Jyoti is right this time ?????????

plz post ur views jyoti is right to take decision to donate her kidney without consult to anybody........its a big decision not a game........If her father in law scold her ....is Manshookh is wrong .......

i think Manshookh is not wrong....... i mean jyoti is not wrong that she wants to give her kidney to her father .......wrong thing she didnt tell to her elders.....

our life is not completely ours . .........all the family members are related to each other.......

what u guys think.........

i think that joyti was right...i think she is only obligated to consult her husband...all other rishtey are secondary. a father-in-law should not have the right to control the women of the house and the decisions they make

i dont agree w/u..yes its related to our fam..buh der r some decisions we shud take by ourselvesz..ya i do think alil too modern buh u cant rely on ur fam all ur life..n abt da donate thing jyoti did..SHES DOING DIZ FOR HER DAD...i mean da person who brought her into diz world..wudnt u do dat for ur dad or mom..i mean i wud defi..buh if ud ont den dats jus sad ..buh ya its a big decision buh for dat u gotta have a big heart..n trust me any kid wud do dat for der parents..

i am happy that she is talking action this time..

Originally posted by: friendlytina10

plz post ur views jyoti is right to take decision to donate her kidney without consult to anybody........its a big decision not a game........If her father in law scold her ....is Manshookh is wrong .......

i think Manshookh is not wrong....... i mean jyoti is not wrong that she wants to give her kidney to her father .......wrong thing she didnt tell to her elders.....

our life is not completely ours . .........all the family members are related to each other.......

what u guys think.........

"think Manshookh is not wrong " i think most of the time in the show he is doing some thing wrong.. he never throuhg that if it was him on the bed his sons' would do the same thing.. they won't wait for days and days to get his approval from anybody etc. beside his view on women is really bad i am shocked to see these kind of people live in this world. he is so unfare and he think he is the god and everyone has to fallow as he says... he never think he make misktaes etc. he is not god ... after all because of him every one is changed now.. when he is not at home everyone is happy at home when he comes home everything changes.. i mean its like havinga devil living in your home or living in a cell that guard is coming for a duity no masti or enjoyment.

Originally posted by: adnanFarz

i think that joyti was right...i think she is only obligated to consult her husband...all other rishtey are secondary. a father-in-law should not have the right to control the women of the house and the decisions they make

1000000% agree w/u there

Well Jyo did ask permission from every possible person. She ran door to door with her plea and no one listened. She wanted to save her father. Is that wrong ? Do u need permission to save the person who gave life to you ?

Originally posted by: aNsHu_tEjPaL

1000000% agree w/u there

totally agree...i'm not sure wht i would do in this situation and wht is the right thing to do..but wht mansuk is doing is wrong...i disagree with the fact that he has to control every single thing and women are treated like servents of some sort....someone should slap him out of it...

Originally posted by: adnanFarz

i think that joyti was right...i think she is only obligated to consult her husband...all other rishtey are secondary. a father-in-law should not have the right to control the women of the house and the decisions they make

exactly all ristey are secondry ......but father in law relation doesnt come in secondry.......

it is correct that fathewr in law should nt have the right to controlthe women of the house the decision they make........but this decision is not mazak.....atleast we should tell only m not talking abt asking........

the way of manshookh was wrong to stop Jyoti.......bcoz father is more imp for jyoti this time.....

i dont want to say .....that jyoti was wrong ...i want to say.......atleast if u take final decision atleast we should tell to ours elder......first of all even she didnt ask to her husband ........

she took very strong decision everybody can not take like jyoti character.........

jyoti was 100 % right for her decision :

one question if father in law is in place of jyoti's father n bahu will take decision to donate her kidney.....

we should nt tell to even our father n mother.......?????????

is it possible .

Originally posted by: friendlytina10

i think Manshookh is not wrong....... i mean jyoti is not wrong that she wants to give her kidney to her father .......wrong thing she didnt tell to her elders.....

our life is not completely ours . .........all the family members are related to each other.......

what u guys think.........

but wht would hve happened if she would hve told...they would hve said no anyway