Is what Sid doing right? - Page 5

Why he has to pay 5 lakhs . For minor surgery he will pay 5 lakhs ?

Originally posted by: Gdbs

subjective statement...ishani saw the convo accidently...and in today epi also ishani saw him taking money accidently only and took the video she didnt stalk him to get the proof...

juz think abt the damage it will cause to sanjivani if it was anyone else instead of ishani...

ishani is more concerned abt sanjivani name so she will do the complain to higher official...and sid will be suspended but the this will be safeguarded as internal proceedings...

but what if the person is journalist/who is having enmity with sid/sanjivani...this will lead bad name to sanjivani, sid licence will be cancelled, ppl trust on doctors will be shaken...

not to forget ishani already undergone this type of defamation...remember that magazine scene...

also juz clear me... asking an actress go for more cosmetic surgery is advisable...??what if that cosmetic surgery gone wrong...?her career will be doomed...

I never said he is perfect. Nor have I defended him. In a nice world and a very developed country where health and medical facilities is free, none of this wld be required.

I know he is playing with fire and someday it will get to him

I am enjoying watching Sid. He has some grey streaks in him . Makes an interesting watch.

May be once he gets a big promotion and has more power, he might stop all this.

I wld see this as a numbers game then. There are more poor ppl than rich. May be that's his thought process.

And he has to do balance. Ensure he gets enough patients to take in Moolah.

So he advertises these kind of big bang surgeries to his big ticket patients.

Also he feels he has to help some poor. And he has to take care of himself too. Living in Mumbai is not easy.

Let's face it. Medical is more like a business these days . No one can deny it.

Sif being able to bring business and still help poor is actually commendable atleast to me .

I don't think what Dr. Sid is doing is right but maybe he have his own reasons which will be explained as the story continues, same as Dr. Ishani's character. They will develop as the show continues and let's not forget how medical is really right now.

Check whether it's apolo, max, Columbus Asia hospital they charge more than 10 thousands for the ward rooms assigned to the patients and lets not talk about ICU people are afraid how much money they will have to pay after even two nights in ICU. People with all the medical insurances are also worried for how much they have to pay after their doctor visits and in Govt. Hospitals you have to wait more than 3 days to get a result of a simple CBC test which can be collected in just some hours from a private hospital. I've experience in both govt. and private hospital and I know how much corrupt system is atleast they're not showing Dr. Sid claiming money from keeping a dead person in ventilator and charging money from the patient as you all must know there are many such cases.

I don't find Dr. Sid is doing anything wrong!!! As Sid said poor people have to always do some jugaad to earn their money and also to make people hear them!!!!

Rich people donate right they can consider this as their donation!!!!

Dr.sid is just keeping humanity above everything....n I agree with him!!!!

As a serving physician, I can say with fair authority that subjecting a patient to unwanted surgery - because of their financial status - is ground enough to get your license revoked and to be debarred from practicing.

A doctor has no right to play with health of a patient . Any form of treatment should only be offered out after valuing risk vs benefit. Patients should be given honest explanation regarding their options and treatment prepared with their consent.

Dr Sid is not just wrong - he is committing a criminal offence and if Sanjivanu is said to be funded by government, there are government insurance policies that cover the cost of surgeries and medicines and hospital stay (have served in government hospital and signed forms for the same)

Someone said the Chanakya neethi works in the world but in the world of healthcare it will have disastrous consequences.

Makers need to do more research before presenting such callous content.

Originally posted by: UmIbrahim

As a serving physician, I can say with fair authority that subjecting a patient to unwanted surgery - because of their financial status - is ground enough to get your license revoked and to be debarred from practicing.

A doctor has no right to play with health of a patient . Any form of treatment should only be offered out after valuing risk vs benefit. Patients should be given honest explanation regarding their options and treatment prepared with their consent.

Dr Sid is not just wrong - he is committing a criminal offence and if Sanjivanu is said to be funded by government, there are government insurance policies that cover the cost of surgeries and medicines and hospital stay (have served in government hospital and signed forms for the same)

Someone said the Chanakya neethi works in the world but in the world of healthcare it will have disastrous consequences.

Makers need to do more research before presenting such callous content.

Of course it's a crime. In my work place,if caught taking even rs100 under scrupulous ways, you get suspended. Here we are talking about lakhs.

Another question to the accounting, finance or income tax people. One doesnt grow money on trees, if someone is using more money than he can have financially, then it's clear something wrong is happening 🤔.

Also robin hood (story one) robbed bad people to help poor ones. How does Sid decide who is a good person or bad person to Rob?

Not all rich people are corrupted afterall. He may be stealing from innocent people here.

Originally posted by: Anonyme

Of course it's a crime. In my work place,if caught taking even rs100 under unscrupulous ways, you get suspended. Here we are talking about lakhs.

Another question to the accounting, finance or income tax people. One doesnt grow money on trees, if someone is using more money than he can have financially, then it's clear something wrong is happening 🤔.

Also robin hood (story one) robbed bad people to help poor ones. How does Sid decide who is a good person or bad person to Rob?

Not all rich people are corrupted afterall. He may be stealing from innocent people here.

But here the problem is not only about money, patient's health is under risk , this is not acceptable at all.

Why I feel his suspension from Sanjivani isn't about Ishani video but something else? Vardhan already had plans to get him removed from Sanjivani, so I don't think it's Ishani who the reason he got kick out?

Now sid will pay money by breaking matki jo group janashtami me mateki todegi use 2 lakh milenge so sid will break matki and will get 2 latkh and pay bills of other

guys! The purpose of whole thing is not showing Dr Sid good either. Its what he thinks its right.. We dont have to think its right. Its his flow in his characters for some while others find it cool.

Personally, i would have liked him to run for charity.. But chalo... I dont mind him doing this also.

Long time ago there's a show of Yashraj films i guess on sony tv.. 'Powder'... One of the officer there used to side money from raid and all but never accepted bribes on other hand.

Apna apna najariya hota hain.

Sid doesn’t do it to make himself look good or bad.. Its just he does it because he think its not a big deal. :p