Crisp Bytes SC - 24th May 13 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

4.4k

Users

14

Likes

145

Frequent Posters

hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
hmm...

once more my theory validated that we need to give the CVs 1-2 epi after a particularly confounding one to smoothen things over...

1) both are soul mates which they know.. but the chuppa chuppi is high risk...

- by whatever small / silly reason (sejal's story) kumud (whose head is screwed right more than our dikra) is finally getting some 'real world' sense that there needs to be an official closure / announcement...and saras has been given a long rope after the hug...but his time's up and he needs to take a concrete step by articulating what he feels...
- saras finally gets it...thanks largely to gunial...

2) gunial's acknowledgement closes a logic ki vaat discussed here that how come everyone knows what's cooking except VC & Gunial.

- good character development in progress of gunial...finally!...who was more or less relegated to the background in favor of DB...despite a very promising start as kumud's very mature mom who was more of a friend...
- she probably did not intervene till now because she did not see the hot & heavy between these two, but knew something's up. also remember her complete trust in kumud not crossing the line and earlier dialogue "betiyon pe rok lagaa ke hum unhe kamzor nahin banayenge...par duniya ke vyavahar seekhana zaroori hai."
- liked her mature and upfront conversation with saras & a very delicate probing / reassurance to kumud.
- good to know that samud has one more ally...coz DB is all distracted due to her hubby's return & kumari.
- also good to know that saras got the 'enlightenment' through her and has made a promise to her about coming clean...will help to mitigate his extreme impulsve reaction when guman strikes.
- very modern outlook this by gunial...really like the step in the show...

3) our sherni has got her groove / spunk / fire back...was begining to worry that her being in love is diluting her essence...a topic covered by other fans too in this and other posts.
- super retort to guman...she's knows clearly who is enemy no.1... nice to see she hasn't forgotten the earlier discussion with guman...and doesn't care if she's her future mon-in-law...way to go!
- stop sign to dikra...and challenge to come clean...it was not an impulsive act...she is really concerned that closure has to come ..see how disturbed she was when guniyal came in...

4) but yes the drizzle which started last epi is beginning to turn into slightly heavier rain...the storm is definitely coming...
- notice gumans's jewellery box right on kumuds desk below the mirror in the last scene...the pieces are in place for guman.

5) Mr. Tubelightchandra has finally seen the light...he needs to close...and is super excited to do so...
- wonder what is guman planning which will turn this giddyness into anger / provoke a strong reaction?

6) My logic of taking it one day at a time is helping...one personal 'enlightenment'...
- without focussing on the baggage of a known story outcome...this feels really good going compared to other tv shows!...
- My MILLION $ QUESTION fo which I am scracthing my head since it ocurred to me today... there is so much adaptation done...are we as fans jumping the gun by continuous comparision to the original? ...
- I for one keep thinking the storm is going to hit next week..and seperation.
...what if this outcome itself has been adapted?... may not come for quite some time?...

...what if guman's attack is foiled?...saras announces...everyone is happy...then the whole premarital issue between the two (due to semi-official sanction after announcement)...then something else...build trps...
...then the seperation...
...SLB wants the show to continue for 2000 epis...abhi seperation de diya to we are already into the next act...

pataa nahin...Wishful thinking perhaps for my 1 happy week desire!😊

but CVs have continued to confound...and move the story in ways not expected...yet retain the balance...

still scratching my head on the last one...but good end to a good week in my opinion..

👍🏼


omshreejaanu thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
What does Kumud want?

a marriage proposal?

a declaration of love?

why?

so that she can talk about it in public?

That's not Kumud!!!


