Faisla Karne kaa Adhikaar - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

69

Views

4.2k

Users

16

Likes

186

Frequent Posters

iViews thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: tejeshec


@ red: adhikar milta nahin hai adhikar liya jaata hai.. For that Rano should do something where she can be trusted with. U can't ask someone who is bad at Math to do accounts..Same here..BM and Alok take all decisions cuz they deserve that job as simple as that. Its not that this decision was taken behind her back. She could have raised this point at that time


Tejesh , I 'll say one thing My Mom said , Time was different than My Mom didn't make decision regarding us Bcauz My Dadaji Made them . Doesn't necessarily means they were RIGHT one . She wanted to give us more than What V got . It was her RIGHT as a Mother . When in past she tried to say My Dad shut her up saying My Dada had a right to make one as he is the eldest . What my Mom wanted was They hear what she had to say .
By the time She got the right , V were almost old enough to make one our selves. Now , She made peace with the past but I have seen My own Mother's ghutan for Astitva. She lets my SIL all sorts of decisions regarding House , Kids everything so She can express her self & She can use her voice .
Dadaji gave Adhikar or ask BM regarding Decisions but They all ignored Rano bcauz of her crying . They all thought She is weak [ mind ] to make one.
Rano never ask her Adhikar as It is not something U can ask but It is not something that U never give anyone to either . Dadaji never gave enough importance to Rano's voice .
crysind thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: netri


Tejesh , I 'll say one thing My Mom said , Time was different than My Mom didn't make decision regarding us Bcauz My Dadaji Made them . Doesn't necessarily means they were RIGHT one . She wanted to give us more than What V got . It was her RIGHT as a Mother . When in past she tried to say My Dad shut her up saying My Dada had a right to make one as he is the eldest . What my Mom wanted was They hear what she had to say .
By the time She got the right , V were almost old enough to make one our selves. Now , She made peace with the past but I have seen My own Mother's ghutan for Astitva. She lets my SIL all sorts of decisions regarding House , Kids everything so She can express her self & She can use her voice .
Dadaji gave Adhikar or ask BM regarding Decisions but They all ignored Rano bcauz of her crying . They all thought She is weak [ mind ] to make one.
Rano never ask her Adhikar as It is not something U can ask but It is not something that U never give anyone to either . Dadaji never gave enough importance to Rano's voice .


@Bold Red... 👍🏼 Completely agree...
tejeshec thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: netri

Rano never ask her Adhikar as It is not something U can ask but It is not something that U never give anyone to either . Dadaji never gave enough importance to Rano's voice .



My Maasi has 3 sons. Maasi always sends her eldest son to buy vegetables from market not cuz she is showing partiality in giving only him the responsibility but she did give a chance or 2 to her other children but were found inept in selecting/identifying fresh vegetables.

Dadaji never gave enough importance only when it came to decision making (not in every aspect ) to Rano only cuz he felt she was not capable (as per her character shown in the serial)

I never said Rano should ask for Adhikar. Adhikar is something u need to take on u'r own. When Alok and BM gave Ishaan permission, Rano should have said I will not send my son. I am sure Ishaan wouldn't have left just cuz BM said yes. He would have then made Rano agree. Thats how it works. If u keep agreeing with what others say then u will lose u'r individuality as well. Rano has become a laughing stock in that house and only n only she is to blame for her current state
Edited by tejeshec - 13 years ago
MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
Two sides of the argument are strong...I will wait and see who has stamina to keep up with it and then join forces. 🤣
tejeshec thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: MadameX

Two sides of the argument are strong...I will wait and see who has stamina to keep up with it and then join forces. 🤣



UD I don't need you. Thank you🤣
MadameX thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
You are too weak and powerless without me. 🤣
But on a serious note, you raised good points and so did Netri so I'm unsure which one is the stronger side. 😆 I shall wait until maybe I'll have an argument that will knock both of you out. 🤣
tejeshec thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: MadameX

You are too weak and powerless without me. 🤣

But on a serious note, you raised good points and so did Netri so I'm unsure which one is the stronger side. 😆 I shall wait until maybe I'll have an argument that will knock both of you out. 🤣



its not about knocking out u'r opponent sweetie its about participating in healthy discussions😆
Diivi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
i hav to say dat,rano ws right to quite a gud extend today🤔..whatever she told ws straight frm her heart..
Rano,as we knw has a very soft heart nd she is in a way little immature in making decisions,compared to BM...bt d decision of letting ishan go to mumbai ws taken by BM nd Alok alone
😲..dadaji ws also complaining abt dis in a past epi..
being ishaans mom,rano has d right to think nd take part in deciding abt his son's life..Bm nd alok shud hav atleast included her in d disussion
😔..

i wud not critisise BM fr dis coz,in her mind nd othrs mind lso rano is 'choti
😕' nd she wud hav thought dat rano will not be able to make such a hard decision..

still,in MPOV Rano shud hav bn included in atleast d discussions for deciding wthr ishan shud go to mumbai or not
🤓..it ws like 'out of d blue' Bm nd alok decided to let ishaan go to mumbai..

PS-- it ws really brilliant of CVs to include such a part,coz sumthin like wud hav happened to any joint family..whn d decision ws taken by 1 or 2 individuals..nd it ws a very realistic thought to bring up such a matter..

Edited by Diivi - 13 years ago
infinity00 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
Excellent post Netri and I would say excellent scene by Shruti, absolutely spot on ! I can relate with her completely, it really hurts when your husband ignores your opinion, Alok doesnt ignores her needs but yes as a life partner he always expected her to stand besides him while he makes /takes decesion with BM , Rano fully supported never said anything as she thought she is being good wife by going along with what Alok decided, that doesnot mean that she does not have any opinion, I really loved the line when she said " Atay mai Namak Kitna dalna hai " . I agree with every word she said, she did not complained about BM directly nor she was questioning her authorities she was questioning her own identity. Being a mother I can see and feel how she must be feeling, as my mother, my dadi, my nani they all have been thorugh this, its not easy. The question is not that Rano would have stopped Ishaan, the question is she should have been heard as well, she is saying now that she would have not send Ishaan , but if Ishaan would have asked her " Kay Mujhay Janaa he hai " then she would have no other choice then saying yes, Ishaan had made up his mind to go, he would have gone eventually , but the question she raised was right , that where do I stand ??? I would like to congratulate SGP team to bring this wonderful scene, I bet there are different people who write different scene as its hard to imagine the same people are writting Sanju and Deepak track !!
zackey_boy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20
I am 200% sure that a person like Rano has no complaints with Badi Maa and Alok taking major decisions...Regarding any matter..

But yes, the decision of sending Ishaan to mumbai came as a surprise even to Rano ( for God's sake, she is his mother)...I mean how could Alok and Badi Maa can can take this decision without consulting Rano...Although they took the right decision but instead of telling it to whole family straightaway, they should have first consulted Rano and if Rano had objections, both of them could have easily made her understand the importance of Ishaan's mumbai trip..

And its not wrong too. Personally speaking, my mom makes sure that she is there in all major decisions of my life, even if when she is not required in some of the matters..But still its her right and no one can do anything about it.

But yes, BM and Alok made a mistake of not including Rano in the decision making and that too on the matter of his dear son..

But yes, Rano could have curbed her anger and she should have said things that are related only to Ishaan and not other things.. They were unecessary
Edited by zak_ris - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".