Does Somya deserve Harman and his love? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

54

Views

3.2k

Users

14

Likes

109

Frequent Posters

Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: Shonal8

Yes Hend I don't understand why Surbhi can't meet Harman and find out instead of again going through a contrived way through Varun. The way these CVs minds work is unbelievable.


They just can't do anything straight and clear they want everything with planning and lies and acting

Preeto acting on Harman lies to Harman and Surbhi acting to Varun and lies to Varun

as if everyone is working in secret agencies
Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: sairitu


Dear Hend,
Honestly, i am not a fan of any actor,i didnt even know them before i started watching Shakti.i am a HAYA fan who voices against wrong things in the show .i believe in constructive criticism instead of blindly supporting a character ,no matter what they do.I use to love soumya and harman equally but writers forcing me to dislike soumya by showing her ruthless ,pathetic behavior against harman. some rubina fans here ,thinking that we are haters of soumya or rubina,which is absolutely wrong.we are neutral people who just love HAYA.we are the same fans who criticized harmna's cha ,when he kept quit seeing preeto manhandling soumya .we are the same people ,now criticizing soumya bec she is wrong .

whatever you said is absolutely true.initially ,her anger was justified but now it is getting over the board now as her anger turned into hatred.This is absolutely CV's fault.In the process of stretching the MU,they butchered soumya's character .Which was easily avoided .They could show MU in many ways but not degrading harman's love and her self respect . Calling herself as "BAzar girl" is pathetic and by not answering back to shanno who called her " prostitute " is disgusting .is she strong only for hurting harman? where is the so called changed soumya ? she easily forgives everybody except harman. she easily ignores all taunts and humiliations from others except Harman.i always wanted to see a strong soumya , not only to harman but to everybody.Her reasons to make harman to hate her looks so absurd ,thanks to her less monologues ,people cant even connect with her emotions .
when i saw the yesterday's episode with my mom,her comment shocked me after watching the episode .i am just quoting her words" i wish surbhi didnt divorce harman ,harman would be happy with her as she is so understanding and loving .She truly loved harman once,who could keep him happy than this thankless,selfish ,mean soumya.how many times this poor harman should prove his love for the person who didnt even confess her love ? at one side she is accepting unconditional love from Harman and other side she is keeping conditions to get her love.so cheap female"
i was surprised with her comment and started thinking is this the common viewer opinion abt soumya . once she cried for soumya and now hating her to core.what are CV's trying to do ,do they want viewers slowly hate soumya and than can bring surbhi into harman's life ? As i see majority of shakti viewers disliking soumya .? i am over reacting or guessing it right? i dont know .
I am so scared even to think what will happen in coming episodes and what will they show by the end of this track?


My dear
thank you so much for your lovely reply
like you said we are not talking about actors we are talking about characters

for me I lost my sympathy for Somya long back ago when she started to listen to Preeto and left Harman room and choose to live in servant room I said back then that she deserve all what will she get cause she is the one left Harman hand and left him to accept humiliation but I didn't hate her even in trio track she got me in nerve trying to for Harman to get close to her sister but I gave her excuse that she think she is doing so for his happiness

But in this track I can't find any excuse for her deeds
she just selfish stupid unfaithful person who stab the one who sacrifice everything for her in his heart and enjoy him pain
why?
why all that hate in her eyes
why she looks to him that way
when all he did is to give her rights and see her happy

I just hate her
I really can't imagine what she can do to deserve forgiveness from Harman
how after what all she did and still doing will look at him again when she knows the truth
and what she did there no forgiveness for it

about Surbhi for me I can't accept her either
both sisters don't deserve Harman
they are both selfish
even Surbhi who CVs push viewers to accept her greatness she is selfish she did nothing for her sister and acting as caring one

if it was in my hand I wish Harman marry another girl and live his life normally and keep Somya as his Gulam in house to see what she waste from her hand
this is the only price she should pay for all her bad deeds with Harman
but I'm sure Cvs will not do this cause HaYa is the main core of the show and if they will make him marry another they will make it Surbhi and Surbhi is a burned card now after what they did in trio marriage
Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: soul76


I certainly agree with your comments specifically that if anything is said against Soumya's character people think we hate or dislike Rubina as a person which in my opinion is rather unfair. I have never been more upset with a female character than I am with Soumya. Saari aqal ghaas khaaney gayi Hai iski. For my part I want Soumya to get out of Harman's life rather Harman to throw her out. I can't bear her selfish behavior at all. She needs to live without Harman to actually realize his worth.