Do you really think Kumud wanted the declaration to talk about it in public??😕
I personally think that the conversation only made her reallized that she hadnt had a real proposal. She has said -mein tumse pyaar karti houn, 3 times to him and him?? Well Kumud is one special girl of course. She is different but also not so different when it comes to matters of the heart, is she??
Knowing that the person loves u is different, having it declared clearly not in riddles is also important sometimes. It makes u feel special. So throwing a lil tantrum toh banta hain!!😳
She only wanted to ask - hum aapke hain kaun n Saras again answered by another riddle.😆



smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: arshicritic

but smrth, today didnt work for me!!

continuity was missing, it just jumped into something else

Gun talking to Saras was great, and more natural than Dugba

but the convo didnt link upto anything in the past

I would have much preferred a different and more emotional reason for declaration of love

and not to give Kumud a kissa to narrate

It just didnt gel with me today


I see it this way, for Kumud, confirming to tradition is imperative from her family's POV. She is badly attacked by Gumaan. Her own aunt routinely upbraids her and her parents. She must be feeling awkward over undeclared love. And she can't come out on her own. Gumaan would pounce on her...So when Sejal speaks about a related topic, it triggers her anxiety. Social conformity is much a necessity now then ever...plus that slighted 'vanity', " mujhe dekhe bina naa kar di?!😡." 😆😆...so you see Saras was up for a scratch....better he responds quick!😃
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: hotdogg

hmm...

once more my theory validated that we need to give the CVs 1-2 epi after a particularly confounding one to smoothen things over...

1) both are soul mates which they know.. but the chuppa chuppi is high risk...

- by whatever small / silly reason (sejal's story) kumud (whose head is screwed right more than our dikra) is finally getting some 'real world' sense that there needs to be an official closure / announcement...and saras has been given a long rope after the hug...but his time's up and he needs to take a concrete step by articulating what he feels...
- saras finally gets it...thanks largely to gunial...

2) gunial's acknowledgement closes a logic ki vaat discussed here that how come everyone knows what's cooking except VC & Gunial.

- good character development in progress of gunial...finally!...who was more or less relegated to the background in favor of DB...despite a very promising start as kumud's very mature mom who was more of a friend...
- she probably did not intervene till now because she did not see the hot & heavy between these two, but knew something's up. also remember her complete trust in kumud not crossing the line and earlier dialogue "betiyon pe rok lagaa ke hum unhe kamzor nahin banayenge...par duniya ke vyavahar seekhana zaroori hai."
- liked her mature and upfront conversation with saras & a very delicate probing / reassurance to kumud.
- good to know that samud has one more ally...coz DB is all distracted due to her hubby's return & kumari.
- also good to know that saras got the 'enlightenment' through her and has made a promise to her about coming clean...will help to mitigate his extreme impulsve reaction when guman strikes.
- very modern outlook this by gunial...really like the step in the show...

3) our sherni has got her groove / spunk / fire back...was begining to worry that her being in love is diluting her essence...a topic covered by other fans too in this and other posts.
- super retort to guman...she's knows clearly who is enemy no.1... nice to see she hasn't forgotten the earlier discussion with guman...and doesn't care if she's her future mon-in-law...way to go!
- stop sign to dikra...and challenge to come clean...it was not an impulsive act...she is really concerned that closure has to come ..see how disturbed she was when guniyal came in...

4) but yes the drizzle which started last epi is beginning to turn into slightly heavier rain...the storm is definitely coming...
- notice gumans's jewellery box right on kumuds desk below the mirror in the last scene...the pieces are in place for guman.

5) Mr. Tubelightchandra has finally seen the light...he needs to close...and is super excited to do so...
- wonder what is guman planning which will turn this giddyness into anger / provoke a strong reaction?

6) My logic of taking it one day at a time is helping...one personal 'enlightenment'...
- without focussing on the baggage of a known story outcome...this feels really good going compared to other tv shows!...
- My MILLION $ QUESTION fo which I am scracthing my head since it ocurred to me today... there is so much adaptation done...are we as fans jumping the gun by continuous comparision to the original? ...
- I for one keep thinking the storm is going to hit next week..and seperation.
...what if this outcome itself has been adapted?... may not come for quite some time?...

