{| SPK: Episode Discussion thread #2 |} - Page 15

Poll

Who do you think has been least butchered by this serial so far?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

84.5k

Users

32

Likes

2k

Frequent Posters

Mirage09 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
Watched both the epis of this week now...And thankfully I m alive and well.!! All hail to Krishna!

Can someone, for the sake of my sanity, tell me who the hell is Karna here ?? A Daanveer, or Duryodhan Mitr or Krishna's Sakha - Bhakt or Gala fadoo, trembling cry baby or some maryada purush who keeps crying for stri ka samman..???

What's up with those under arms - shoulder hugging laces btw??

Is it just me or Karna looked like a damsel in awe, when all Krishna did was Shishupal Vadh..?? Reminded me of a 90's heroine who was just saved from a villian who tried to rape her, by her hero. Come on!!!

No comments on Drau's vampadi laugh! And no comments on Bhim and Dury's constipated looks as well! I thought only the twins do not have any dialogues in this show, but it seems Arjun is also relieved of them!

I have to say, the actor who portrayed Shishupal had done really well! It takes guts to act like the way he acted! Don't ask me how he acted though!

Yeah, the reason for her andha comment was good! So, SidT rectified something after all, in this other wise reversed show! He definitely must have gone bonkers from the backlash during ⭐️B, hence the change, perhaps?

Y did it feel as if I was watching some school theatre drama and not a tv show?

Drau tying the cloth on Krishna's hand was so good! I loved that scene in ⭐️B as well!

P.S.; I liked Krishna's gyaan when he said about what goes around comes around! That is soo damn true! And, for the first time and I hope it will be the only time, I liked Shakuni's acting yesterday! (All of the above are strictly my POV😆)

Edit :- What irked me the most was Shakuni's stupid prophecy of the name 'Draupadi'! That was pathetic, but sadly true as well.
Edited by ---Anu--- - 9 years ago
Regina_Lupa thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
Saw Monday's epi..
Is GR doing Arjun's role instead of Karna?? The way he was burning when Shishupal insulted Govind was... Ggoosshhh...
Seriously... Is this a 90s show??? Anyone can walk in to a queen's chamber and misbehave... N the 5 "dumbos".. Not juz sony's even star pandavas were handicapped in several instances!!!
Dury is like.. "Come insult me" mode.. What the hell...

N andha ka puthr statement.(epic is long forgotten bt makers.. Sooo). I expected it.. N i m relieved for tht damn reason drau gave.. (I can't believe myself)
Ramya_98 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: DramaQueenBride

Saw Monday's epi..
Is GR doing Arjun's role instead of Karna?? The way he was burning when Shishupal insulted Govind was... Ggoosshhh...
Seriously... Is this a 90s show??? Anyone can walk in to a queen's chamber and misbehave... N the 5 "dumbos".. Not juz sony's even star pandavas were handicapped in several instances!!!
Dury is like.. "Come insult me" mode.. What the hell...

N andha ka puthr statement.(epic is long forgotten bt makers.. Sooo). I expected it.. N i m relieved for tht damn reason drau gave.. (I can't believe myself)


I can never forget what this show did to parav.
And today he actually was so keen on saving the pandavas from VH, like wth? 😡 Why does sony karna have to stand up everywhere to save the pandavas, krishna and draupadi. Be it lakshagrah, that non-existent attempt of r**e on drau by shishu and now DS. Have arjuna and bheema died down? Thank god, Navi got a dialogue today otherwise i would have forgotten the presence of my beloved arjuna in the epic because all his jobs are being done by karna.
Brahmaputra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat


Actually all 5 Panchakanyas had relationship with more than one man.
Ahalya
Mandodari
Tara
Kunti
Draupadi

Ma Sita is not one of Panchakanyas as is commonly mistaken. It is Kunti who is a Panchakanya...😳

As for the manliness...ok I am happy with the explanation...👍🏼
Objection overruled.

