SwaSan TS: Music of the Soul-The Agony & the Ecstasy-Completed - Page 21

Created

Last reply

Replies

476

Views

28.6k

Users

81

Likes

653

Frequent Posters

Cogito_Ergo_Sum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ishanita

that was a treat to read
loved it to d core
tnx for pm
ishanita


Thanks a lot, Ishanita. 🤗 Glad you liked it.
Cogito_Ergo_Sum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: soapbubble

Oh lovely part 2! Honey sweet...


Thanks Bubble. Glad you liked it. 😊
Cogito_Ergo_Sum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: foresight

I loved ow you went into the intricacies of the rag. build a subtle bond between annapurna and sanskar through it and through who he is as a person. you beautifully put that he gave swara the power to hurt him, but trusted her not to. loved that line.

i really liked how sanskar here asked her why didnt she ask him straight of what he was going when he was burning the blanket rather than asking obtuse questions, i was always bothered by it in the show. i am so glad your brought it up here. i am glad this swara realises there was changing in the nature of their relationship 😃

i liked how you put that fate is based on decisions. i always felt that ragini was more perceptive than swara. swara is more naive and utopia despite having had a tougher life and being elder to ragini. you brought that really well in ragini's advice to swara.

woh!! swara has really studied sanskar's eyes...even sanskar couldnt miss reading that sign and kissed her 😳 😉 and what a kiss...

amazing part and amazing rang 👏 👏 👏



Hey Sapna...🤗 🤗

Thanks so much for your lovely comment.

Am very glad you liked the tie-up of the Raag Bhairav, with the tone of this chapter, and indeed with Sanskaar's inherent nature, his immense, unshakable trust in Swara, and the slow growth of that feeling in Swara, too.

I wanted to bring that question up in the Sanskaar--Swara confrontation, that if she had a doubt on that blanket burning, she only had to ask. When I was watching that scene too, I felt it weird that she should have approached a simple question in such a roundabout manner.

Though I had made the chapter SwaSan centric, I did want to give a role to Ragini here too, a further step in her slow path to redemption. She's not fully out of the woods yet, after all, it would take time. But she is sure trying to overcome those clouds of envy and paranoia, which blinkered her for so long.

Oh yes, Swara has certainly observed Sanskaar's eyes in detail. 😉 He is her pati and her bestie, after all! 😆

Happy that you liked the concluding romance. I was in dreamland when I wrote that too. 😳 ☺️


Cogito_Ergo_Sum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: luv_virmaan

Viji!

The 2nd part was awesome 👏
You have written it so beautifully and so poignantly that I could visualise all that you have written. And the way you have blended in music to the story, is amazing.
Loved loved loved the way you showed Swara craving and pining for Sanskaar's attention and his presence.
Ragini and Swara's convo was really good too! Just like you have showed in your story, I feel ultimately, its Ragini, who is going to be the one who will make Swara realise her feelings for Sanskaar or atleast give her the push to go and confess, if she has realised it already.
I have always love the sister bond and I really want it to be re-established it back on the show.. They make an adorable sisters pair.
And the SwaSan scene
She sings for him 😳 Their patchup and her description of his eyes was just WOW!
And then their kiss... *sigh*
They are just adorable! And finally their misunderstanding is cleared

Waiting for the second part! And thank you so much for the PM 😳



Hey Pratyusha 🤗 Thanks a ton for your lovely comment, am really glad you liked this chapter.

Yeah, as we were discussing the other day, I had really wanted Swara to pine for Sanskaar, miss him, and realize just how much she had hurt him with her mistrust. I wanted her to realize just how much he meant to her, far, far more than this convenient "best friends" tag. 😆

I wanted to show Ragini slowly on the path to redemption. She still feels the occasional pang of envy, and things between Swara and her are still a bit uneasy and tense. But she is genuinely thinking of the opportunity Sanskaar gave her: to confess her mistakes, and take that path towards the genuinely good person she used to be.

I wanted to make Swara express her feelings through music...words do not always suffice na, especially when the hurt is deep. I just wanted to tie in that music theme here, with Swara using the Raag Bhairav to express her belief and faith in Sanskaar. Of course, his favorite Raag sung by his favorite person, managed to soothe his wounds. 😊

You liked Swara's desciption of Sanskaar's eyes, huh? I loved writing it too. 😳 And I was seriously going ☺️ when I wrote that kiss scene, so glad you liked it, too.

Cogito_Ergo_Sum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: The.Lannister

@Part 2:

Your command over language is so good. As you go on describing things, early mornings in MM, their routines etc everything plays out in front of my eyes when I read your descriptions. Cut to the last scene...when even that plays out... 😆☺️


While in the show we are just assuming that Swara has been developing feelings for Sanskaar over the past few days it was good to see things from her perspective here & have it confirmed that yes she does feel something for him & considers him more than a friend. But then her doubting him becomes all the more disappointing than it was in the show. There at least I convinced myself saying that she is only his friend...

