Crisp Bytes 11th Oct 13- updated - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

120

Views

10.3k

Users

33

Likes

694

Frequent Posters

ShanUlas thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: happychappy


This is the most beautiful interpretation I have read so far, L.i.D. !! Thanks ever so much...šŸ¤—
Love the way you correlated it with the agni of the shaadi (separation of Samud as lovers), the havan (meeting again as "strangers across the fire"), and now the punar-milan (who dares separate them now?)


TBH, while I am happy-happy about the Samud-milan as anyone else, the execution ws not on the same level as either the shaadi sequence or the havan scenes (both of which moved me to tears)
I tried re-watching the rescue scene but it still felt quite "cold"...😲 Was it with with the eyeline match or actor fatigue or just poor editing? I didnt feel the intensity, or maybe practical me was just not into seeing the intensity when I'd rather they got out of danger asap instead of having mute conversations..

Dont want to sound churlish, Am truly Grateful that the story has taken this turn!!šŸ˜› It's just that I can imagine the earlier team wd have turned out something exquisite... Divine, even...😳




i am really surprised that u did not feel the heat we felt during the scene .It was one of those filmy scenes where u dont need to get moved but to just be excited and clap ...while SC anthem plays in BGšŸ˜†...and i did the same ...watched and rewatched it agin...and giggled...agree it was not a moving scene that brings tears...as u mentioned many previous scene have been...why coz ...it was never meant to be so...it was just a high point where hero saves the heroin with fire drama musik...

saras expressions were more of a fire fighter working hard to save a victim rather then that of a lover...and kumud was in just one mode...manne maaf kar do ...manne maaf kar do sarasšŸ˜†

.the best is yet to come on monday ...and i promise then sure we will feel the seething samud passion
Edited by ShanUlas - 11 years ago
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
Kumud to Saras


Credit : Internet
pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ShanUlas



i am really surprised that u did not feel the heat we felt during the scene .It was one of those filmy scenes where u dont need to get moved but to just be excited and clap ...while SC anthem plays in BGšŸ˜†...and i did the same ...watched and rewatched it agin...and giggled...agree it was not a moving scene that brings tears...as u mentioned many previous scene have been...why coz ...it was never meant to be so...it was just a high point where hero saves the heroin with fire drama musik...

saras expressions were more of a fire fighter working hard to save a victim rather then that of a lover...and kumud was in just one mode...manne maaf kar do ...manne maaf kar do sarasšŸ˜†

.the best is yet to come on monday ...and i promise then sure we will feel the seething samud passion

The scene was very intense in my opinion and far better than many of their scenes where Jen siffens up her muscles so tight.
The scene where they look at each other after he engulfs her with blanket. Fire around them. They as if united by fire. Their looks were awesome. The silent apology, the acknowledgement and then the empathy from Saras were brilliant. This was a scene where not just one of them but both were in danger and turmoil. And they came out with flying colours. Just my POV.
pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Arshics

Kumud to Saras



Credit : Internet

Wah Arshi. Kya baat hai. Remember our analogy. Saraswatichandra is the moon. Moon is supposed to shower nectar. And Kumud is the water lily that blooms only at night. Their names match so well. And their lives too.
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: pasumarthisa

Wah Arshi. Kya baat hai. Remember our analogy. Saraswatichandra is the moon. Moon is supposed to shower nectar. And Kumud is the water lily that blooms only at night. Their names match so well. And their lives too.


I came across while browsing the net and immediately thought of Saras and Kumud. So I had to post it here
Mrieshka thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Arshics

Mreishka, you cannot make more than 10 posts in a day, otherwise there is no limitation.

So post on, dear.

