Vasundhara's - Mahiya - Page 2

I agree.....I don't like vasu's voice

Originally posted by: AznDesi

In my Opinion it wasnt even sung technically right. She even messed up the second english verse. Vasu was In the USA for quite a bit and her english is very good. She should have had no problem. When you compare Annamika's Song "Mere Dholna" to "Mahiya" the pure difficulty level of singing in "Mere Dholna" is 10 fold if not more. Yet Anamika got lower marks I think Manik bhai is 100% right it is just Zee politics. That Redention by Vasu didnt deserve it atall.

i totally agree. I mean if they want to give every kid an equal chance and treat everyone the same then why this favor towards her? You should judge her based on her voice and singing not becuz she can't see. There are many ppl in this world who are worse off then she is. They shuld all be treated equally instead of giving her special favors for any reason. Zee needs to get a reality check. This isn't how the real world works.

Originally posted by: AznDesi

Whoa!!! One of my Fav songs of 2007 and Vasu Sang it lekin it was an absolute dissapointment 😭. I just watched the show was busy all saturday and to finally watch the show and hear such a happening number in this redention was very very dissapointing. ON top of it she got 2 A+'s ??? That left me speechless LOL. 😆. I guess the Cafe coffee was sooo good and they all got such a good Caffine buzz that they thought it was a A+ Deserving song. I dont think it was even a A- worthy. Fair would have been about a B+ or so . Anyways would have loved to hear it in Annamika's voice! I think she would have been a better choice. 😛

😆 I donot mind Vasundhara but I agree with you it was not a good rendition. As for Anamika singing it......... naw, lets just forget about it.

I thought her first performance was much better, she sang Billo Rani really well. I was disappointed with Mahiya, she tried her best but I was expecting more after I read the update and read the judges comments about her performance

Suresh Wadkar looked funny when he awarded A++ for Vasundhara's Mahiya but not to Anamika's excellent performance.

I think it is like this, he can do classical stuff and he thinks probably the song was not composed in a proper way and he would have done a better job. What else can be the reason after knowing that both Sonu Ji and Suersh Ji had never heard the song before and Sonu Ji, the best singer of today's time felt it deserved A++ but he thought it deserved only A ?

Whereas he cannot do western stuff and he is impressed that someone can do it , so straight away A++ to Vasundhara!

but I liked it. 😕 I was enjoying it so much. I never really liked the original, I found it too boring and repetitive, but Vasu made it more colorful and interesting. I guess the judges thought like me too. You can't call them UNFAIR because they don't have the same opinion as you. And FYO Anamika did get an A+ from Sonu so you can't direct your comment at the "judges", only a "judge".

If vasu got A+ for that song then I wouls say quality of A+ has drooped down!!

Seriously..these judges are on somthing!!!
on wut... dont know dat. 😆

Friday night performance by Vasundara was so sweet. Maybe this caused judges not to have eliminations too.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZDE6kMTWOk[/YOUTUBE]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZDE6kMTWOk

Originally posted by: qwertyesque

mahiya was like daisy duck on high speed down hill - 200 rpm..

😆 i couldn't agree with you more. that was by far the most horrible rendition of mahiya i've ever heard. goodness.. all my fav songs don't remain my favourite songs once ms vasu has sang it. barso re was ruined & mahiya was destroyed. i wonder how much more some of us have to bear with?