Crisp Bytes SC - 23rd Aug 13 - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

80

Views

7.8k

Users

19

Likes

312

Frequent Posters

hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: IdiotViewer

Apologies again for bringing previous discussion to current CB... Aadat se majboor, Arshi ji 😳 :

Hgg Bhai: *standing-frickin-ovation* to your foresight. And the way you present that. Awestruck. A query - after today's epi, how much will you quantify the 'reveal' as? From what I watched, Kumud talked about Saraswati & her chandra only. Not about her & Saras... Or were we supposed to infer that she has told him the entire story? If I was Pramad, I'd be left cheated by the 'big reveal' and left 'wanting'. Not to mention that his mind has already been poisoned by umess... Who knows what all the sick inspector told him? Or on second thoughts, K was being a clever girl. He asked who is Saraswatichandra? And she told him Mother-Son story because that is really who SC is. His Mother's son. But in terms of jigsaw pieces, P has just been handed some by Kumud, others by Kalika & some by Saras himself from Precap. He has started joining pieces together. He too is a clever boy.

Happy & kaadal... My friends, my pleasure for giving you some positivity, but I must also issue a disclaimer: Markers are just that, markers. They are never absolute, but rather merely one interpretation that you or I can take from the way they are presented. I could just as easily be wrong, but the way I'm reading current markers is all to do with the way they fit within my overall understanding... They fit in my larger building blocks. And I'm very flexible with the smaller building blocks. I don't hesitate to throw them out. But for now, I stand firm on my interpretation that Pramad is up to no good. Today's epi gave further markers to underscore that... But have to go out now. Will get back to this later =)



Ivy-

I would say 50%...

Yes...kumud is a smart girl. She answered to the point and essentialy clarifiying only why her rishta got broken...This answer can satisfy BD, Alak, Pramad and everyone else satisfactorily. It will align with what Umesh also told him..

She did not hint or reveal whether they were romantically or physically involved. The intensity of their feelings, PMS etc. is only known to both of them, Gumaan & Guniyal. So that connect is for kalika to piece together and detonate...

The question when it does explode is whether Pramad will feel she told him only half of the story and get more angry due to a sense of getting cheated?...remember kalika has already stirred the pot with him.

On Pramad i guess the CVs haven't decided which way to play him. I expected some markers yesterday, but he's still on the fence for now..

In the current state, the exposure will be like a red flag to a raging bull to Pramad...Imagine his perspective:
1) He resents Daddy but is dependent on Daddy which increases his resentment ...sort of like an infinite feedback loop...
2) Daddy manages the cash flow to him.
3) Daddy orders his life.
4) Daddy gets him married without him having any choice in the matter...increase in #1 due to #2 & #3.

NOW
5) Daddy instantly replaces him with a person whom he found on the road...increase in #1
6) Daddy openly compares him with 'naukar' and says he wishes Pramad was like 'naukar'...super high spike in #1...he is what he is largely due to #3...Did Daddy be so caring & understanding when he needed him to be? With him he seems to have always been dismissive. Daddy has played favorites between him & Alak. (Lot of what Kalika said about him applicable here)

THEN
7) He comes to know that 'nauker' was the wife's old flame...

Imagine the loud W*F scream coming from Pramad at this realization...
- Daddy forced him to get married to a virtuous Kumud...against his wishes...who has a holier than thou attitude...and condescending approach towards him...who is the old flame and who had PMS with the 'nauker'...the 'nauker' who was forced into his world by Daddy...who usurped his son relationship with Daddy...and both his dear holy wife and 'nauker' were together for days in his home...and pretending they did not know each other...

We have #1 going to infinity here...because of #1 TO #6 all going into an infinite feedback loop...


Then what's he gonna do???
Take a gun and shoot everyone down starting with Daddy or take a gun and shoot himself!

Forget where his current character stands... if we gave benefit of doubt of a shitty childhood to saras behaviour...iska bhi kuch haq banta hai...

