SKR-Of loops and symbolisms#5: Hard way and Smart Way : P.88

First Previous

Page

116

Next Last

Frequent Posters

shruthiravi

@shruthiravi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#1021

@aditi exactly for me too a human becomes God through his or her actions. Even in tough situations they dont sit and blame circumstances. But take action. Good or bad. But take action. They manage situations. They will be available in some form if not directly. In Sita's case it was through Hanuman. We just have to trust enough.

Quote

radianteyes.

@radianteyes.

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#1022

Hi sanju dear

I am well

How are you ?

@sruthi di

I am reading your ff

Will comment soon

Some chapters are left

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#1023

Shruthi di even i saw your post in Ashu's AT 😆

Remember once SKR made u change your analysis during Sulochana 's Sati time 😆

When it comes to SKR, we really can't predict anything...

The fact that most of your predictions were true itself is very surprising, shows the depth in your writing and the continuity SKR team maintained...

Hope your prediction (I don't know exactly what u have predicted though😆) gets true even this time 😛

Quote

radianteyes.

@radianteyes.

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#1024

Great analysis shruthi di

I loved the kobhavan relation

More or less the gate closing reminded me the closing of hate when Bharat pushed kakiyi out in the hands of the praja

This time there was role d revesal

Prakriti closed the door to sanskriti

But alas the door remained ...

We need a medium and messenger there

That could have solved things

Sita had mediums her sisters

And ram had hanuman the messenger

But alas only luv kush who were both could help out the matter .

Aditi di you are absolutely right

Edited by radianteyes. - 9 years ago

Quote

vipraja26

@vipraja26

Navigator

Posted: 9 years ago

#1025

Another wonderful episode and a wonderful analysis Shruti !

The scenes between pitha and putra were really done well ! Seemed quite natural and well enacted .The questions asked , the apologies sought and then acceptance!

The sisters trying their best to bring back the sita didi they knew who had been in deep love with her Raghunanadan with their cheerful ( but with some unsure feelings too) talks was good .

Rams walk towards the Kutir of sita was sure the toughest for him so far due to the guilt feel .

Finally the door scene was sure the reminder of the one when Sita left. Ayodhya just a beautiful one and the wind opening up the barrier - the door ( kind of pavan putra trying to ease out the tension ) .

Well the emotional break down though has begun has its heavy share yet to come .

Your analysis wrt Kaikeyi dasharsth in comparison to Ram and sita , Barath -Kaikeyi and Ram - kids were too good.

Edited by vipraja26 - 9 years ago

Quote

shruthiravi

@shruthiravi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#1026

@Charvi yes Prakriti closing door on Sanskriti and you said rightly to open the door completely you need medium and messenger. Well we all know Hanuman has some more role now. Let us wait.

@vipraja that walk was the best and BGM was too good. Actually it reminded me of one more thing. Dasrath's long drawn walk towards Kausalya's chamber after Ram, Sita and Lakhan leaves for Vanvass. But the difference was Dasrath was broken, his ego and pride crushed. But Ram he only had truth in his eyes when he did banishment and when he walked yesterday. There was no ego there. Only the apology for the misguided dharma which forced him to do her banishment

@aditi exactly Sulo Sati I was so sure. Because all the versions I had read have talked about it. But CVs decided to be inline with present times. Yes after the dialogue to Hanuman the analysis which I thought is picture perfect is shaken a bit. But nevertheless I am sure it will be connected. See one of the things about SKR I have loved is the absolute connect in screenplay. One of the reasons can be Ramayan story cannot be altered to the whims and fancies of TRP junta. But still to maintain the flow I am sure CVs would have taken lot of effort. Yes as I put in AT thread also I wish we get more such tightly scripted shows. India has rich classics of Kalidasa, Bhavabuti and all. Many mythological stories are buried in the treasure house of our literature. Stories like Malavikagnimitra, Meghadootha and stories of Princess Roopamati, even Meera Bhai makes for soulful watching if taken by the right PH.

