Thappad-E-Azam - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

59

Views

5.1k

Users

14

Likes

185

Frequent Posters

Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: pasumarthisa



Hum kahan se kahan aa gaye.

Saras ki galti se kumud ki galti tak. Yeh safar kya zaroori thaa kumud aur Saras ko milaane ke liye?

But in original Saras was not this responsible and Kumud this stupid.

Dont know why I dont feel sad about the thappad. Because I feel Saras can take it in his stride and wont care that much? And he knows that she doesnt know the reality(by that time he would have known Pramad's conspiracy with Kalika) so he might forgive and forget.

Kumud saying, 'Ye Khushiyon ko meri hi nazar na lag jaaye' is still coming to my thought. She is able to feel the khushi now.

My question is, is this the only way for Kumud to get closer to Saras. By falling and then realizing?


Santhi, baat thappad ki nahi hai. do baatein hain.

Both you have actually touched upon.

First is the treatment - the original source connect is lost, but even with that had they shown a Saras trying to convince a conflicted Kumud about her husbands duplicity, there is so much scope for good drama.

But yeh melodrama, yeh thappad, yeh Kumud ki pramaad Bhakti is very unconvincing.

Second is the relationship between Saras and Kumud themselves, they have come such a long way, walked through fire literally, so a thappad drama also doesn't gel well here. Esp so soon after the man got his shradh done. Again cvs seem to be opting for cheap drama instead of an emotional drama.

Rahi baat " ye khushiyon ko Meri nazar ... " it was such a misplaced dialogue. In just a couple of pramaad sudhar days, with the sword of Navin aka Saras truth hanging, the dialogue makes no sense. Poor writing, here.

Also, in the chess scene, dukhba wants VC to give neg to damaad ji, as it is shashthi. Wasn't it the first Day of navratri? Why did she say shashthi? Any thoughts on that?
pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: Arshics


Santhi, baat thappad ki nahi hai. do baatein hain.

Both you have actually touched upon.

First is the treatment - the original source connect is lost, but even with that had they shown a Saras trying to convince a conflicted Kumud about her husbands duplicity, there is so much scope for good drama.

But yeh melodrama, yeh thappad, yeh Kumud ki pramaad Bhakti is very unconvincing.

Second is the relationship between Saras and Kumud themselves, they have come such a long way, walked through fire literally, so a thappad drama also doesn't gel well here. Esp so soon after the man got his shradh done. Again cvs seem to be opting for cheap drama instead of an emotional drama.

Rahi baat " ye khushiyon ko Meri nazar ... " it was such a misplaced dialogue. In just a couple of pramaad sudhar days, with the sword of Navin aka Saras truth hanging, the dialogue makes no sense. Poor writing, here.

Also, in the chess scene, dukhba wants VC to give neg to damaad ji, as it is shashthi. Wasn't it the first Day of navratri? Why did she say shashthi? Any thoughts on that?



Arshi,

I meant to say a month ago it was Saras's mistake. Now that mistake is almost gone and he is redeemed. And Kumud ki baari hai. Quite a turnaround.


I fully agree that the thappad is misplaced even if we view from any angle. Coming on the back of Shraadh. Wonder how she is viewing his help at that point. She thinks its just interference?

And regarding the 'Shashthi' mention, I think its due to the SC calendar. I used to follow another serial and by now know that TV shows have their own calendar and it has no rule and rhyme. Take the earlier KArwa chauth scene.




Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: pasumarthisa




Arshi,

I meant to say a month ago it was Saras's mistake. Now that mistake is almost gone and he is redeemed. And Kumud ki baari hai. Quite a turnaround.


I fully agree that the thappad is misplaced even if we view from any angle. Coming on the back of Shraadh. Wonder how she is viewing his help at that point. She thinks its just interference?

And regarding the 'Shashthi' mention, I think its due to the SC calendar. I used to follow another serial and by now know that TV shows have their own calendar and it has no rule and rhyme. Take the earlier KArwa chauth scene.







but even in SC calendar the mataji ki moorti ki is yet to be brought. So it hasto be day1 of navratri.

shoddy writing again where the writers have no idea of what they are writing.
pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Arshics




but even in SC calendar the mataji ki moorti ki is yet to be brought. So it hasto be day1 of navratri.

shoddy writing again where the writers have no idea of what they are writing.



Wow I forgot the fact that Pramad didnt bring the murti yet. Good catch.

