Finally back - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.8k

Users

10

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
From Sid T, I never expect a flawless characterization of Karna.
Karna is too much a complex character, with too many shades, which Sid T & his creatives team, never ever able to handle.
If I talk about performance, then for me its always Aham Sharma as Karna.
Aham cried too much as Karna, he gave tough competition to any serial bahus, But I simply love Aham as Karna.
Gautam is a very good actor. But I cant never imagine him as Karna.
But I dont know how, I love Basant Bhatt, the one who play youth Karna, I loved his performance, despite of the crap script.Only thing, I like in this show.
About Krishna, Its always SRJ, this new Krishna, sorry again I dont like him.
But, here I liked the actor who is playing Arjun.
& again, in my view, I love Pooja Sharma as Draupadi, she perfectly captured the essence of Draupadi.


Patrarekha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: srishtisingh

great post👍🏼

agree navi is great. but yeah sonykarna gives me on or off feeling of karna. sometime yeah its good and other time ... agree that starkarna was more crybaby(even though i loved aham potrayal and his intense eyes) but sonykarna is more confused. abt krishna i agree wholeheartedly. i dont doubt actor capabilities but something is amiss in sonykrishna. i too loved simple no from sonydrau than star's bhoot pishach. and i even liked the episode. btw how did u find dhrist? he looked ccute(star one was hawt bro)


yes navi is anyday better arjuna. don't want to compare as i still love Shaheer's look as arjuna and his action sequences and chemistry with krishna,abhimanyu,karna and ofcourse Brihannala. but barring that he was nowhere arjuna what navi is.

sonyKarna is too much stupid portrayal still not a crybaby. thats what makes resemble epic karna.

and dhristadyumna was Chandradev of Devon k Dev mahadev if i am not very wrong. i love both dhrish
Edited by Patrarekha - 9 years ago
Patrarekha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: sania_58

From Sid T, I never expect a flawless characterization of Karna.
Karna is too much a complex character, with too many shades, which Sid T & his creatives team, never ever able to handle.
If I talk about performance, then for me its always Aham Sharma as Karna.
Aham cried too much as Karna, he gave tough competition to any serial bahus, But I simply love Aham as Karna.
Gautam is a very good actor. But I cant never imagine him as Karna.
But I dont know how, I love Basant Bhatt, the one who play youth Karna, I loved his performance, despite of the crap script.Only thing, I like in this show.
About Krishna, Its always SRJ, this new Krishna, sorry again I dont like him.
But, here I liked the actor who is playing Arjun.
& again, in my view, I love Pooja Sharma as Draupadi, she perfectly captured the essence of Draupadi.



bold part is hilarious 😆. and i agree with you Aham is Karna. i liked Basant Bhatt too and Vidyut Xavier too who played young Karna in starbharat . Pooja was great performer and lookwise apt but i hate stardraupadi portrayal but iagree she could have played epic draupadi perfectly as well

and about krishna the least said is better for pandeyji krishna
Ramya_98 thumbnail
Book Talk Reading Challenge Award - Pro Thumbnail 10th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
First of all, its good to see you back patrarekha.(i hope that is your name) Can't say much about star mb because i did not get a chance to watch it. But in this show i feel that firstly karna is arrogant and outspoken,no doubt very much like in the actual epic but his shouting is just so irritating! I always felt GR was a good actor because i heard he won many awards for his potrayal in sarswatichandra but in this show he is not that good. But must say he is improving a lot!
Second comes arjuna and i admit that i did not like shaheer much going by the promos or the tits and bits of star mb i saw but here i am loving Navi. I feel he looks closest to arjuna and he is working hard on the character too.
And then pankhuri, well watching yesterday's episode i think that she is fabulous as panchali and i just adore pankhuri-navi aka dhananjaya-draupadi of this show though i always thought arjuna loved subhadra more.
I don't like this shakuni and dhushasan looks a bit of a sanyasi himself with that long bearded look. 😆 And duryodhana is not too bad but they are showing him in a villainous light and karna-dury friendship has been badly butchered which is obviously not right.
And must say there is no match for srj as krishna. This actor on SPK also has a negative look with his make-up and that wierd crown on his head.
Overall i feel they must focus more on karna's life and his pov not on the other things they already showed in mb because this is SPK afterall.
panchaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Okay I am a big Aham fan and a big Gautam fan too..

I liked Aham as Karna and liking Gautam as Karna very much..