Quote

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#1027

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@aditi exactly Sulo Sati I was so sure. Because all the versions I had read have talked about it. But CVs decided to be inline with present times. Yes after the dialogue to Hanuman the analysis which I thought is picture perfect is shaken a bit. But nevertheless I am sure it will be connected. See one of the things about SKR I have loved is the absolute connect in screenplay. One of the reasons can be Ramayan story cannot be altered to the whims and fancies of TRP junta. But still to maintain the flow I am sure CVs would have taken lot of effort. Yes as I put in AT thread also I wish we get more such tightly scripted shows. India has rich classics of Kalidasa, Bhavabuti and all. Many mythological stories are buried in the treasure house of our literature. Stories like Malavikagnimitra, Meghadootha and stories of Princess Roopamati, even Meera Bhai makes for soulful watching if taken by the right PH.

Even i feel history/ mytho should not be altered according to trp audience's fancy. Infact the same Ramayan which we usually see would have been more trp garnering 😆

But SKR showed what they had planned, didn't alter their story for anyone. That's why we can find symbolisms in each episodes 😳

Mytho can have many interpretations, as it's about how the writer views the God, their way of looking at Him. And there are many versions of the epics which we don't know.

Neither SKR claimed to be purely Valmiki/Tulsidas Ramayana. It's an adaptation of Ramayan hence they followed many versions and presented the best to us.

Moreover there are versions where Sita comes back after bhoomi pravesh. So let's see what they show.

I am watching with an open mind as of now, and am prepared either ways , bhoomi pravesh or reunion. As far as it's convincing, I am ok with it 😊

Agree our Indian mythology is very rich and aesthetic. I believe shows like SKR , StarMB n DKDM should be made which can connect present day audience with the rich culture of our country.

Quote

ayushimehra

@ayushimehra

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#1028

shruthi, nice analysis,

shruthi, is Mandavi, Urmila, shruthkirti, No kids this time. if you know tell.

Quote

shruthiravi

@shruthiravi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#1029

@aayush as far as I know the other brothers also have kids in 12 years. But SKR seems to show no kids at this point. But as per the story all brothers have 2 kids. Ramayana was perfect family planning of our times. We two, our two

@aditi if you look my first post in SKR forum Ramayana from Sita's POV the one thing I had decided was watch it with open mind so that answers to some of my long lasting questions can be found. Because a visual helps than reading. Even when you feel nothing more to tell, there will be a lot to tell. I don't know how many youngsters today have read Amar Chitra Kathas. But my childhood and teenage years these books that came twice a month was a treasure trove of stories rooted in our culture. I had 4 binded books close to 200-250 Amar Chitra Kathas which is currently with my cousin. For me every child should read them. It is our culture in a very positive way written in a very simple language. You will grow a love and appreciation for our culture through it, than blindly imbibing the west

Quote

ayushimehra

@ayushimehra

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#1030

Originally posted by: shruthiravi
@aayush as far as I know the other brothers also have kids in 12 years. But SKR seems to show no kids at this point. But as per the story all brothers have 2 kids. Ramayana was perfect family planning of our times. We two, our two

@aditi if you look my first post in SKR forum Ramayana from Sita's POV the one thing I had decided was watch it with open mind so that answers to some of my long lasting questions can be found. Because a visual helps than reading. Even when you feel nothing more to tell, there will be a lot to tell. I don't know how many youngsters today have read Amar Chitra Kathas. But my childhood and teenage years these books that came twice a month was a treasure trove of stories rooted in our culture. I had 4 binded books close to 200-250 Amar Chitra Kathas which is currently with my cousin. For me every child should read them. It is our culture in a very positive way written in a very simple language. You will grow a love and appreciation for our culture through it, than blindly imbibing the west

shruthi, this great We two our two, we worship Ram, we should follow this also😊