Infact after first 50 posts your status will change and limit will also increase






Thanks very much Arshiji for letting me know the details. I thought I am allowed total 10. You, your CB and all the writers/ members here are awesome!!!.
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ShanUlas


i am really surprised that u did not feel the heat we felt during the scene .It was one of those filmy scenes where u dont need to get moved but to just be excited and clap ...while SC anthem plays in BGšŸ˜†...and i did the same ...watched and rewatched it agin...and giggled...agree it was not a moving scene that brings tears...as u mentioned many previous scene have been...why coz ...it was never meant to be so...it was just a high point where hero saves the heroin with fire drama musik...

saras expressions were more of a fire fighter working hard to save a victim rather then that of a lover...and kumud was in just one mode...manne maaf kar do ...manne maaf kar do sarasšŸ˜†

.the best is yet to come on monday ...and i promise then sure we will feel the seething samud passion


Originally posted by: pasumarthisa

The scene was very intense in my opinion and far better than many of their scenes where Jen stiffens up her muscles so tight. The scene where they look at each other after he engulfs her with blanket. Fire around them. They as if united by fire. Their looks were awesome. The silent apology, the acknowledgement and then the empathy from Saras were brilliant. This was a scene where not just one of them but both were in danger and turmoil. And they came out with flying colours. Just my POV.


I guess this just shows how differently how each of us sees the same show and comes up with different experiences of it... For me, it was not one of their intense moments and I was not surprised given the circs of the scene, so I was puzzled when I read about the passion that other people had noticed...😊

Shana, your "fire-fighter" analogy cracked me up..šŸ˜† That is so spot on.

Santhi, thanks for "illuminating" that part, it's interesting how the connects can be so obvious to you and not me. Hope I am not stuck with this disconnect for future scenes as well...šŸ˜›


Edited by happychappy - 11 years ago
hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Happy-

Came back today from vacation and one of the first things I did was check out the epi...

Halleluah!...someone agrees with me...I too did not feel the intensity of the connect...read somewhere that smrth too felt the same...So I guess to each his own!

I felt the CVs have rushed this through...so many things happening in 20 mins:.
- Alak finally picking her side with Kumud...(very faint throwback to the novel where Alakkumari in BD was Kumud's true friend with empathy at her plight)

- Pramad_Kalika games

- Pramad trying to woo Kumud

- Pramad exasperation

- Pramad trying to kill Kumud...This was the most illogical scene of the whole epi!...
1) Off hand I can think of at least 5 different ways he could have killed kumud cleanly & neatly...dunno why he had to do it in such a messy way...what happened to the small knife he had shown Kalika in the previous epi!!
2) Read in some WU that he had wanted Kalika to find out some stuff of Saras and plant it in the room...when did he plant it?
3) If it was not planted...then the whole assumption of saras coming back to kill Kumud is heresay without any evidence...What was he thinking?
4) He got away cleanly without Saras seeing him leave with Kumud (in epi beginning)...no one knows where he's gone...not even Alak...Then why the hell did he have to send Kalika back and try to route him to some other address!!!!!!!! THIS is the raison d'etre of saras being able to find Kumud...Why did he have to do that ?????
5) Saras did not look even slightly threatening when with Kalika...when he should have been shown in a position which scares the shit out of Kalika and forces her to give him the correct address...
6) When Saras punches him the first time...the door just falls off!!...Even Kumud could have done that and walked away free!!

- Kumud selfrealization

- Saras_Pramad fist fight

- Saras_Kumud seeking forgiveness / giving forgiveness

- Saras_Kumud rescue itself

The direction was too rushed

- Again the CVs succumbed to the easy way out...Om Shanti Om scene copy...What man!!...they are not even imaginative enough to come up with a decent murder attempt!!!... Or just plain lazy most likely!!... How can candles cause such a roaring flame?

Methinks...the CVs completed their TVT exercises and realized that they have milked the current level of TVTs for all its is worth from all the rona-dhona ...and the next level will come from the Samud story getting resurrected!

So in the same way they had massacred the original story for the current track in double quick time, they will now swing the pendulum the other way equally quick!...

...Expect them to now show Samud in love but now seperated by society & samaj

Sadly, the expectations / bar had been set so low that we feel gratified just by seeing Samud together...

Where is the emotional kick of elation and relief duly supported by the build-up?... Unfortunately, I couldn't find it...

