Ok Here I am with my 1.5 cents worth of opinion(yeah it is worth less than 2 cents😉😆)...But it is pretty hard hitting(probably because it has no value).....😆😆...so there i go
Lavanya:
U have lovely voice.There seems to be some disturbance in the background,so ur voice can't be heard too clearly.I dunno if it is a problem with my comp or in the recording.Anyway,very good performance. This song needs a lilting touch to it which u have brought about perfectly. Wonderful. While staring the mukhda again after the gap in "Maine", u seem to have skipped half a beat(just for the heck of pointing out)Ovreall enjoyed ur song 👏👏👏
Mini:
I liked ur voice very much and ur style of singing. U seem to have slowed the pace of the song. The original song is a li'l faster than this……u have also changed the "sruthi" or pitch at the end of the first antara….the reason for this is that u 've started the first antara at a higher note and hence the change thru out….Other than that it sounds fine….. It was a good effort 👏👏
Suhana safar:
let me start off by saying that u have a very sweet voice..I've loved ur voice in all the songs u've sung so far.Again the only thing I want to point out is the sur.In "rang armaanon ka bares" u've shifted to a different pitch .But while coming back to the mukhda u've come back to the original pitch.Also at times inbetween sur is slightly shaky,esp in "jiya mora bas mein " …….However it sounded lovely,overall 👏
Nikhil:
First of all, the song u've chosen is a very difficlt one.And u've done a good job of it.It is very diffilct(almost impossible) to match up to the original,but I thought u sang well.U have a very good range of voice.The "teri deewani " is to be sung in two octaves –low and high.Most ppl (even in music competitions like SRGMP) omit the the lower octave conveniently.That simplifies the song considerably.U have sung both octaves perfectly.👏Hats off to u for that.The song requires a li'l more feel,esp being a sufi style number.And the harkats require more precision and strength (like the teri deewani in the end etc)Basically,liked ur performance very much.👏👏
Tabu:
Good attempt.U have brought the enthusiasm/verve required for the song.But more concentration on sur which seems to be slipping a bit on and of…like in intezaar,in haathon mein who haath aaye etc… 👏
Mala:
Liked ur performance very much….There was a li'l dragging of pace ,esp in the lines "jiya mora bas mein", otherwise it sounded gr8….A li'l more concentration on taal is needed thru out the song…The higher notes of haay rama (second time) needs more precision….very good performance,overall 👏👏👏
Naughty n nice:Good performance. Found the pace a tad slower than the original. Also a li'l dragging of the rhythm in certain places like in the lines "meri saason mein tu hai basa "..Alos certain places like the "tu" in the line meri saason mein tu hai basa" ," o sajna" mein in ,"baje dil mein shehnai etc need more precison……A li'l more feel is reqd in the song….liked ur performance,overall👏
Kiti: Saawan ab baras gaya hoga…u've sung so beautifully…Agar nahin barsa,to iska matlab hai sawan's ears are blocked😆😆………Loved ur song….It was simply superb…….Cld hardly find any fault with it, inspite of trying hard to come up with mistakes……Ok,u have a slightly nasal quality in ur singing which shows up on and off…(not thru out the song,but in some lines)…another thing is in the first line while starting off "ab ke sawan " back from "aise jam ke bares" u've missed half a beat…these are all things that I am pointing out for the heck of it…….and lastly maybe even more strength in the harkats of "ghata sawan ki etc"….but this easier said than done,esp while singing without background music….😳
Anyway,superb , mind blowing, fantabulous. .overall…..aise hi gaate rehna 👏...bas ki aur claps chahiye 😉
Evilseye:
Again ,I have not heard the original.But I liked ur performance very much.Ur voice seemed perfectly suited to this song,giving it a rustic feel.U brought the right amount of verve or bounce to the song…overall,it was very good
👏👏👏
Kalpa:
Though ,I have heard the original,it was ages back..so I can't remember much.I liked the song overall.A lil more concentration on the rhythm.So words are said too quickly and somea li'l too slowly,affecting the pace.I think this song requires aslightly different feel to it,more like disco type of song which was missing……But overall good performance 👏👏
Saara:
I have not heard the original song …..So I cannot comment much on the song.I am presuming this song requires more verve or enthusiasm.. I might be wrong.There was also a slight faltering in the rhythm at some points..,esp where one line ends and the next one starts.Otherwise it sounded good 👏
having given such strong fb ,I hope ppl are kind enuf to give me equally strong fb....hehehe...i know they will...abhi Rasny,adi aur bhaskarji ka fb baaki hai...they will make faluda of me...not to mention bdi 😉😆😆
Edited by rock&roll - 17 years ago
Ganesh Kartikeya
CID
Anupamaa