But she lived without Harman only month and she got kidnapped and sold in flesh market and still she prefer to be sold to strange man in strange county rather than to be with Harman safe in his house
Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: sairitu


you are absolutely correct.she has already crossed the line of forgiveness .I dont think even after knowing the truth,she will confess her love.All her sensitivity,innocence is dead.she is a ruthless,mean ,selfish person nothing more than that,Sorry,i cant buy her fake love of removing his shoes .Even today,she was so stubborn against harman,didnt bother when he was drinking alcohol like that .How could somebody be so rude for any person? Even i havent seen any female lead like soumya who is extreme in everything,she was extremely sweet and innocent.Now,extremely rude.i think deliberately Cv's making us to hate soumya character ( almost they got succeeded ) ,so that we would accept surbhi in harman's life? As i have no hopes on these idiot writers. i am going to take a break from shakti for few days as i cant this negativity anymore .i just hope this MU comes to an end soon.


I don't know why CVs force us to hate Somya I hope not the reason in your mind it would be disaster
but to tell you the truth there is no logic to make audience hate your lead character
But shakti is beyond any logic or reasns

for me I don't know I will quite the show or not but I think no cause I'm watching the show to enjoy Vivian performance but in this track instead or enjoying the show now watching the show rise my blood pressure and really and can't take it anymore from Somya
Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: anitarani

^^ Exactly...CVs continuing to portray Surbhi as mahaan...

more understanding...sacrificial...everything...and making us
hate Saumya's character...


that make me worry but no mater what they do we can't accept Surbhi
Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: LuvRUBI

This is what irritates me more... I can understand people's anger for saumya but how this surbhi became better than saumya... what mahaanta has this mahaan character shown that she is getting tagged as better life partner for harman n actually when was harman happy with her ??? If ppl want harman to get hooked to some other girl just like preeto then ask for a new girl n.. why this saali-cum-yonger bro's wife?? Stop this khichdi of relationships... plzz...

When we know what kind of great minded writers we have who are master in spoiling every pure relationships n make them so ugly.. then atleast we should respect relationships but it seems before they can show anything like this ppl themselves will invite such craps. I can tolerate any drama but not cheapness in the form of disgusting triangle/reactangle of relationships.. plzzz spare my poor soul...


and who said that we are agree to bring Surbhi back to Harman life
it is not acceptable at all for most of the fans
and it is burned card now they can't use it again
or they would be the most stupid writers in history
sairitu thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Hend_Refai


My dear
thank you so much for your lovely reply
like you said we are not talking about actors we are talking about characters

for me I lost my sympathy for Somya long back ago when she started to listen to Preeto and left Harman room and choose to live in servant room I said back then that she deserve all what will she get cause she is the one left Harman hand and left him to accept humiliation but I didn't hate her even in trio track she got me in nerve trying to for Harman to get close to her sister but I gave her excuse that she think she is doing so for his happiness

But in this track I can't find any excuse for her deeds
she just selfish stupid unfaithful person who stab the one who sacrifice everything for her in his heart and enjoy him pain
why?
why all that hate in her eyes
why she looks to him that way
when all he did is to give her rights and see her happy

I just hate her
I really can't imagine what she can do to deserve forgiveness from Harman
how after what all she did and still doing will look at him again when she knows the truth
and what she did there no forgiveness for it

about Surbhi for me I can't accept her either
both sisters don't deserve Harman
they are both selfish
even Surbhi who CVs push viewers to accept her greatness she is selfish she did nothing for her sister and acting as caring one

if it was in my hand I wish Harman marry another girl and live his life normally and keep Somya as his Gulam in house to see what she waste from her hand
this is the only price she should pay for all her bad deeds with Harman
but I'm sure Cvs will not do this cause HaYa is the main core of the show and if they will make him marry another they will make it Surbhi and Surbhi is a burned card now after what they did in trio marriage


Hend,i have slightly different idea from yours.As i cant see anyone with harman ,cant even tolerate if some other girl stands even close to him😆( we are poor HAYA fans) ,i want him to leave this mad soumya and his evil family .Live peacefully alone.i lost my interest completely on this track as there are going to include surbhi and harman marriage drama next week. i am not going to watch shakti till soumya realizes her mistake but i will be in touch with you all.
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#48
Does Saumya deserve Harman ? Right now Nope she does not deserve him till she realises her mistaks , redeems herself by expressing her love for him and also confesses her love verbally ..

