be critical ever to the nirmitee group & deewana group also?

If Sonu & SLB needs ears cleaned than so does Shreya.

Nice topic, good for reflecting on attitudes of the people 😆👏

i dont think its abt any one judge being too critical at all...anyways i find most of the singers avg to above avg on X factor ...

I do feel judges (specially Sonu) are quite harsh towards Amit as well as Geet. Amit's saturdays performance was really good but Sonu praised him at the same time he pointed out alot of critical points, but with Deewana group or say Nirmitee & all he doesnt come up with soo much criticism no matter how bad their song goes.

I disagree about Shreya, in fact she gets up and shows a lot of verbal praise for other judge's contestants a lot. Even when Sahiti messed up lines during the faceoff, Shreya supported her. I have very rarely seen Shreya giving any bad comments. Sonu and SLB go to the extent of being RUDE.

I don't like geet that much sorry, I think Sonuji is right. Amit has a nice voice, but I feel he is holding back. he is losing his charm. Sherya needs to pick better songs for him. If he sang sonyie from that chocolate movie and danced, it would rock!

Honeslty, the singers of this show are okay, sherya has the weakest team I'm sorry to say. Amit is her best and he hasn't shown his full potential yet. Sonu has Seema who is fantastic, Shaiti is okay. SLB has the best team. Nimiritee is his best followed closely by dewanna group. Sadja sisters are his weakest but far from the weakest on the show.

IMO the true stars of this show are Nimiritee, Dewanna( they had a bad day but they still are amazing) and Seema.

I guess we ll have our opinions. To me, X factor is more than just singing. It includes performance, personality, entertaining, stage presence etc etc. Geet may an ok to good singer (I don't think he is as bad as he is made out to be) but he has personality, stage presence, charisma and does perform well on the stage. His singing is also getting better. Nirmitee, Deewana, Piyush and Amit also have that.

Seema has the best singing talent but is just okay in other areas. Sahiti and Sajda sisters are overrated. They are not consistant in their singing (they scream more than sing) and lack a lot of other things I mentioned above.

Kartar uncle is a totally different ball game.

Again, the point of this thread was on how judges behave. I think that now matter how great they are as far as talent is concerned, they have no right to be rude and I find SLB and Sonu do that often.

For example, when Sonu & Shreya picked Amit after the faceoff, SLB's outburst was simply rude especially when he did worst while excusing Sahiti's performance during her faceoff with Shuvon and picking her.

Sonu also has attutude problems they way he speaks to Amit and Geet or even Seema when he was trying to force her to sing a song she was not comfortable. Like he said "nahin kar sakti to jao, out ho jao" I remember years back on an award function, Sonu had given a lengthy speech on how his talent was ignored by the industry for so long and how badly he was treated. For a man who was hurt on how he was treated, he sure seems to have forgetten his early days

Originally posted by: suresh555

I guess we ll have our opinions. To me, X factor is more than just singing. It includes performance, personality, entertaining, stage presence etc etc. Geet may an ok to good singer (I don't think he is as bad as he is made out to be) but he has personality, stage presence, charisma and does perform well on the stage. His singing is also getting better. Nirmitee, Deewana, Piyush and Amit also have that.

Seema has the best singing talent but is just okay in other areas. Sahiti and Sajda sisters are overrated. They are not consistant in their singing (they scream more than sing) and lack a lot of other things I mentioned above.

Kartar uncle is a totally different ball game.

Again, the point of this thread was on how judges behave. I think that now matter how great they are as far as talent is concerned, they have no right to be rude and I find SLB and Sonu do that often.

For example, when Sonu & Shreya picked Amit after the faceoff, SLB's outburst was simply rude especially when he did worst while excusing Sahiti's performance during her faceoff with Shuvon and picking her.

Sonu also has attutude problems they way he speaks to Amit and Geet or even Seema when he was trying to force her to sing a song she was not comfortable. Like he said "nahin kar sakti to jao, out ho jao" I remember years back on an award function, Sonu had given a lengthy speech on how his talent was ignored by the industry for so long and how badly he was treated. For a man who was hurt on how he was treated, he sure seems to have forgetten his early days

I agree Geet is not as bad as he is made out to be and seema needs more stage presence. Seema however is still fine without it cause her voice is just to amazing, but I agree, I can't watch her again and again like I can with Nirmitee. But you are right, I don't think SLB and Sonu need to get their ears checked. Most of the time Sonu is right on the money. But yes they are rude, esp Sonu. He has an attitude problem.

SLB is usually nice but I think his outburst is more TRP thing. I give props to sherya for maintaining a positive attitude. I think SLB was annoyed that in his opinion, not mine a worthy singer was outed over geet and amit. Sonu is just rude cause he has high standards.