I agree that StarB Karna frustrated me for that punching bag thingy..

and that's why like you I too am loving how SPK Karna more 😊

I loved the way he gave Draupadi back..

Many popular versions say that after Draupadi rejects Karna, he didn't say anything just left the hall..

However, after the Bhoot Pishach episode of StarB, SPK Karna's curse was such a relief..I completely agree with you..😃

Though an ardent Karna Draupadi shipper [which any fool also can understand, seeing my username, siggy and my favorite character from Mahabharat] 😆 yet after BRC MB Indian TV screen kind of failed to give me any chance to ship them...😔

StarB Karna Draupadi would always be a "BIG NO" for me... [so as Star Karna vrishali,, I so hoped the CVS to keep him celibate...but] 😭

I like Pankhuri, she is a good actor, and quite refreshing but sadly she is not the face of Panchaali.. I liked her more as Razia...

So I don't want any KD in SPK too...

[ However, I ship StarB Karna with Dharmakshetra Draupadi 😉 they look quite stunning together and they proved it ]😃

I feel DH (Dharmakshetra) Draupadi would look great with SPK Karna too 😳 DH Draupadi was bold [just as I imagine her] and Kashmira did a great job. 😃

After Roopa Ganguly if I like any Draupadi on Indian TV that's Kashmira...but sadly I did not like the Karna actor on that very show(DH)..

I am neither a Arjun and ArDi fan nor a hater, but I am liking the actor Navi..he looks similar to epic Arjun..

After seeing marvelous SRJ, I just can't digest this Sony Krishna... agree..


well it's just my understanding, and my like and dislike. I do not mean to hurt anyone..

Edited by panchaali - 9 years ago
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
Great post...n I agree with most of your points...
This Star Plus n Sony characters n actors have got mixed up...
The actors on Star Plus were far far better but the portrayal on Sony is much more apt.

For example: Pooja was the ideal face of Draupadi...She looked like her...walked n talked like her...
Her charm...her aura...her dignity was very much like Draupadi.And yes...there were some brilliant scenes as well in Star Plus. However...the portrayal was very very rough...
She was too harsh at times...even going to the extent of kicking out her husband for marrying again and even insulting her elders...We NEVER see Draupadi in the epic doing that...
Not to mention 'Bhoot-Pisach'...I have written many many long comments expressing my utter hatred for the makers for making Draupadi speak like that...just to invoke sympathy for Karna

However in Sony...her portrayal is better...Atleast Draupadi in Sony is not unneccesarily insulting people...But at the same time I feel Pankhuri is too naive to play Draupadi. Pankhuri is beautiful...n a great actor...but she lacks the regal pride of Draupadi. I hate the arrogant portrayal but the pride must be there.

Maybe Pooja Sharma with her aura as Sony Draupadi and the correct portrayal would have been the perfect combination.

Coming to Karna...same problem.
Star Karna was too soft...which the epic Karna wasnt. Epic Karna had an integrity but he was nowhere a softie...he was quite proud n harsh too...In that regard...Sony Karna is better...
But again Aham Sharma was brilliant. And Gautam Rode is equally unsuitable as Karna...and his screaming is so irritating. His curse to Draupadi, though quite meaningful and heartwrenching, was very very unmanly and unlike the epic Karna...If epic Karna goes around cursing women for not marrying him...then half his charm is lost...Just my opinion. Not meant to hurt anyone. The epic Karna is somewhere between Star Plus' Karna n Sony Karna...

Maybe Aham Sharma as Sony Karna with this proud portrayal yet Aham's classic dignified aura would have been a perfect combination.

Coming to Arjun...I have to admit...Shaheer LOOKED amazing as Arjun.
He is the best-looking Arjun ever...but his acting was not impressive...neither was the portrayal.
Arjun was a very detached character...n the constant tears n 'Mujhe Kshama Kardo Panchali' irritated even an ardent Ardi fan like me...

As for Ardi...I dont know y u hate ShaJa so much...maybe fan outrage...
But I feel ShaJa were the best Ardi for me...or maybe actors dont really bother my love for a character or pair...
Yes...PanNavi also look promising let's see...

Pooja and Aham probably would have made a great pair but being an opposer of K-D I never imagined them in one frame...May be in some other show...they will rock...😳

I actually liked the K-D scene in Suryaputra Karna...maybe bcoz it was devoid of any kind of romance...
I actually liked Gautam Rode n Pankhuri's scene...but I cannot imagine them as lovers...
I liked their scene...just like a scene between two humans...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".