...we should give some benefit of doubt to his perspective also...all his drinking & rage is a desperate attempt to break the restricting shackles of his circumstances...all the more poignant because he probably does not inherently have any great personal capabiltity to redeem himself in his father's expectations...

...this cross of super high parental expectations misaligned to the child's innate capabilities is a huge burden to bear...

...and here I actually begin to like kalika...if her affection for him is real...these two are so very similar...forever relegated to a second-class citizenship status - one by birth and one by lack of capability..

...no wonder they found each other when young in the otherwise teeming BD social universe and survived to adulthood. ...she mentions 13 years...pramad would have been a kid of 10-12 at that time!... ..both have complementary capabilities...kalika's lack of power due to her birth is complemented by pramad (notice all the emphasis on 'chote seth ko bata doongi') and pramad's lack of capability is complemented by kalika's social savvy and street smartness...

...So no wonder kalika is so possessive...she took him in when no one would...and now a first class citizen just expects him to be returned back...just because she has married him...and who is still so condescending towards him...

... and without him she loses everything...so its a fight to the death here!

This is like a greek tragegy...with the greys... and where once you get to know the villians..they invoke pity rather than hatred!

This is one of the reasons for my rant on saras...there is so much to be explored on pramad / kalika...and we get the same crap scene like Khana Kha Lena...

I just wish they move this forward...and really develop Pramad...his character is now so much more interesting than anyone else...and Anshul is a damn good actor who I think can pull this off...

But if wishes were horses...
😔



Edited by hotdogg - 12 years ago
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: pasumarthisa

...

Kumud revealing her past. Didnt like it at all. The emphasis on his dad's affair. It started in yesterday's episode with Saras being very attached to his mom and ended with he being broken due to his dad's affair. There is no other mention. Not that other facts had to be revealed but the whole thing didnt gel well. Looked as if it was done by Kumud just to dig a deeper hole. Pramaad though got the point. But it did have Kumud's acceptance and forgiveness towards Saras written all over...

But what a way to open up those feelings. To Pramaad. That was a terribly written scene. This could have been a very very poignant, touching moment if she said it to someone from her maaika who could understand her. It was said to Pramad who could only look for lack of love in that statement.

...

Kumud has intuition about something going wrong with both Saras and Pramaad going together...

Santhi, they did show Saras in the pre-cap doing something unexpected, out-of-character! Opening up to Pramaad(!) about his own love life... Cant think of any reason why he wd do that - they are the opposite of bosom buddies...😲 Maybe the Kusum+Kumud combo (one barrage of accusation+one measure of kindness) just caused Saras to become momentarily mentally unstable?

And Pramad - is he the local relationship counsellor ? First to Kumud, then to Saras, "tell me about..."🤣

If Saras says something about his mum to P, (not knowing what Kumud has said) then that will be the last piece of the jigsaw...👏 in advance! But going by pre-cap track record, there will be flirting with danger but no lasting damage..😔


Edited by happychappy - 12 years ago
hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#53
Ivy-

Dear wife just peeked in..

One more perspective--

When there are parental issues you can go 2 ways to get attention / approval / acknowledgement:

1) Saras way: Where you try to diligently work so hard and become an accha baccha and get attention. In Saras case, despite his work gumaan was always in the way to forge a connect. The connect finally happened because kumud displaced gumaan and facilitated.

2) Pramad way: You revolt, try to do things out of the way to get attention. Here his over-indulgent mom ...all the more so because she got pramad after so many mannats ...came in the way. She would come to his rescue , in the sense of hiding his wrongs. So the connect again did not happen from an attention / approval perspective...It initially must have started small, then became big...Now he does all of what he does to mainly irritate his dad...attention seeking taken to the other extreme..

On Kalika:
she doesn't agree with me ..
kaika is just a cunning person...who wants to prove her masters wrong..

Had she been a good person...kalika could have been a mini-kumud to facilitate...while she did not have the standing of a kumud, she could still have reformed him at the mini-level when the transgressions were minor... a real friend...