...what if guman's attack is foiled?...saras announces...everyone is happy...then the whole premarital issue between the two (due to semi-official sanction after announcement)...then something else...build trps...
...then the seperation...
...SLB wants the show to continue for 2000 epis...abhi seperation de diya to we are already into the next act...

pataa nahin...Wishful thinking perhaps for my 1 happy week desire!😊

but CVs have continued to confound...and move the story in ways not expected...yet retain the balance...

still scratching my head on the last one...but good end to a good week in my opinion..

👍🏼




What bothered me -

Kumud was not insecure, she wanted a kissa

She wanted a unique kind of proposal that would satisfy her ego

This was not like Kumud

Even her line was about him having trouble verbalising his feelings, not doubt of his intent

Her asking for a unique proposal was too urban and not ratnanagri

I wish she didnt have to ask for a proposal, not this way,

I wish Dobo had realised the need for it on his own


Then Gun - I would have liked her to show some inkling earlier, not suddenly today

The whole convo about taking ehsaas to next level and giving name to rishta - again came

without a prelude - continuity to any past track was missing


Edited by arshicritic - 12 years ago
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
Most of this week, I have had trouble forming an opinion on the developments on SC. I dont know why, but I seem to start with indifference on first viewing to (on most days) improving appreciation when I watch later! The only similar experience I have had is with AR Rahman's music where you have to hear a track several times to really get into it!

There, that's a compliment if you can see one hiding in there, Mr. SLB!

p.s. Do the TRP aunties watch twice? 😕
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: omshreejaanu

What does Kumud want?

a marriage proposal?

a declaration of love?

why?

so that she can talk about it in public?

That's not Kumud!!!


Do you really think Kumud wanted the declaration to talk about it in public??😕
I personally think that the conversation only made her reallized that she hadnt had a real proposal. She has said -mein tumse pyaar karti houn, 3 times to him and him?? Well Kumud is one special girl of course. She is different but also not so different when it comes to matters of the heart, is she??
Knowing that the person loves u is different, having it declared clearly not in riddles is also important sometimes. It makes u feel special. So throwing a lil tantrum toh banta hain!!😳
She only wanted to ask - hum aapke hain kaun n Saras again answered by another riddle.😆





Looking at the flow of events, and their convo, it seemed as if she wanted a proposal she could boast of, and narrate to others, she did not indicate any unsurity, she indicate only wanting a kissa
Arshics thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: happychappy

Most of this week, I have had trouble forming an opinion on the developments on SC. I dont know why, but I seem to start with indifference on first viewing to (on most days) improving appreciation when I watch later! The only similar experience I have had is with AR Rahman's music where you have to hear a track several times to really get into it!


There, that's a compliment if you can see one hiding in there, Mr. SLB!

p.s. Do the TRP aunties watch twice? 😕



you all liked it

why didnt I?😕
hotdogg thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
@arshi
earlier posts by onshreejanu & smrth have explained my point about kumud with greater clarity.

about gunial...
...she has had & provided signals...(i) khoti vaat outburst after kumud danced in the rain (ii) guman / kumud when she was going on her date (iii) guman when she questions kumud the day after the hug...notice there were shots of her with a concerned look...and all of us were jumping to the conclusion (wrong when seen now) as to why is she so 'concerned' about...

so i see a logical extension today when she stepped in...

...in the new course correction, maybe there was no time / possibility to bring it back again through more screen time

...also remember our SLB likes subtlety... things are not what they appear at first...and he wants us to work hard even if we wish to enjoy the show..

😎


Edited by hotdogg - 12 years ago
smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: arshicritic



you all liked it

why didnt I?😕


Look at it again at 11 arshi...specially Guniyal...umpteen times I have complained her fading...
In bet'n Sunny talked exact logic we were discussing; letter came in open and from your side..so you must 'repair' in public...😆
happychappy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: arshicritic


Her asking for a unique proposal was too urban and not ratnanagri

I wish she didnt have to ask for a proposal, not this way,

I wish Dobo had realised the need for it on his own


Arshi, even the most intense love story doesnt have to be perfect...

Remember that misshapen pot Saras made that Kumud took for herself...
Saras is like that (she has to ask to get a proposal!!😆 ) but she loves him the way he is!



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".