No. I did not mean Seetha, but Mandodari. Was Mandodari in relationship with another man than Ravana?
Well, 50% of our chromosomes is from father, 50% from our mother. So we all have all qualities equally. Just the expression varies. Sometimes one trait is projected, sometimes another, depending on the situation. Just because a trait is not expressed, does not mean it does not exist in us. It is simply not the right time for its expression. This is why I said manliness is not the monopoly of men. That quality is there in women also, but only very few really developes it.😊
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra

No. I did not mean Seetha, but Mandodari. Was Mandodari in relationship with another man than Ravana?
Well, 50% of our chromosomes is from father, 50% from our mother. So we all have all qualities equally. Just the expression varies. Sometimes one trait is projected, sometimes another, depending on the situation. Just because a trait is not expressed, does not mean it does not exist in us. It is simply not the right time for its expression. This is why I said manliness is not the monopoly of men. That quality is there in women also, but only very few really developes it.😊



I had attended a play of Panchakanyas where it was shown that after Ravan's death Mandodari had married Vibhishan...just like Tara married Sugriva.
I am not sure if this is part of the epic or another folktale like Jambu fruit.

However I feel it is true. In fact the whole idea of Panchakanyas is to prove that virginity of a woman is the state of her soul not body. And hats off to the scholars who came up with this idea so long ago.
Maybe all modern Kunti haters n Draupadi haters should take a lesson...
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ramya06


I can never forget what this show did to parav.
And today he actually was so keen on saving the pandavas from VH, like wth? 😡 Why does sony karna have to stand up everywhere to save the pandavas, krishna and draupadi. Be it lakshagrah, that non-existent attempt of r**e on drau by shishu and now DS. Have arjuna and bheema died down? Thank god, Navi got a dialogue today otherwise i would have forgotten the presence of my beloved arjuna in the epic because all his jobs are being done by karna.



Now I am pretty sure Sony Karna will take off his Kanchivaram n drape it over Draupadi to save her honour.
Or no...this time Sony Draupadi might call him Bhoot-Pisach...monkey...dog...everything n after hearing all this Sony Karna will call her 'unchaste'...


Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat

Exactly Sabhayata...
Even in Star Plus...they did the exact same thing.
Right from the very beginning Draupadi was being taunted for her polyandry!!

If I not mistaken except Karna n Dushasen noone ever insulted Draupadi for her polyandry.
And if Karna's words are interpolation...then except 🤬 Dushasen noone insulted her for this reason...And here everyone seems to have problem with her 'Paanch Paanch Pati'!!🤬


That is because our modern mindset cant accept polyandry hence Sony Dau who is in a polyandrous relationship needs to be insulted every time.BRC was best in this regard at least they didn't exaggerate Drau's polyandrous marriage.

Drau's hardships began only after Pandvas lost everything

Before that she was wife of 5 powerful warrior's and an empress no one would have dared to talk to her like that

Even Karna and Dushy said what they did once Pandavs became their slaves

Sabhayata thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: aanvi98

it's really a very sad thing tht people forget she only sacrificed for dharma, for future. We hv really became animals.


why sacrifice for Dharma i didnt understand
Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat

Vrish

On a side note...I have heard many theories saying that if Karna had been the one then he would have never shared his wife...I mean these are speculations of some of his admirers...

Since you are also a Karna admirer...do you think Karna too would have agreed to share his wife with his brothers just like his biggest rival? 😉



Yeah, I do. I don't think he really had the opinion on polyandry that he expressed in the court: as he told Krishna later, that he only did to delight Duryodhan.

After all, the person who declared that he owed everything of his to Duryodhan and Radha - if he had gotten his fair share from Kunti & the Pandavas, he'd just as happily have shared Draupadi w/ them.
MBcrazyfan thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: .Vrish.



Yeah, I do. I don't think he really had the opinion on polyandry that he expressed in the court: as he told Krishna later, that he only did to delight Duryodhan.

After all, the person who declared that he owed everything of his to Duryodhan and Radha - if he had gotten his fair share from Kunti & the Pandavas, he'd just as happily have shared Draupadi w/ them.

That's quite possible vrish...he would have done the same thing...we hv to consider that this incident took place in dwapar yug...I hv read in many fiction books on karna, that he says he'd nvr shared draupadi...but who knows..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".