...she cunningly used pramad to continue his destructive behaviour so that he is always alienated and within her control...so actually the Gumaan to Pramad

On the last scene of Khana Kha Lena ...she doesn't agree with me..and bashed me up for writing it in the same sentence with the word crap in it...

- Kumud when in love went with food always (during the gau hatya, the flower scene etc.) to saras...because she cared for him deeply..
- Now when she was hurt..she was trying to hurt him back,,,all the not taking & giving prasad, no arti etc.
- Now when she knows exactly what has happened and why he ditched ...she is trying to forgive him..which she has not done totally...
- Saras smile was to depict that there is a ray of hope... a scope of forgiveness...AND a hope that he will succeed in fulfiling the promise he made to his mom..

She finds it amusing to see me glued to the laptop trying to figure out stuff...and then comes in and sorts out things in a jiffy 😛...

I tell her to also join the forum...but she says one lunatic in the family is more than enough...and that...baccha kabhi atkega toh mere paas aana...

Posting this again coz she forced me to correct the sin I have done on the Khana Kha Lena post ...and not appreciating the superlative acting by Samud...

😭


Edited by hotdogg - 12 years ago
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#54
@Hgg...thanks to both of you! 😃 @Mrs. Hgg,... do join the gang!


Originally posted by: Arshics

...The key I think is with Navin, and how long he lasts in BD house. Saraswatichandra mar chuka hai was a key dialogue Aur isliye Kumud apni zindagi ko samet ke pramaad ke saath aage badh gayi Lekin kuch aisa hone wala hai Jisse Saraswati Chandra wapas laut ke aayega Kuch dhamaka Aur jahan saras hoga wahin Kumud hogi


Loved this bit, Arshi!
Wish they'd stop dilly-dally,pussy-footing around and get on with the dhamaka! 😊


Edited by happychappy - 12 years ago
-Ivy- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#55
Hgg bhai... Would cast my lot with Bhabhi. Again, deliver my *standing-frickin-ovation* to her 👏 Although you are no less 👏... You both perfectly complement... A veritable ying & yang 😳

Your perspective first:

Got me wondering... Did Umess also tell about Saras landing up on wedding night? The kind of character he is, it won't be too much of a stretch to believe he would have bragged about it. Maybe even about beating Saras up and leaving him for dead? Just spinning my wheels here...

Second, Kalika already hinted to P at Navin ji, and Kumud being 'intimate'... The way she added that they were left alone to come home and after that 'kamarbandh' came into Navin's possession, she deliberately skewed facts to incite, because Kalika had once before, found kamarbandh in Navin's possession as well. She does not know, per se, whether it is Kumud's like she outright alleged, but she is taking some risky bets here, just to see reactions. And she is scoring, I would say. Bringing that kamarbandh in, just because Kumud upped her by making P come to the party... She goes and finds something she already knew was in Navin's room. At this point she is not certain of its provenance. So she takes a shot in the dark. And Kusum, claims the article as hers. Hence, Kalika hits bulls-eye. There is no way it can be Kusum's because then Navin should not have had it from before. So, now by Kusum's admission and Kumud's silent acquisience, Kalika knows kamarbandh is Kumud's. Crucially, kamarbandh is the first concrete evidence to link Saras and Kumud, right from the very beginning of Kumud's marriage. I present Exhibit A. This is huge, I would venture.

Edit: Oops, was that Kalika's first tryst with the kamarbandh? Now I'm confused 😕 But even if not, nothing much changes. Kamarbandh was 'hidden' like a 'dirty secret'... That much is enough for Kalika to know this is one route (Kumud-Saras-Kusum) she outta investigate till it hurts

Edited: Yes, it is 😃 She finds it when she cleans Saras' room in the 2 August epi. Saras snatches it away from her hands, being the precious thing it was. His expression was totally 'caught out'. And now, Kalika knows that precious thing belongs to Kumud and Kumud only. She also knows that the three (Kumud-Saras-Kusum) are co-conspirators. No wonder Kalika's akad to Kumud. She is on much steady ground, while the rock strata has already starting dislodging from under Kumud's feet. But as long as Kumud feels she is making head-way with P, she is gonna be in a bubble with blinkers on. The day she finally 'removes' and 'gets out' it will be too late.

