Why Naina's approach to Karan's disease deserves a lot of Credit

Sona1121 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Hello everyone!


This is not my usual episode review post. Though NaiRan as always were adorable! The moment when she went "Sach?" And he responded "Sach" was so beautiful. Its like it sealed a bond between them. But today, I want to talk about something else. I have mentioned many times before how Naina is perfect for Karan and how good she is for him. But since I ship them romantically, all that probably takes the same tone. However, some recent real life incidents, though not exactly related to the topic, made me want to talk about Naina's response to Karan's disease and her approach towards him as a separate issue, not in terms of romance, but in terms of how she deals with a person suffering from a psychosomatic disease. I am no medical professional, but this is just what I know from general reading.


Recently, it was World Health Day and the theme this time was "Let's Talk", which was a reference to clinical depression which is a very big concern in world health these days. A lot of reports mentioned that people suffering from depression and other psychological issues find it very difficult to speak to people about it. People generally are not sensitive to such issues and either don't consider them a big deal or don't understand the seriousness of what a person is suffering. There is also a sort of taboo associated with it. That is true for all psychological and mental health issues actually and more so in India. All literature increasingly mentions the need to be sensitive, patient and understanding. This means having a varied approach. You have to be considerate but also forceful if necessary. Its very tough to handle everything, not only for the patient, but also for his or her loved ones. In the light of all this, I feel that what the makers are showing through Karan Naina is very commendable.


Karan's issue is not exactly related to the above paragraph but it has elements of a physiological nature. It has been shown that his family, despite their best intentions, does not really get it and that is something Sandhya has obviously used to her advantage. His fears about his disease, his insecurities, his feelings of worthlessness have all contributed to making him the way he is. And he was resigned to this life till Naina chanced upon the scene.


Right from the time Naina found out about the disease, her response has been admirable. She didn't get worked up or hyper, she just wanted to figure out what it was and how it could be treated. She consulted Vishal, who told her everything. She didn't get agitated when he mentioned it was a psychosomatic disease, which is great because usually people get very uncomfortable when you mention even a hint of a psychological problem. After that, she has been patient and has been increasingly trying to get Karan to see beyond his disease and fell some sort of self worth. This is very crucial as such patients really need to feel that they are not less in any way from others and are as important to family and society as the next person. Understanding doesn't mean she lets him get away with things. She is very firm if she thinks he should do something. But she constantly makes him feel wanted and portrays that his well being is important to her, that he is important to her. The fact that she shows that she cares what happens to him goes a long way in building his confidence and making him believe that he matters. She doesn't expect quick solutions, but slowly wants to help Karan build a better life for himself. Forgetting the fact that they are a potential romantic couple, what she is doing as a human being, as a friend to Karan is so laudable. This is exactly what people around need to keep in mind when we deal with such issues.


A lot of people might wonder why I am saying this especially. After all, isn't this what anyone would do. Sadly, that's not true. As I have mentioned, sensitivity towards psychological issues is not a norm. Real life is filled with examples of the same. Which is why I wanted to write about this. The fact that Naina is doing this gives a great message to society. It takes a lot of strength to be the way she is and do what she is doing with Karan and it deserves appreciation.


As I have mentioned, I have no special knowledge about these things so I apologize if I have said something wrong or hurt anybody's feelings as it is definitely not my intention. I have just written what I felt and what ever little I know. Would love to hear your thoughts!

Edited by .Sona. - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.4k

Users

8

Likes

87

Frequent Posters

Namita-M thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Very well said Sona. I am a Canadian now and here there are programs to tackle or rid of mental health stigma.
People in general don't get it. Usually, the victim is ridiculed and made fun of. Everything is in their head.
That's not true. Patience and kindness will go a long way when dealing with such a patient. They are humans and need to be understood.
Agreed. Chauhan family is a perfect example of it all. Sadly this is how many people and families are.

A service provider here Bell, has a Let's Talk. It's a wide-reaching, multi-year program designed to break the silence around mental illness and support mental health all across Canada.


We tweet using a hashtag and 5 cents is donated with every tweet to Canadian Alliance on Mental Illness and Mental Health.

I didn't know much about mental illness and was probably just as ignorant but thanks to the initiatives, I can proudly say, I am more aware and very much more educated in this sensitive matter.