But the question here is not exactly if Saumya deserve Harman or not because in the show right now , Saumya herself believes she dont deserve him or this marriage .. isn't it .. she feels his love is caging her .. so when she herself believe she dont deserve him .. the debate itself dont arise

Instead the question should b does Harman deserve someone like Saumya who dont trust him enough ?? As a angry viewer my instant reaction will b he deserves better and not her ... But from Harman's POV , if we think , then he will literally die without her .. so its a catch 22 situation .. mayb he deserves better but he believes he dont deserve anyone other than Saumya .. so if we say he deserve better , then we r actually going against Harman only 😆 ...

So my conclusion is they both deserve each other because its a HaYa love story at the end of the day .. Harman has proved enough why he deserves Saumya ... Now its Saumya's turn to prove why she deserves Harman but before she proves this , she got to first believe that she actually deserve him which is possible only after the Misunderstanding is sorted out

I know I hv confused everyone here .. but this is what the makers r doing too .. confusing us and playing with our mind and emotions 😉😆


Hend your post is a superhit .. did u realise that 😉 ,. make more such posts for forum activity 😆

Edited by jyoti06 - 8 years ago
Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Does Saumya deserve Harman ? Right now Nope she does not deserve him till she realises her mistaks , redeems herself by expressing her love for him and also confesses her love verbally ..

But the question here is not exactly if Saumya deserve Harman or not because in the show right now , Saumya herself believes she dont deserve him or this marriage .. isn't it .. she feels his love is caging her .. so when she herself believe she dont deserve him .. the debate itself dont arise

Instead the question should b does Harman deserve someone like Saumya who dont trust him enough ?? As a angry viewer my instant reaction will b he deserves better and not her ... But from Harman's POV , if we think , then he will literally die without her .. so its a catch 22 situation .. mayb he deserves better but he believes he dont deserve anyone other than Saumya .. so if we say he deserve better , then we r actually going against Harman only 😆 ...

So my conclusion is they both deserve each other because its a HaYa love story at the end of the day .. Harman has proved enough why he deserves Saumya ... Now its Saumya's turn to prove why she deserves Harman but before she proves this , she got to first believe that she actually deserve him which is possible only after the Misunderstanding is sorted out

I know I hv confused everyone here .. but this is what the makers r doing too .. confusing us and playing with our mind and emotions 😉😆


Hend your post is a superhit .. did u realise that 😉 ,. make more such posts for forum activity 😆


Now you confusing me Joyti

first of all welcome back my dear we missed you so much here


to deserve one it is not about relaization
may be I think I deserve someone but I don't

it is not that I think I deserve someone and act according this realization then I do deserve him

when Harman did all his sacrifice he didn't think I deserve her or not
he just acted
she was kidnapped and he rushed to save her


and before that the best thing in Harman as a husband even when he hated her after the truth revealed he hated her he felt disgust by her he even couldn't stand her touch if she wanted to help him in anything at this time in his peak of anger from her and her mother for hiding the truth
at his peak of hating her and her face her voice
he did his best to protect her from every one and even from his family and his mother
he lied to his family so they don't kick her out
he acted as a happy couple even in front of his won mother who loves the most and consider her as his best friend
at this time he didn't think who deserve who
but he acted

now even if Somya feels she doesn't deserve him at least don't hurt the one who did everything to make you happy

if feels she doesn't deserve him she should talk to him open her heart to him tell him that I must leave you I can't live with the guilt that I can't make you happy or give you normal married life please let me go
and then she can live with his Nani learn something work do a job be independent and the writer be creative to bring them again together by anyway
but not hurting him and stabbing him over and over and over in his heart and listen to any1 but him