Or some celebrate in a big way only from Shashthi. Anyways, its very loosely written.


annete thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#45
isnt shashti the sixth day of navratri (before kalratri) the day mahishasura reached heavens to overthrow the Gods ...maa Katyayani daughter of sage katyayana is worshipped on this day..she is the daughter form of durga and epitomizes love...worshipped by gopis to get a husband like krishna in vraj also called queen of vraj...she battles evil and decietful entities relentlessly...her devotion and faith leads to dharma ,artha,kama and moksha...it is also a day of self realization of the shakti within us (ma kayayani has three eyes )...also marks the end of the demons shumbh n nishumbh (greed and lust )...not difficult to guess that kumud is the shakti daughter of the sage ,VC, not yet awakened by the trinity,saras, to end mahishasura,pramaad, and his army of asuras...kalika,umeesh...who have reached the gates of heaven,ratnanagiri...


ps; murti has been bought ,though the sthapana was not shown
Edited by annete - 11 years ago
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: annete

isnt shashti the sixth day of navratri (before kalratri) the day mahishasura reached heavens to overthrow the Gods ...maa Katyayani daughter of sage katyayana is worshipped on this day..she is the daughter form of durga and epitomizes love...worshipped by gopis to get a husband like krishna in vraj also called queen of vraj...she battles evil and decietful entities relentlessly...her devotion and faith leads to dharma ,artha,kama and moksha...it is also a day of self realization of the shakti within us (ma kayayani has three eyes )...also marks the end of the demons shumbh n nishumbh (greed and lust )...not difficult to guess that kumud is the shakti daughter of the sage ,VC, not yet awakened by the trinity,saras, to end mahishasura,pramaad, and his army of asuras...kalika,umeesh...who have reached the gates of heaven,ratnanagiri...


ps; murti has been bought ,though the sthapana was not shown



wow annete that is a great post for all of us whose knowledge of navratri iz very sketchy.

so can we hope for end of asuras by dushehra?
annete thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#47
hopefully unless Cvs decide to turn Pramaad into Ravana and Saras and Danny are banished sansSita maiya...mishmash i say even Ramayana will be rewrtten...😆
Edited by annete - 11 years ago
twila thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: annete

isnt shashti the sixth day of navratri (before kalratri) the day mahishasura reached heavens to overthrow the Gods ...maa Katyayani daughter of sage katyayana is worshipped on this day..she is the daughter form of durga and epitomizes love...worshipped by gopis to get a husband like krishna in vraj also called queen of vraj...she battles evil and decietful entities relentlessly...her devotion and faith leads to dharma ,artha,kama and moksha...it is also a day of self realization of the shakti within us (ma kayayani has three eyes )...also marks the end of the demons shumbh n nishumbh (greed and lust )...not difficult to guess that kumud is the shakti daughter of the sage ,VC, not yet awakened by the trinity,saras, to end mahishasura,pramaad, and his army of asuras...kalika,umeesh...who have reached the gates of heaven,ratnanagiri...


ps; murti has been bought ,though the sthapana was not shown





annette ...


Thanks for the above info... 😊
KK84 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#49
ab kya umeed kar saktey hai...shraat hogaya toh yeh thappad kya cheez hai...perhaps ek aur kasam dedi saras ne? 'tujhe meri kasam Kumud, tumhe mujhe thappad maarna parega!!'
waisey bhi indian serials are not complete until the heroine slaps someone! lol!
I just want Saras to leave and go make something of his life to prove his dad that he was able to stand on his feet. Jab dad milenge and poochenge 'kya kiya tune after disowning me'...Saras bolega..'kuch khaas nahi...did some choogli at Kumud's sasural, got my shraath done and got a chaata from Kumud!!'
This is what they have reduced my poor Saras to.
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: KK84


ab kya umeed kar saktey hai...shraat hogaya toh yeh thappad kya cheez hai...perhaps ek aur kasam dedi saras ne? 'tujhe meri kasam Kumud, tumhe mujhe thappad maarna parega!!'

waisey bhi indian serials are not complete until the heroine slaps someone! lol!
I just want Saras to leave and go make something of his life to prove his dad that he was able to stand on his feet. Jab dad milenge and poochenge 'kya kiya tune after disowning me'...Saras bolega..'kuch khaas nahi...did some choogli at Kumud's sasural, got my shraath done and got a chaata from Kumud!!'
This is what they have reduced my poor Saras to.



ishq ne ghalib nikamma bana diya humko

varna hum bhi aadmi the kaam ke

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".