What the maker's are trying to show through Naina is indeed commendable. That is exactly what is required.

Hats off to them.
Sona1121 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: -Namita-

Very well said Sona. I am a Canadian now and here there are programs to tackle or rid of mental health stigma.

People in general don't get it. Usually, the victim is ridiculed and made fun of. Everything is in their head.
That's not true. Patience and kindness will go a long way when dealing with such a patient. They are humans and need to be understood.
Agreed. Chauhan family is a perfect example of it all. Sadly this is how many people and families are.

A service provider here Bell, has a Let's Talk. It's a wide-reaching, multi-year program designed to break the silence around mental illness and support mental health all across Canada.


We tweet using a hashtag and 5 cents is donated with every tweet to Canadian Alliance on Mental Illness and Mental Health.

I didn't know much about mental illness and was probably just as ignorant but thanks to the initiatives, I can proudly say, I am more aware and very much more educated in this sensitive matter.

What the maker's are trying to show through Naina is indeed commendable. That is exactly what is required.

Hats off to them.


Thank you Di!

I agree. There is lack of awareness about mental health issues and the way they should be dealt with. It might appear to people that what Naina is doing is general niceness but its actually not common and is more than usual behavior. It takes a lot of courage and strength and I really admire her for it.

I am myself not very knowledgeable, slowly I am getting to understand better.
Namita-M thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
@Sona, our girl really is strong and courageous. Like you said, it takes a lot from a person to do what she is doing.
Everyone who dismisses the efforts or Naina as a typical character, most probably are not educated in the mental health issues.
It's sad how many people are suffering alone. Not speaking up for fear of ridicule!!

Sona1121 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: -Namita-

@Sona, our girl really is strong and courageous. Like you said, it takes a lot from a person to do what she is doing.

Everyone who dismisses the efforts or Naina as a typical character, most probably are not educated in the mental health issues.
It's sad how many people are suffering alone. Not speaking up for fear of ridicule!!


I don't know about others Di but I can only say that I don't know if I will have the strength to respond the way Naina is doing in such a situation. That is why I find it inspiring. Agree about the last part, the number of people who are not able to avail of help is staggering.
Tahitien-moon thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Nice post yaar agree with you this girl is such a courageous little package and determined that comes from that deeper courage she has👏 and so very observant and clever to the core👏how she changed Karan that lonely person who closes up himself to the world dissapointed in the way he has been treated by them now opening up like a flower bathing in her sunshine her courage and her endless support👏 and her deep faith in him👏 and even more beauty of their relationship is how he is trying to give back bit of that support to her 👏 when he almost nothing to give back at the moment👏
neon145 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Just curious to know...
What really karan is suffering frm.
I know its skin allergy.but any specific disease.frm what i have seen in a scene he is allergic to sunlight.its similar to porphyrias.but non of his family members have it.of course the disease penetration differs in individuals.and if its porphyrias then it doesnt spread through touch.
Sona1121 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: neon145

Just curious to know...
What really karan is suffering frm.
I know its skin allergy.but any specific disease.frm what i have seen in a scene he is allergic to sunlight.its similar to porphyrias.but non of his family members have it.of course the disease penetration differs in individuals.and if its porphyrias then it doesnt spread through touch.


Hi!

They haven't mentioned a disease specifically yet. Vishal mentioned that it was a psychosomatic disease and that it was contagious. Karan is allergic to a lot of other things as well. I guess we will find out more in coming episodes.
Sona1121 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Tahitien-moon

Nice post yaar agree with you this girl is such a courageous little package and determined that comes from that deeper courage she has👏 and so very observant and clever to the core👏how she changed Karan that lonely person who closes up himself to the world dissapointed in the way he has been treated by them now opening up like a flower bathing in her sunshine her courage and her endless support👏 and her deep faith in him👏 and even more beauty of their relationship is how he is trying to give back bit of that support to her 👏 when he almost nothing to give back at the moment👏


Thank you!

Exactly. His life is turning better because of her!
neon145 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: .Sona.



Hi!

They haven't mentioned a disease specifically yet. Vishal mentioned that it was a psychosomatic disease and that it was contagious. Karan is allergic to a lot of other things as well. I guess we will find out more in coming episodes.


who is vishal?
Even if its psychosomatic then also it cant b contagious.lets see what kichidi they ll do with medicine..;-p

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".