SADHNA HAS A DUAL CHARACTER (Note: Page 2)

aruntouch thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Sadhna has a dual character in the show when Ranveer was in jail she was telling truth. when her mami was sick,she was lying and hiding the truth from the family members and even though she is not telling the sickness of her mami to her real daughter Ragini. then why is she potrayed as a super woman and has all the qualities one should have and even she saved Alekh from accident also.

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.7k

Users

9

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

scrpngl thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: aruntouch

Sadhna has a dual character in the show when Ranveer was in jail she was telling truth. when her mami was sick,she was lying and hiding the truth from the family members and even though she is not telling the sickness of her mami to her real daughter Ragini. then why is she potrayed as a super woman and has all the qualities one should have and even she saved Alekh from accident also.

Oh c'mon guys.. give Sadhna a BREAK for God sake..!! there are other topics regarding this topic so y to open different topics on same issue again and again?? urghh..this is so disgusting!!
n now whole Sharma family knows the TRUTH about Kaushi's illness..so they can also tell this to their daughter.. y u want only sadhna to tell this??
well now this will be reveal in the cuming episodes of Nitraj mohatsav.. so have patience... LOL!
Omshanti1111 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
why is the real daughter closing her eyes and believing what she needs to believe...

at least 100 times this discussion has occurred what is the importance of Bhagwad Gita and truth. Now if someone tries to belittle my Lord and Bhagwad Gita, pls be aware that I am not going to keep quiet, I'll just report that an effort is being made to hurt our religious sentiment.

wuthering thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
@ The Original Poster: I understand where you are coming from, mate and I agree with what you are saying. That was one of my biggest problems with the character too. It is just a fictional character at the end of the day and nowhere near the super-human-ness that some people think. But its alright. Everybody is free and entitled to have their opinion. All we can do is sit back and hope that the future track is more logical and does more justice to all the characters involved in the show. 😊
Sweet-Violet thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

why is the real daughter closing her eyes and believing what she needs to believe...

at least 100 times this discussion has occurred what is the importance of Bhagwad Gita and truth. Now if someone tries to belittle my Lord and Bhagwad Gita, pls be aware that I am not going to keep quiet, I'll just report that an effort is being made to hurt our religious sentiment.



Agree with you. This topic has been discussed million times already. lol

The bottom-line is ....Sadhana couldn't lie under the oath of Bhagwad Gita as per her upbringing and moral values. Everyone has to pay for his/her deeds...so did Ranveer in this case.
Mr. Shahi didn't make her lie for the same reason as it would hurt the religious sentiments of Hindus and also give a wrong message at the same time.
Edited by --Anu-- - 15 years ago
479445 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: aruntouch

Sadhna has a dual character in the show when Ranveer was in jail she was telling truth. when her mami was sick,she was lying and hiding the truth from the family members and even though she is not telling the sickness of her mami to her real daughter Ragini. then why is she potrayed as a super woman and has all the qualities one should have and even she saved Alekh from accident also.

1. Sadhna took an OATH on Geeta. And she was TESTIFYING in the Court of Law. There is a great difference. This great difference is always missed by our fellow Indians, due to which I can witness a regular display of lawlessness in my Mother Land!

2. When her Mami was ill, it was a different scenario. There she had to hide Veenu's deadly deed from Mama to avoid another panic storm. This is a domestic scenario ... not a national or ethical anti-climax. Its a way to handle things internally, to manage the money while saving the shock of Mamaji and also keeping things in control.

3. Telling Ragini is not Sadhna's responsibility. Veenu should've told her ... atleast he could share with Ranvir ... why didnt he? ... All these months Ragini couldnt notice her Father's SERIOUS accident ... which even a blind can realise ... And her mother's illness did not make her curious enough to atleast discuss about her report in house....or care to look at her medicines ... or even talk with a third person about her! ...EVEN share her mother's health with her inlaws or husband! .. No! ... not only that....she doesnt even call after returning home to inquire.... she is cool with everything unless it directly effects her joy! ... I cant agree that Ragini is equally affected with the miseries of others, as is Sadhna.

A daughter is not told about her mother's problems from the AWAM ... she actually should even have that restlessness. How can she be so relaxed ... her mother is on death bed.

You cannot throw this blame on Sadhna ... its highly unjust.

Sadhna IS THE POTRAYAL OF Beauty and Purity ... she is not a super-woman ... she is a pure woman ... but ALAS ... being pure is so unwelcome in today's world ... that pure people are rediculed, cheated and tortured. Its something no one can deny ... its something we see evident everywhere, including Sadhna's case.

Yes she saved Alekh ... and you know what? ... She would've saved Vasu too, if she would be in Alekh's place at that time. And Sadhna was standing and knew she could save if she acted...

** You know what Alekh should've done after he got well. Every morning he should've kissed Sadhna's forehead when she was asleep, and when she woke up. ... WHY? ... because in our Indian Heritage its said that the forehead is the symbol of fortune ... and Alekh's whole EXISTANCE is a result of Sadhna's fortune ...

Ragini should do the same aswell.... atleast every day ... once ... if not that, then atleast in her heart...
Edited by Ice-Thinker - 15 years ago
MagixX thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: isabel

@ The Original Poster: I understand where you are coming from, mate and I agree with what you are saying. That was one of my biggest problems with the character too. It is just a fictional character at the end of the day and nowhere near the super-human-ness that some people think. But its alright. Everybody is free and entitled to have their opinion. All we can do is sit back and hope that the future track is more logical and does more justice to all the characters involved in the show. 😊



Precisely..!!
I always like your posts,Eddy's girl!😆
They are so upto the point!👏
Enjoy reading them!😊
Keep it up! 👍🏼
wuthering thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: MsMagixX



Precisely..!!
I always like your posts,Eddy's girl!😆
They are so upto the point!👏
Enjoy reading them!😊
Keep it up! 👍🏼



Aaja meri Mrs. Brett Lee! Aapka hi intezaar tha! And how could you NOT like my posts?! And I am not, NOT, I repeat Eddy's girl! 😆 😆 And haina? You think so na- thoda bahut contradictory dikhaya hai characters ko....just hope there is more realism incorporated in the show!

BTW, I never asked you this- do you like that actress who plays Lana on Smallville? Isn't that her in your profile pic?
MagixX thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
@Sparkly boy's girl(Chalega?😆):-

I am floored by the title you gave me..Completely flat..Loved it!🤣

Anyway,back to the topic!😆

Yes,I do think that she shouldn't have lied when it came to Kaushi's health at the first point..It contradicts her move to tell the truth..Wish they could have shown her telling the truth..It would have made all that look better!😊

Hey yeah,I do like Lana..She is very pretty..U like her too?
Edited by MsMagixX - 15 years ago
Bini311 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
The topic has been discussed several times. Lying by touching a Gita is a big deal. Even the most evil criminals have a tough time lying by touching the Gita, hence it is used in courts.

So, how can Sadi lie?

I don't want to comment on Kaushi's sickness, but how can saving your own husband be a super-womenly act? Isn't it the responsibility of every husband and wife to be there for each other when needed. In my eyes, Sadhana is the real Hero. I think the saying is really true, "Valai ka jamana nahin raha".
Edited by Bini311 - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".