feel commiseration towards Simar. - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4.7k

Users

8

Likes

29

Frequent Posters

CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: upra

You started this one by saying that no one can stand in front of Simar if she cam to dance & i completely disgree with the statement. The show may be trying to potray Sim as a good dancer but we the audience have to watch the show correct? I am not buying what the cv's r trying to shove down my throat here & acc to me Simar is a terrible dancer compared to Roli. Roli is by far the prettier and graceful sister even in the show...so when the CV's put dialogues like some Aunty telling Sim that she is looking beautiful is very hard for me as an audience to buy because I have eyes & can tell who is the prettier sister. Here is why the reel scenario seems unreal to me but maybe not to you as you are a simar fan. I watch this show only for Roli & Sid & thats it...not the current track or the rest of the actors.

How can you comment on what Roli would have done or not done? Simar's course of action was wrong here as well as in every other situation..which is why she is in all this trouble all the time. Plus the day Simar iactually ack her mistakes I will start liking her because that is the day she will believe in Roli. Right now she is just worried about saving herself and not correcting her mistakes. Jut my pov.

Also you said you hate to compare actors but you did anyways which is fine by me. I have no issues comparing people as actorsor the characters they potray. Their are multiple reasons why people get lead roles and a big one is comp. i have no desire to discuss Deepika's comp here but that plays a huge role. This is Deepika's 3rd show but acc to me Avika continues to be more popular and famous than Deepika.

same way its hard for me to digest when people say roli is best sister. Even i have real eyes to judge who is best sister. And ofcource dipika is much beautiful compare to avika. Its doesnt matter what she has done in past but now she is giving her best. And there is something which is known as destiny. Avika was lucky that she got balika vadhu and became famous while there was struggle in dipika's life. And she has achieved everything late. Agree with 1 thing that avika is more popular as i always accept the facts.

Like u even i have my point of view. And according to me dipika is much better dancer than avika. Even she acts better than avika. I agree with u that avika is more popular than dipika. But i dont enter in the forum to compare avika and dipika as we r here to discuss about show not to comment on actors. For my favouritism i dont wish to degrade other actors. Today i said so many things on avika just because u was pointing dipika as not good dancer, Lets talk about simar and roli why to get personal in it. You r taking me wrong. I m simar supporter not fan of dipika or simar. I m supporting her coz she is right. One slap dont give u right to portray ur sister as most negative person and assume whatever u want. My POV.

@bold: Yes i started and i think i m not wrong. I was talking about roli cant stand in front of simar. I never said that avika cant stand in front of dipika. And simar is better than roli in dance thats the fact of the show. Let me remind u i'm talking about scripted show not actors.

@red: If u can comment on what simar should have done than even i can comment on what roli would have done.

Hope i m not sounding rude.😊
Edited by -ASTHA- - 13 years ago
upra thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22
@ Astha - each to his own...just like you prefer Simar's character I prefer Roli. Anything we say we will not be able to change each others mind..you will still support Simar & me Roli.
1 thing I would like to say is that Simar's fans underestimate the impact of that slap. Simar slapped her sisterinlaw and not her sister in their inlaws house which is huge and although Simar is lamenting about loosin her sister she is forgetting what a huge insult the slap was for Roli..just my POV.

I like strong female characters like Roli, phulwa, Priya, Khushi, Manvi & Siddhi and not weak characters like Simar & Gopi who actually protect wrong doers in the name of family. sorry just my POV?
Just as you think Simar is a better dancer in the show I am allowed to think that Roli is better as well. See even though the title of the show is SSk , Sim is no longer the only lead...Roli became very prominent probably more so with the marriage of Roli & Prem. The show is the story of 2 sisters and not just 1 sister Simar anymore; as a Simar fan you can disagree with what I am saying but this how I feel.

Also 1 more thing I judge Simar 's actions after she has completed them and not before that wheras you were speculating on what Roli's actions would have been had Simar stopped the dance.

I dont think you were rude and hopefully the feeling is vice versa. We are strong supporters of the characters we like in the show and are standing up for them..so no hard feelings 😊
659287 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23
Roli fans have been start with their stale stories which i am completely fed of. Guys , Keep one thing in mind that Rolia is a source of Negative energy, as long as she is staying in home She would not let things be better . Seems like she is kinda ominous for her Sasural.
upra thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: --P.K.LeLe--

Roli fans have been start with their stale stories which i am completely fed of. Guys , Keep one thing in mind that Rolia is a source of Negative energy, as long as she is staying in home She would not let things be better . Seems like she is kinda ominous for her Sasural.

Which is why Mataji is trying to kick Sim out & not Roli..Simar jaise log jahaan pe bhi rahenge they will ony create a sad envt because of their weepy behaviour so Simar is the source and cause of all negativeness in the show..just my POV.
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: upra

@ Astha - each to his own...just like you prefer Simar's character I prefer Roli. Anything we say we will not be able to change each others mind..you will still support Simar & me Roli.

1 thing I would like to say is that Simar's fans underestimate the impact of that slap. Simar slapped her sisterinlaw and not her sister in their inlaws house which is huge and although Simar is lamenting about loosin her sister she is forgetting what a huge insult the slap was for Roli..just my POV.

Well i agree with u on that point. She was not standing in her mayka when she slapped roli and i m seriously not appreciating simar for that slap. Atleast u should be more logical before performing any action. But roli is not upset because of that slap. She is behaving so weirdly becoz of that college stuff. When simar slapped roli people were asking why she has no faith on her sister? Same way I want to ask why roli has no faith on her sister? Their relation changed into devrani and jeethani after marriage but roli knows simar as elder sister from the first day of her life, Still she dont know that simat cant even think about such filthy and law level things and that also about her own sister. If simar really wish to play these type of game than uma and pari is there who never spared her.