Sanskaar loves music & then Swara using that as a means to break the ice...brilliant👏


And coming to my most favourite part: that description of Sanskaar's eyes☺️ That was a mix of so many things on her part, it was sweet & cute & at the same time a confirmation of a growing awareness she has of him, just too good Viji😳 Only someone who has been observing him for long will note all these things


Loved the Oscar Wilde quote, but then I love everything the man says! I think I am going to sit down with my diary, open all your FFs & jot down all the wonderful quotes you add in all your works. I know many of them but will never be able to use them at the correct place like you always manage to do👏



Shruti darling...🤗 🤗 A BIG Jhappi to you for that lovely comment.

Thanks for saying you liked the descriptions. You would have guessed I'm a big fan of Sunsets and Sunrises by now. 😊 I do love them, describing them in this TS (Sunset in Yaman Kalyan; Sunrise in Bhairav) also was to set the tone, since Raag Yaman Kalyan is an evening Raag, while Raag Bhairav is an early morning one, traditionally played at sunrise or just after.

He he...you liked the description of the concluding SwaSan scene in this one, huh? Well, I liked writing it, too. 😳 ☺️

I wanted to bring in that aspect of their Diwali interaction, because it seemed to me that Swara was really, at some level, aware that Sanskaar was behaving with her like a guy normally behaves with the girl he loves. In a slightly flirtatious, teasing manner. And her response certainly wasn't discouraging at all. 😛

I know, Shruti, I was also disappointed that she chose to doubt Sanskaar. I was majorly bugged with her, in fact. But then, I have rationalized it (and explained her side in this chapter), that she only felt Sanskaar could have kidnapped Ragini, to teach her a lesson for insulting/ maligning Swara. Basically, a small seed of doubt arises, since Swara knows how protective Sanskaar is, about her.

That's why, I also made her apologize to Sanskaar in that reconciliation scene, that she ought to have known, even had he done this kidnapping, he would have never let Swara be blamed for it. Nor would he have let Swara worry so much for those couple of days, he would have told her in confidence.

Glad you liked the music aspect of this chapter as well as the previous one. I wanted to weave that in convincingly. Quite often, music "speaks" to us more powerfully than words, na?

Am also very happy you liked Swara's description of Sanskaar's eyes. I enjoyed writing that bit, a lot. 😉

Oh, I love Oscar Wilde too. That man was an absolute genius. Have you by chance watched "The Good Woman", a film based on his play "Lade Windermere's fan"? If not, please watch it. It ahs so many of his witty quotes incorporated into the dialogues. I was grinning non stop throughout the film.
Starring Helen Hunt, Scarlett Johannson and a couple of others.

Cogito_Ergo_Sum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: tootiefrootie11

Res for part 2 comment

Unres

Sorry I am late Vij! I have been struggling with workloads and other commitments and just got home - it's gone 10 pm! I didn't want to write a comment from the phone.
Beautiful! The descriptions you evoke are always so effective, you can literally transport the reader straight to the place you write of. I was lost in the majesty and grandeur of the MM and the way Annapurna was singing the Aarti and later Swara, I could actually hear it. Bhairav is my mum's favourite raga- she sings it very well too:). I also loved the connection drawn between the music and how Sanskaar's character is moulded. Like me, you have always seen the real connect he has with Annapurna.
The SwaSan reconciliation applied a balm to my heart. I loved the idea that Swara was working so hard on conveying her remorse and particularly loved that you used Ragini in the way you did. What I liked was you did it realistically, she is still not immediately reformed- we all know life doesn't work like serials- mad drama leading to big instant changes. I really liked the balance of her desire to change fighting against her deep seated feelings of frustrated anger and jealousy but finally, some goodness winning through and her telling Swara would of course be so effective. As it is we have doubts about Swara's real love in life being pyaari behena 😆. Seriously though, talking of the real love of ones life- I so enjoyed how Sanskaar finally melted with the message wifey sang out to him. Again, in real life we all know that over time and subject to amount of effort put in, anger can fade and when we love someone so much, at some point the softening is inevitable. And what a way you chose to get Swara to express her changed feelings! Ah- that description of Sanskaar's eyes and his reaction- ☺️ . That kiss and their love and passion for each other was so beautiful, I can sleep happy visualising 😳. Oh and before then- we saw the scene with Sanskaar angry and then upset and Swara devastated on screen but reading it like this brought all the power and feels of it back.
I am not sure I have told you before but Oscar Wilde is one of my favourite authors- I got record high marks in my literature paper on the essay I wrote on him. I devoured his work- his dry sarcastic wit and satire always right up my street. And of course Khalil Gibran ❤️
It'll be no surprise to you that like all your work, I was lapping this one up, ever hungry for more! Hope to read Part 3 soon.
The redemption of Laksh question is interesting. I am currently mulling over doing a piece where I wondered if I should try that but at the moment my anger levels re Laksh ji are so high, I couldn't decide 😆. I find it easier to just cut him out or make him the big bad but I know at some point, it would be good to somehow have him dealt with. I am not being much help but at the moment I enjoy reading him getting scalded, punched, scratched etc etc 😆 but if you do redeem him, I know you will do a fine job so either way is fine!