Third, I really appeciate the way you write about Pramad. There is so much scope for his character, because it is being played by a superb actor here, who brings the sort of edge that makes Pramad teeter effortlessly between black and grey. Hats off to Aanshul 👏

Also, and I did make the point today... For Kumud to really succeed mending rifts between BD and P, one of the two has to give way:

A: Either Saras has to be removed from the equation, because as long as Saras is in the picture, P will always not only pale in comparison, but act as a personal sting to BD, that this is the son I should have had and look what I got saddled with. How long before Kumud realises that?

B: Either P and S reach an understanding whereby Saras remains the 'naukar' and defers to P, so that P can at least tolerate him. This I don't see happening, UNLESS, for the time being, P hands S the charge of finding Saraswatichandra, thereby giving him the incentive to 'tolerate' S. Which BD might then see and perhaps, appreciate. Because if he had to choose, BD would choose Navin over Pramad in an heartbeat. And that fact really spells out the precariousness of both Saras and Kumud's position in the Dhan household.

Edited by IdiotViewer - 12 years ago
kaadal thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#56
@hotdogg I understand your frustration. I feel the only fact which makes this dragging worth it is the end explosion. Saras and Kumud's love was stretched so widely that the breakage broke our hearts. Now we wait for more impact on the next explosion as every player here is currently covered with deception.
We would love to have your wife online as well hotdogg. You really compliment each other.
And a big thanks for the wonderful perspective on Pramad. Anshul is a wonderful actor and it would be great to see more of his potential. Reading it the fact that struck me was there is no way that we are going to have a Kumud-Pramad relationship. Pramad might turn temporarily positive but like you said he has been humiliated by his dad for long. The exposure of Saras and Kumud would be the biggest hit in his life. If his character portrayal stays true he would never be able to forgive Kumud for her deception EVEN IF he starts trusting her a bit. And again he will go back to Kalika at that wounded time who would make sure he stays with her.
Now after all her hard work in trying to make her marriage work and reform Pramad, if everything goes back to square one ONLY BECAUSE of Saras, my million dollar quedtion is will she ever be able to forgive him the next time? I don't think so. It even scratches off a Saras-Kusum track in near future if the story is taken properly. You have given me hope hotdogg. Now let me cross my fingers and hope the tracks are written sensibly and not for TRP sakes.
KK84 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: hotdogg


kaadal / kat / adiani-

thanks. feel much better after reading your posts.

I guess it is the reduction of saras character from primary to a sort of hangeron which is bothering me.

Add to it that the story is not moving forward fast enough with respect to saras, kumud and pramad ...yet has the now mandatory presence of an inactive saras...and now this unnecessary kusum getting involved track...

seeing saras sort of just sitting there with nothing to do but look hurt, angry, confused, sad is the pits...

but I guess he is living his own repentence...experiencing the feeling of helplessness and reduced to a secondary citizen status in everyone's eyes ...including that of kumud

I just wish they speed this up and move it forward...






Hgg Bhai read the thread on saras being crapped on! Well written thread n I really think
U both..infact we all share the same sentiments.

Putting aside the fact that perhaps Saras is meddling but then he didnt choose to come to BD mansion in the first place. However, he does need to redeem himself n stop allowing to be treated like a gali ka Kutta. I understand that he can't say anything to Pramaad since kumud has told him not to but I wudve loved for him to stand up for himself infront of kusum or better still for kumud to come there n shut kusum up n say she will explain later how n why he is here.

KK84 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: pasumarthisa


</div>


<div>


Arshi,


The lump comes whenever he is on the screen. He is repenting, suffering and all that. The lump is not due to those. But, due to the fact that no one cares for him.Except for Mr. BD who is giving lot of respect to him. Completely isolated. Otherwise, he is a dhokebaaz,, naukar and mehmaan etc etc. Earlier he atleast had a dad and mom to call them so. Now no worldly relations.