Hend_Refai thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: Naaz695

When this track began... I was liking the tashan btwn both of them as it was equal from both the sides ,But now it has turned in to a khichdi wid no head & tail As it was supposed to be a HaYa centric track but our cvs couldn't resist themselves from adding their illogical & useless drama to spoil such a potential track... aur jiska dar tha wohi hua spoiled another track for drama 👏

After they returned from Bangkok Harman turned stern which I wanted him to be...He never reacted harsh or rude towards her earlier it was just once during her truth revelation & that was very normal any guy would react like Harman but after that he never spoke to her in loud tone or behaved rude but wat she did & she's been doing since this track started is not making any sense at all ! 🥱 I was still trying to connect wid her when she was fighting for her identity & staying wid the kinnars that still made sense...But when she chose to auction herself over going wid Harman that's when I started disliking her & lost connect 😕

She wanted to get auctioned & save her identity I didn't get it ...How can u save ur identity by getting auctioned in a flesh market ?😳 it was the most illogical & stupid reason they gave to bring up this track... Ok I was still fine wid it as I thought this will give us a HaYa centric track wid focus on leads & I was enjoying it until I came to know that it's Preeto behind all this another illogical twist to insert Preeto...It would've made more sense if she did it on her own instead of again getting influenced by Preeto which spoiled the track for me 👎🏼 & I couldn't connect wid saumya's character as she again started dancing to preeto's tunes & hurted Harman & wid the episodes passing she's only pissing me off more & more...😵& Her reasons to make him hate her seems baseless 🤔 (for which I think even cvs r somewhere responsible for not giving her proper monologues which is making her look bad ) & when she knows he's not gonna leave her why is she going on hurting him ? That's not gonna get her anything instead she's hurting that person who left the world for him & later she has to repent I can't say she deserves his love or not...But I can't support her actions coz its hurting not only for Harman fans but neutral viewers as well everyone's finding her extremely selfish

Now I'm so fed up wid this track...That I want the MU to clear asap ! & Redemption should happen if there's no redemption after all this...Then its useless 😳 they better give a proper redemption after making us hate her so much, Only that will make me connect with her again It's a MUST !!!


My dear sister
I was against this track from A to Z
but till the end of Bagkok track they were focusing on HaYa
Vivian and Rubina did indescribable job
Rubina in protraying Tarana and Vivian in portrying his anger and his sadness and his pain that Somya left him
so the audience loved the track and the TRP raised so I kept my mouth shut and just enjoyed the ride
but the scene that really hit me and get me on the nerve when she ran away from him in Bangkok not to run from the gang who kidnapped her or not because she feels she doesn't deserve him after what all she did and what happened but to run towards the gang and accept to be sold out
what?
Really?
Are you crazy?
at this scene I really didn't get it
do you prefer to be sold out to any stranger and live with him as a gulam to do whatever he wants to please himself by you and not to go to your husband who protected you from all the world

for me this is only come from cheap girl who preferred to be touched by any stranger rather than her husband
the only excuse I one can give to her that she is naive and doesn't know what will happen to her when she will be sold out
she thought that she will be a servant or something
it is not excuse but just to process what she did in my mind

I thought when they will back to India it will take one or two days and she will realize her mistake and apologize and the next track is how to make Harman forgive her
but no
she still stubborn
she still hurting him over and over and over and even she can't listen to him when he tried to explain

and why you hurting him
why you listen to Preeto
the one who always was bad with you

it just doesn't make any sense
and episode by episode she makes all the audience hate her more and more

and now after all the audience started to talk and trp starting to fall again
they will show her as a sacrificing
what?
last night episode she watched Harman drink to death and even when he was sleeping from alcohol all her looks to him was anger and hate
when she was sleeping she doesn't bear his hand touch her body
she is really hate him
then tonight episode she told him happy anniversary Harman Ji and she cried when he was sleeping

do they make fool of us
we now should believe that she is sacrificing and she is loving him but hiding it from him
after all that happened
after all she did

they will not show redemption or anything
they will make her sacrificing and the moment she knows the truth she will say sorry if she did and Harman will forgive her and nothing will happen they will shift to another problem to solve and another track

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".