I like strong female characters like Roli, phulwa, Priya, Khushi, Manvi & Siddhi and not weak characters like Simar & Gopi who actually protect wrong doers in the name of family. sorry just my POV?

Disagree with u. Simar is not weak character. She should fight but against whom? She even dont know mataji is behind all these things. First let her know that actually what is happening in house than judge her as strong and weak. Even gopi is not weak as she is presented as illiterate character and we cant expect an illetrate girl to be bold and smart. So she innocent as she dont know about world.

Just as you think Simar is a better dancer in the show I am allowed to think that Roli is better as well. See even though the title of the show is SSk , Sim is no longer the only lead...Roli became very prominent probably more so with the marriage of Roli & Prem. The show is the story of 2 sisters and not just 1 sister Simar anymore; as a Simar fan you can disagree with what I am saying but this how I feel.

Agree this story is now a days looking like 2 sisters. But even i have to even agree that not bidaayi way where both sisters were positive. Its going in sathiya way where simar is positive and roli is becoming negative.(not claiming that roli is negative but its fact)

Also 1 more thing I judge Simar 's actions after she has completed them and not before that wheras you were speculating on what Roli's actions would have been had Simar stopped the dance.

Well simar cant read what is going on in roli's mind. She thought its good to support her in dance but that doesnt mean she want to gain all the credit. Her intentions were pure. And as u r roli fan u would notlike to agree that roli dont wish to see anything good in her sister as she has set in her mind that simar is jealous of her jeethani. No matter how much good simar is behaving but roli just need to find out faults in it. Like small dance matter was turned into competition.

I dont think you were rude and hopefully the feeling is vice versa. We are strong supporters of the characters we like in the show and are standing up for them..so no hard feelings 😊

Edited by -ASTHA- - 13 years ago
upra thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
@Astha: I can also ask you the same question, that how come Simar did not trust Roli why did she not believe Roli. Infact during the heater episode Roli told Simar that " I am your sister and I am telling you that I did put the heater outside and you are still not believing me" and Simar to this date does not believe her. Trust is a 2 way thing & atleast in Roli's case their is concrete evidence against Simar which is why she did not believe her & I ask again whats Simar's excuse?

Simar is a weak character & this is just my POV. She stopped Roli from retaliating against Uma & Pari and in fact stopped Roli from bringing the truth in front of the family. None of the ladies I had mentioned would have done this. Infact Uma, Pari, & Chachi would taunt and take digs at Simar even when Mataji was positive and she never did anything..that in my view is the sign of a weak character.

In SNS Rashi is an extremely selfish character with no background for her negativeness...Roli has a reason for behaving the way she is...so Roli is not negative at all in fact she is bigger victim than Simar. Tons of Simar's actions have been negative so does that mean she is negative as well?

I disagree with you here, had Simar really wanted to help Roli she should have stopped the dance instead of dancing along with Roli especially when relaions are sour.

Hopefully I have addressed all the points you have made😊
sagark thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27
Forget all this yaar, now this track is only revolving between mathaji, manoranjan, simar and roli and its the same old drama. Now the cvs are not showing sid and prem, where are they gone? No scenes of sid roli and prem simar, its getting boring now yaar only kichen politics and the same old dramas and plotting. Am just fedup. This show is gone totally.😡
upra thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: sagark

Forget all this yaar, now this track is only revolving between mathaji, manoranjan, simar and roli and its the same old drama. Now the cvs are not showing sid and prem, where are they gone? No scenes of sid roli and prem simar, its getting boring now yaar only kichen politics and the same old dramas and plotting. Am just fedup. This show is gone totally.😡

True!! I watch this show in fast forward these days soon I will only watch the Rosid scenes on youtube. The story has gone down the drain. How will Mataji redeem herself once this track is over.
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
@ upra
I dont mean that roli broke the trust. After so many things happened no hard feelings from simar. Roli just acted on the base of evidence but she is not witness. I mean she just asked in courier office about the signature but never bother to go and check the hand writing neither she saw simar doing anything against her. She is just assuming didi apni jethani se jalti he. While simar is witness of all those things which is happening against her that also from her own sister. Still she is curious to solve all these things. Mataji is not trying to make only roli against simar but she wish to see both fighting like hell. Its happening with roli but her plan is not working on simar.

In uma and pari matter than she just thought its small matter and why to create mahabharat on it? As lots of things happened in marriage so she was trying to make everything proper. She never thought that it might turn into such big mess.

Many people r claiming that simar is behind proving herself innocent when everything came on her. Previous matters were not big as this one. She can ignore if her jethani dont like her but its hard to ignore when her own sister treating her like hell. Specially her husband has no faith on her. She can easily avoid her jethanis but she cant live if her husband misunderstand her.

And it was her way to help. She realised it later that roli is taking it as competition.
Now we cant expect all maturity from simar only. Even roli has to be mature. Even she can guess that simar was trying to help her to romove all sourness but she bahved completely opposite.
Edited by -ASTHA- - 13 years ago
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
wah bhai wah kya baat hai roli negative hai isliye hai ki roli simar pur believe nahi kar rahi hai aur use bura bhala keh rahi hai .waise tum sub simar fans yeh kyon chahte ho ki roli simar ko support kare aur believe kare?sacchai yeh hai ki jub roli simar ko support karti thi tub bhi tum log roli ko sheepish lady bulate the .durasul roli negative hai ya positive tum simar fans ko roli hai hi nahi pasand and this is the eternal truth

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".