Sorry if my comments today are scrambled, they might resemble the state of my brain! Love you soul sis xoxo



Hi Shru...🤗 🤗


Hope your mad week, work wise, is giving you some breathing time in between.

I thought we weren't to say Sorry? 😆 No problem dear...I understand work/ family pressures so am glad you read at leisure, and comment in detail when you get the time. I feel incredibly happy, in fact, that you set it aside to do when you have sufficient time. 😊

Great to know Raag Bhairav is your Mom's favorite. Mine is Yaman Kalyan, but with Bhairav, Todi and Bhairavi coming very close behind...but I don't have enough material for a 4th chapter as of now, to fit in Bhairavi. 😊

Since Bhairav is an early morning Raag, traditionally performed at daybreak or a little after, I wanted to set that ambiance at the beginning. Am so glad to hear you liked it. 🤗 And I wanted to weave in the theme of music into how Swara conveys her feelings to Sanskaar. After all, sometimes music conveys emotions much more powerfully than words, na?

You hit the nail on the head about what I was trying to portray regarding Ragini. We really have this soul connect going on. 😉 I wanted to show the gradual, difficult process, it wouldn't happen just with a snap of her fingers. She's obviously thinking seriously of the opportunity Sanskaar has given her to confess her sins, repent, and thereby redeem herself. But she still feels those pangs of envy, disillusionment, and anger. But she took that important step of at least nudging Swara in the right direction.

Am so very happy you liked the SwaSan confrontation scene, as well as their subsequent reconciliation and the romance. I was going quite 😳 ☺️ when I wrote that, this couple is so magical, the sheer passion they bring on screen is just electric!!

You liked Swara's observation of Sanskaar's eyes, huh? I thoroughly loved writing that, too. 😉

And I really adore Wilde's works. 😆 Its uncanny to hear how you chose his works for your literature essay. Which one is your favorite? I love both "The picture of Dorian Gray" and "Lady Windermere's Fan". Actually, I love "An Ideal Husband" and "Lord Arthur Savile's Crime", too. I just can't choose. 😊

I agree regarding Lakshya Ji, BTW. I am too biased against him to attempt a credible redemption as of now. So in Part 3, he certainly won't get redeemed, but he certainly will get his comeuppance. 😉

When are you gonna be doing part 3 of your piece? By this Friday I think you said? Are you planning a part 4 as well?



tootiefrootie11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
Hey Viji, stalking the forum between meetings but on annoying phone so can't make this as long as I'd like to. My favourite OW is Dorian Gray, it calls on so many levels. I do love An Ideal Husband too and am a huge Rupert Everett fan so don't know if you saw the adaptation they did of it on film? Very funny!
I was hoping to start writing my part 3 today but have another client do after work so it will have to be tomorrow as again on Friday I'm in endless meetings in London so can't! Uuurgh! I hate such a packed diary but always happens this time of the year. Still mulling over how to make part 3 work as I really don't have an elaborate story this time to rely on so it all turns on the interaction and if I can do justice to it. Not sure of part 4, maybe a very brief epilogue.
When are you going to have time to get Todi up by? Glad to hear Mr LRG isn't getting redeemed yet lol!

Lots of love xx
Zephyr8 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Read both parts together...beautifully written and so very expressive. I like how Swara explained herself to Sanskar. Waiting for your next update. Thank you for the PM.
Mallika-E-Zain thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Omg Viji!
The second part was so beautiful!😳
Full of SwaSan☺️ and even Ragini looked good in that!😊
It was awesome . Loved it immensely👏

JazzyM thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Holly Santa Maria! Viji ... I'm totally floored.
Ragini...why she is the way she is...near to Lucifer as Sujatha says ...had me glued to the story. Sanskar...gosh, the guy has style but now you have given him a halo too..he is bigger than life..the conversation between him and Ragini, his last parting shot...'If you are opposed to Swara, you are my enemy today, Ragini...that sounded like something Mario Puzo of Godfather fame would write...

Rest later... got a conference call starting in 5 minutes.

Finally caught up with all my readings...

Ever since young, I have been brought up to listen to Carnatic music, my early remembrance of my grandmother is of her doing tiny, tedious but super lovely needlework with music flowing around her. She taught me the different aspects of Carnatic and Hindustani Raag. To her greatest disappointment, I could recite all the 'words' she had described but not a thing of the actual music stuck to my brains. I remember her lamenting to my mom, about my 'handicap'... 😉

Reading your 2nd update made me realize that music connects to the soul but it also connects your soul to you...

The yearning of Swara to get into Sanskar's good books, her explanation of why she was worried he might be the suspect made a tremendous impact on me...It was so well thought of and brought to life in your writings, it was haunting...Every single para was so vivid, I shed a tear or two sympathizing with Ragini...a feet to be applauded in my books as I simply deplore Ragini's character...

The sangamam of the souls of SwaSan...it was a Raag by itself...Todi might just be it...(after all Hindustani's Bhairavi corresponds to Carnatic's Thodi in terms of its aroha and avaroha)
Edited by JazzyM - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".