It was not even a seeti-maro scenario...Typically even seeti-maro scenarios are either so OTT that they cause that reaction all the time ...Or they are usually built on a great emotional build-up ...such that when the pieces fall to what you as the viewer desire it causes the said reaction...
this was neither...sort of half-way from both approaches..

So net-net...good that from saras & kumud perspective one chapter is now closed ... Mr. Ehsaas is back!...

As for me... will wait for the next CB resurrection to start watching again...




Edited by hotdogg - 11 years ago
Infofan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: hotdogg

Happy-

Came back today from vacation and one of the first things I did was check out the epi...

Halleluah!...someone agrees with me...I too did not feel the intensity of the connect...read somewhere that smrth too felt the same...So I guess to each his own!


I felt the CVs have rushed this through...so many things happening in 20 mins:.
- Alak finally picking her side with Kumud...(very faint throwback to the novel where Alakkumari in BD was Kumud's true friend with empathy at her plight)

- Pramad_Kalika games

- Pramad trying to woo Kumud

- Pramad exasperation

- Pramad trying to kill Kumud...This was the most illogical scene of the whole epi!...
1) Off hand I can think of at least 5 different ways he could have killed kumud cleanly & neatly...dunno why he had to do it in such a messy way...what happened to the small knife he had shown Kalika in the previous epi!!
2) Read in some WU that he had wanted Kalika to find out some stuff of Saras and plant it in the room...when did he plant it?
3) If it was not planted...then the whole assumption of saras coming back to kill Kumud is heresay without any evidence...What was he thinking?
4) He got away cleanly without Saras seeing him leave with Kumud (in epi beginning)...no one knows where he's gone...not even Alak...Then why the hell did he have to send Kalika back and try to route him to some other address!!!!!!!! THIS is the raison d'etre of saras being able to find Kumud...Why did he have to do that ?????
5) Saras did not look even slightly threatening when with Kalika...when he should have been shown in a position which scares the shit out of Kalika and forces her to give him the correct address...
6) When Saras punches him the first time...the door just falls off!!...Even Kumud could have done that and walked away free!!

- Kumud selfrealization

- Saras_Pramad fist fight

- Saras_Kumud seeking forgiveness / giving forgiveness

- Saras_Kumud rescue itself

The direction was too rushed

- Again the CVs succumbed to the easy way out...Om Shanti Om scene copy...What man!!...they are not even imaginative enough to come up with a decent murder attempt!!!... Or just plain lazy most likely!!... How can candles cause such a roaring flame?

Methinks...the CVs completed their TVT exercises and realized that they have milked the current level of TVTs for all its is worth from all the rona-dhona ...and the next level will come from the Samud story getting resurrected!

So in the same way they had massacred the original story for the current track in double quick time, they will now swing the pendulum the other way equally quick!...

...Expect them to now show Samud in love but now seperated by society & samaj

Sadly, the expectations / bar had been set so low that we feel gratified just by seeing Samud together...

Where is the emotional kick of elation and relief duly supported by the build-up?... Unfortunately, I couldn't find it...

It was not even a seeti-maro scenario...Typically even seeti-maro scenarios are either so OTT that they cause that reaction all the time ...Or they are usually built on a great emotional build-up ...such that when the pieces fall to what you as the viewer desire it causes the said reaction...
this was neither...sort of half-way from both approaches..

So net-net...good that from saras & kumud perspective one chapter is now closed ... Mr. Ehsaas is back!...

As for me... will wait for the next CB resurrection to start watching again...



Sir ji, back from vacation?

@ blue - make that 3 of us. Did not feel the connect. I was thinking ' its me, its not you Samud or SC'. 😃

The entire thing was so rushed with complete logic ki vaats. Where was the fire when Saras just walked out carrying Kumud? She could have walked out by herself !!!!

Everyone was so excited about the episode. Ivy was unwell yet took time to make a detailed post on episode analysis, I didnt want to spoil the mood so kept quiet.😳

@ Red - true sadly. Ditto to the entire post.
annete thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Jab pyar ki nazar se unhhey dekte dekha,
Paani ki tarah beh geya barson ka gilaa bhi.

internet

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".