Nandhini is not rape victim - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

60

Views

6.7k

Users

26

Likes

225

Frequent Posters

Saazhumsafars thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#11
^^this internalizing or normalizing could have consequences,right?even leading to some kind of exploding or imploding or breakingdown?
SummerRain7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Saazhumsafars

^^this internalizing or normalizing could have consequences,right?even leading to some kind of exploding or imploding or breakingdown?

Yes. But, it need not always be a breakdown, it could be a gradual destruction of your sense of self. There could be behavioral changes that could manifest in many different ways, affecting every other aspect of your life. It could push you to depression, substance abuse, other psychological issues etc.
nimmu96 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#13
Not supporting rape of any type but I think the TM is referring to Indian law which does not recognize marital rape. Meaning no punishment for it. If I remember there was a recent judgment by court of law to this extent. As cringeworthy as it is.
But yes domestic violence is punishable
Edited by nimmu96 - 6 years ago
pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: VARUNI2014

Stop saying nandhini us a rape victim .she is NOT there us a reason why marital rape is not considered rape in many countries ..it's a GREY Area

Trauma in marital rape us different and less compared to brutal gang rape like nirbhaya or child rapes

So don't consider nandhini as rape victim



Rape is rape whether it is marital or otherwise, whether its considered legal or no. It has far reaching consequences to person's self worth, self-respect, dignity and personality irrespective of whether you are married or not. Just because you are married, does not make you immune to your internal feelings. There is no differentiation in the trauma that a rape victim suffers whether she was gang-raped or child rape or just raped, married or otherwise.

You are entitled to express your opinions but please do not make general statement about sensitive and difficult topics and who should be considered a victim or not.
Saazhumsafars thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#15
@SummerRain7 oh.Thank you.Now I am thinking about a woman I know who goes through something like this and trying to compare her dynamics with her husband(whatever I know about or have been told about) to that of nandini with rajdeep.
Edited by Saazhumsafars - 6 years ago
chirpyhapibird thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: SummerRain7

Rape is rape, marital or otherwise. Even if the victim is not showing outward signs of trauma, it does not make the act consensual. A lot of abused people just internalize and normalize the abuse, with the result that they appear normal to everybody.

Also, TM , you are free to think and express your opinion here but please do NOT tell people what to think or do.

@Red
They go about their normal life.Everything will be normal between husband and wife next day.These kind of women actually do things like binge eating,do household work,they will do a 5 min work for 2 hrs.They will prepare food for children but will never care or i say they are not good /strong mother figures.They also fall prey to other men who seem less violent.They dont have any say in any important matters.These things are not counted by people as symptoms of forced sex.Basically they will say aurat hai to yeh sab chalta hai.

Edited by chirpyhapibird - 6 years ago
Cinnamonn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#17
For your information, Any kind of Rape is Rape.
Edited by -Ariaana- - 6 years ago
AnnaSloan thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#18
A rape is a rape, PERIOD. The difference between the two kinds is that a woman (or a man!) of a marital rape has an option to stand up for herself and fight back in a regularly abusive relationship and leave. However, the pain and agony are just as much for a married woman than a normal woman. Yes, one may say that the person gets 'used' to the torture and does not have trauma in comparison to a 'regular' rape victim - however, it is much different.

Marital rape may at times be more horrendous than let's say regular rape because the person who is raping is someone who you and your family have entrusted your life to and you believed in this person, loved this person and they cheated you (like in case of Nandini). While in a 'regular' rape (if only done once) you feel the same pain and torture, but you go through it once and you are not broken by someone you know and believe in. It's more physical while the other one is both physical and emotional.

And let's not bring Nirbhaya and Asifa to define 'rapes' - that are brutal murders and heinous crimes that are way worse than rape. They are done by inhumane people who have pathetic lives! Sexual satisfaction is one thing but what was done with these young girls was barbaric and the idea of a twisted sick mind.

As far as the show is concerned, the writers failed to write an empathizing story for Nandini by rushing into it too fast, otherwise, she would deserve all the sympathy and empathy that a rape and abused woman deserves.

P.S- A woman/man/child raped by a family member suffers incomparable trauma just like any normal rape victim. However, rape victims with unidentified 'rapist' may have more chance of going out and seeking help and justice than when raped by a family member or a loved one. And that is why most rapes go unreported because you are too scared to speak against the family. Thank god, we have people fighting to criminalize marital rape in India. High time!
Edited by AnnaSloan - 6 years ago
kukuraja thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#19
Just because Indian law has taken a regressive stand doesnt mean that Marital Rape is not rape. Yes Marital rape is difficult to prove that is why it is a grey area !! But in this show where it is clearly shown with no doubt that Rajdeep was forcing himself on Bandini, I dont know how anyone can say she was not raped ... unless of course you puposely want that part gone so you can burn the witch'.
vibha28 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#20
This is one of the most ignorant and silliest post I have come across- aren't you lucky that a social media platform allows your misguided thoughts to be opined?

Any kind of sexual relations where one party is not consenting is RAPE!!!!!! PERIOD!!!!!! Indian laws are archiac and regressive that's why they do not recognise martial rape as a criminal offence. The other countries you speak of will cut a person's hand for stealing so that's not much to hold in terms of examples.

Developed first world countries define this perfectly- even sex workers mid sex can say no and that's it. Anything beyond that is rape. Some people enjoy being dominated and role play, which is fine. Two consenting adults can do what they want but when stops that consent then it's rape.

Rape can take away a person's confidence, being raped by s stranger is horrifying but imagine your own husband raping you? You have to live with your rapist - that's worse than anything.
Edited by evenjleena28 - 6 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".