Chandralok, Amrit and Mandodari an analysis

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Today I was debating whether to take Shanta-Sita or Mandordari's Amrit mission. Have decided to stick to the latter. Because the way Mandodari gets Amrit shows an important aspect of incorrect understanding of dharma by women.
How women themselves is responsible for the atrocities happening on them without even realizing their actions are helping men like Ravan.

Mandodari takes it as her Patni dharma to protect Ravan. What is Ravan doing. He is raping woman. He is forcefully marrying woman, he is terrorizing people, he takes even devas as prisoners and orders them. She is going to protect such a man in the name of patni dharm.

Now see how she reaches there. First her mother. Dear daughter I understand your patni dharm here take power to reach Chandralok, now in Chandralok Rohini, yes I know how a wife feels, takes her to Amrit kumbh. How will Amrit not come because the woman is devoted. Who is asking these 3 women to support Ravan.

This is how women in general behave. We have them in present society. They might be victims of domestic abuse, their husbands dont even regard them their equal or worthy of anything. But still they will support their husbands and the other woman will take pity on this victim woman and will support her in the mission save her husband who is good for nothing fellow.

If I need to give a much better example it is the TRP of serials. Wherever this so called victimized woman cry, calling out mere pati ki raksha karo, mere parivar ki raksha karo TRP will soar.
Wherever you see an independant woman, who is raising voice against injustice in her sasural, or questions her sasumma well people wont tolerate it. Because they love the victim woman who is protecting Ravan like men and Lanka like family. If that is not enough they will call such a doormat Sita also. No wonder many progessive woman of present day cannot relate to real Sita and her inner beauty.

A much better proof of this Pati ki raksha business was seen when I was watching EHT. When the leading lady was fighting for the justice of her sister who is a rape victim TRP was low. But the moment leading lady does a Karvachauth for her husband and goes to protect him in the court, pata nahi kahan se TRP aunty bagke chali aayi. The show became slot leader. Can you believe. Actually that was one of the reasons I loved EHT also. It exposed society's hypocrisies if you observed carefully. I didnt had any problems the leading lady wanting to save her husband because he was a man who loved her and had walked the hard path for her sake, to get her justice. But I am damn sure TRP aunty wouldnt have understood all this.

So as woman we cannot see or understand pain of another woman we protect this so called men. We cannot relate to woman who are fighting for a woman's cause. We cannot understand men who truly believe a woman should have her rights, her space.

Have we woman become idiots to the point we cannot differentiate between Ram and Ravan and we love to propagate Ravan even if indirectly . Question to ponder and I will stop now
Edited by shruthiravi - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.1k

Users

13

Likes

71

Frequent Posters

KrishnaRukmini thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Beautiful post
Woman should understand another woman n her pain agony but sadly very less understand it...maximum time its like proverb woman is enemy of another woman ..sadly this is the society..
n not only men but women also glorified Ravan like man than Ram...
now u said m still wondering y y mandodari support n gone this much to save Ravan ok her patni dharma but what about as woman..
Ravan the man raping torturing other women but...

gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Shruthi a big 🤗 to you for the post today. Loved everything you wrote. Will try to leave some thoughts later. On duty now. Was actually waiting for your post.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
@Krishna the point is patni dharm. I have to protect my husband. Many woman still believe man has a right to hit them. A national survey told 43% women and 65% men believe woman are inferior to man. 43% women yaar. And these 43% becomes a big bane to the rest 57%.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
So true, Shruti.

And all these women are so self centered. Mandodari cannot see beyond her own needs? She didn't want her father murdered, so she chose Raavan..and now, she feels her chastity will be questioned if she doesn't protect Raavan- so she has to prove her chastity by getting him the amrit. And in the whole process, she fails to see how she has hurt her father, who would have chosen death over a son-in-law like Ravan...and the only trigger that made her go back to that father was again her selfish need to prove her chastity to the world- at the expense of every other woman!!!

Also shows how the death of a husband would be blamed on the waywardness of their wives those days...

So in those days, If Ravan died, it would be because his wife was not pure enough...not because of all the curses he acquired by his deeds!
KrishnaRukmini thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
@Shruthi yes I understand ...
our believe is wrong about men n women do n don't totally
but isn't patni dharam said to make sure my husband do right if he falter I will help him to see the right...
Actually our society make dharam complicated...

jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Very well put across. If u accept abuse and try to protect the person who is abusing. Then you no longer are a victim. You become as guilty as the one abuser.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
@Krishna a good mother is one who will not allow her son to stray from the path of rightenous. A son who knows his mother wont protect him if he does wrong will not stray, same is with wife. A good wife shouldnt allow husband to stray from path of righteousness. A husband who knows his wife will not tolerate rubbish will behave well.
@jayashree yes to live alone is difficult to stand against your loved one is painful, seeing your loved one suffering is painful. But which pain do you want. The pain of protecting the person who abuses you day and night, or the pain of standing with the right. Which pain is more acceptable. Many women choose the pain of domestic violence sadly

@chicksoup whether it was society that day or society this day protection of family is entrusted with woman. Her principles are supposed to protect her family. But it is her duty to know that she uses this power wisely and on right men, never on wrong men.
radianteyes. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Beautiful post shruthi di
Women are the sheild , the strength everything .
Wherever she goes by choice , knowledge , wealth and power flow .
Lovely post
Arijit007 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
patni dharm, suhaag ki raksha, i just hate this crap. pataa nahi yeh hindustani mard kaise haqdaar hogaye hain is kavach ke? yeh problem aaj ki nahi sadiyon se chali aa rahi hain. jalandhar, shankhachud in jaise daanavon ki marne ke liye in ke patniyon ke satitva ko haani pahunchaayi jaati hain aur woh atmahatya karne ko vivash hoti hain, kyun? why is the fidelity of wife is so importent?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".