Remember, this guy was not treated very well in Desai household too. the response was tepid in the beginning. Except for VC.


He takesall thisin his stride. Aadat hai usko.



It's like that story Aamir khan said in taare zameen par...kuch log roz ek peyr ke paas aatey the, kostey the uss peyr ko Aur ek din woh peyt khud bakhud marr Gaya :-(
pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: hotdogg

Ivy-

Dear wife just peeked in..

One more perspective--

When there are parental issues you can go 2 ways to get attention / approval / acknowledgement:

1) Saras way: Where you try to diligently work so hard and become an accha baccha and get attention. In Saras case, despite his work gumaan was always in the way to forge a connect. The connect finally happened because kumud displaced gumaan and facilitated.

2) Pramad way: You revolt, try to do things out of the way to get attention. Here his over-indulgent mom ...all the more so because she got pramad after so many mannats ...came in the way. She would come to his rescue , in the sense of hiding his wrongs. So the connect again did not happen from an attention / approval perspective...It initially must have started small, then became big...Now he does all of what he does to mainly irritate his dad...attention seeking taken to the other extreme..

On Kalika:
she doesn't agree with me ..
kaika is just a cunning person...who wants to prove her masters wrong..

Had she been a good person...kalika could have been a mini-kumud to facilitate...while she did not have the standing of a kumud, she could still have reformed him at the mini-level when the transgressions were minor... a real friend...

...she cunningly used pramad to continue his destructive behaviour so that he is always alienated and within her control...so actually the Gumaan to Pramad

On the last scene of Khana Kha Lena ...she doesn't agree with me..and bashed me up for writing it in the same sentence with the word crap in it...

- Kumud when in love went with food always (during the gau hatya, the flower scene etc.) to saras...because she cared for him deeply..
- Now when she was hurt..she was trying to hurt him back,,,all the not taking & giving prasad, no arti etc.
- Now when she knows exactly what has happened and why he ditched ...she is trying to forgive him..which she has not done totally...
- Saras smile was to depict that there is a ray of hope... a scope of forgiveness...AND a hope that he will succeed in fulfiling the promise he made to his mom..

She finds it amusing to see me glued to the laptop trying to figure out stuff...and then comes in and sorts out things in a jiffy 😛...

I tell her to also join the forum...but she says one lunatic in the family is more than enough...and that...baccha kabhi atkega toh mere paas aana...

Posting this again coz she forced me to correct the sin I have done on the Khana Kha Lena post ...and not appreciating the superlative acting by Samud...

😭



I was about to say the same about saras-pramaad duo. They both have similar issues. But their response was completely opposite. Saras turned into a humane person, tried yoga, excelled academically and became a rounded person. An eligible bachelor. His dad banked on him in matters of business.

There is too much said about their similarities of late. But similarity ends there, in the situation. Their response is in complete contrast and defines them.

Felt the same about saras's reaction to Kumud asking him to eat. He saw a ray of hope. He saw another ray when she came to his room n talked cordially about the daawat.


pasumarthisa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: happychappy

Santhi, they did show Saras in the pre-cap doing something unexpected, out-of-character! Opening up to Pramaad(!) about his own love life... Cant think of any reason why he wd do that - they are the opposite of bosom buddies...😲 Maybe the Kusum+Kumud combo (one barrage of accusation+one measure of kindness) just caused Saras to become momentarily mentally unstable?

And Pramad - is he the local relationship counsellor ? First to Kumud, then to Saras, "tell me about..."🤣

If Saras says something about his mum to P, (not knowing what Kumud has said) then that will be the last piece of the jigsaw...👏 in advance! But going by pre-cap track record, there will be flirting with danger but no lasting damage..😔



Haha. Both opened up to pramaad. But I think you do agree that saras did it unknowingly. And kumud knew the seriousness of the issue and how curious Pramaad was about this.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".