death of tragic hero karna - Page 6

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Did you even read the citation mate?, please read the underined the part, Bhima broke their body parts when they were children

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@The Watcher - Again citation, would a different translation and version be ever considered or just one book holds the testimony of truth.

Draupadi never forgave her husbands too, she made them and taunted them endlessly. They had to fight her honor like Bhim to redeem somewhat for their silence. But did Karna make upto her ever? His dialogue to Kanha in your book too doesn't matter simply because it was not directed to the right person.

Nobody takes away from the glory of Karna even if we disagree of his portrayal.

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

Draupadi forgave her husbands because they were their husbands, those times were not the times when a Lady can leave her husbands. Epic's Draupadi would have no way forgave Karna and Duryodhana, she was fiery and not a delicate darling as shown in Star plus' Mahabharata

Karna did repetnt, the citation provided by Ritika (riti4u) confirms it.

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@The watcher - I did read your citation - like I said should be take one book as the end all? But then you won't buy my citations would you?

Hence I asked if logically you see it fit that 1 Bhim could have bullied 100 other kids ?

Still if he was bully , he was very wrong, his guru , Hastinapur King and mother should have been reported , yet there were many forms of punishment , killing him in such a manner is not one of them .

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

When a logic can say Draupadi and his brother came out of the fire, 5 god came to bless Kunti for a child, endless saree can appear, why not Bhima bully 100 children of Gandhari, he was the son of the wind god, when he was granted to Kunti - she dropped the infant Bhima from a cliff and Bhima broke a stone when he fell.

So yes, Bhima bullying 99 Duryodhan's brothers is very much possible. As I already said - please provide citation from whichever translation you like, but be sure that it is translation and not a retelling.

Have I asked or presented the above stated examples like Draupadi as counter points. but for citation I recommend you read C raja Gopalachari - he is eminent enough to be recognized as a serious author and please feel free to disagree as well because unlike you I don't hold these words as the sermons of truth.

In the end the kid Duryi with his brothers were able to better Bhim right, the son of Wind? But why plot to murder him, why not just let him suffer and be fearful? Was Duri not motivated to kill him so that he can best Yudi and Arjun and claim himself as Crown Prince? Did they not bully Yudhister , Nakul and Sahdev, could Bhim's behavior not be a revolt against the treatment his brothers were getting from kauravas. ( read C G Rajagopalachari ).

Rest This is Karna's thread. Lets continue with his story instead.

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

When a logic can say Draupadi and his brother came out of the fire, 5 god came to bless Kunti for a child, endless saree can appear, why not Bhima bully 100 children of Gandhari, he was the son of the wind god, when he was granted to Kunti - she dropped the infant Bhima from a cliff and Bhima broke a stone when he fell.

So yes, Bhima bullying 99 Duryodhan's brothers is very much possible. As I already said - please provide citation from whichever translation you like, but be sure that it is translation and not a retelling.