A great article that I read which impressed me
R Ashwin's shock retirement announcement actually makes a mockery of Indian cricket. It is tragic that someone of his calibre was struggling to get selected while Kohli kept getting picked without any scrutiny. For all those who want to understand how the utter nonsense that has gone on around Kohli affects a team, they can just look at this instance.
In the same five years where specialist batsman Kohli averaged 32, Ashwin averaged 21.09 with the bat and 20.89 with the ball. A bowling all-rounder who consistently kept his batting average higher than his bowling average (or very close) - to do that over 106 Tests in a 14-year-career (25.8 with the bat and 23.9 with the ball) makes him an all-time-great of the game. But it was Ashwin who was dropped overseas, even in England (where he averages 28 with the ball, so why would he not get picked in June 2025 for the English tour? Jadeja averages 43.5 with the ball in England. Kumble 41. And the great troika? Bedi 38, Chandrasekhar 34, Prasanna 58). Not even once has anyone considered dropping Kohli in ANY conditions (but he, as captain, had no problem dropping Ashwin in England, without any repercussions to his glorious career).
Enough with the "one of India's greatest" copouts from every single cricket commentator and writer (as is their pathetic wont). Let's have the courage (and the smarts) to get more specific. Ashwin is not just India's greatest match-winner, he is the world's greatest Test series winner in history. In January 2017, during the culmination of my Impact Index days, we had identified Ashwin as the highest impact Test cricketer of all time. Please pause on this - the highest impact Test cricketer of all time - this is serious stuff. He had played 44 Tests at the time with a batting average of 35 and a bowling average of 25, which is awe-inspiring on its own. But these numbers were not why. It was purely because of his record in affecting series results. Ashwin had seven Man of the Series awards at the time in 14 series. Just for perspective, Wasim Akram had seven in his career in 43 series, Shane Warne eight in 46 series, Imran Khan eight in 28 series, Jacques Kallis nine in 61 series, and Muttiah Muralitharan eleven in 61 series (at that time). (And in Impact Index, we did not even weigh in Man of the Series awards). Despite Impact Index not existing since 2018, Ashwin's status of the highest impact Test cricketer of all time would not be affected since then, simply because no one else performed with that consistency since then (not even Ben Stokes).
Cued below is a video of Impact Index's book launch where Ashwin was told this (along with the explanation of why he was higher impact than even Bradman) and his reaction, which is rather interesting (there are some other interesting conversations in here too; apologies if it makes you barf at what passes as cricket conversations in the media these days; specifically listen to what VVS Laxman has to say - especially at 39-25).
https://youtu.be/Sa_dw1cUrpE?si=I5vgZ8BYpEvqReuR&t=1011
It doesn't matter how people spin this, it is a tragedy that Ashwin left like this. It was NOT a planned retirement - no one leaves in the middle of a series like this (Dhoni did, but that wasn't planned either, that's another story). Melbourne and Sydney are actually where Ashwin would be in play, more than anywhere else on this tour (he got 5 crucial wickets in his last Melbourne Test in 2020/21, when India won memorably). Fact is, Ashwin deserved the greatest send-off any Indian Test cricketer has ever got - greater than Tendulkar or Kumble. That he didn't get it is one of the greatest failures of Indian cricket. What a shame.
734