Superb Start to IF SRGMP Finale - Page 6

Originally posted by: Morgoth

"Mindblowing Mahiya" - Aparna, kya bolti tu? Better or worse than "Hawa Hawaii"? 😆

😆😆 no comments 😆

Originally posted by: Thakur Saab

I would really love to see some response on this from Aparna Ji.😆

Heard the classical song of Aparna Ji. Just Fantastic!!! 👏👏 For me it was not an unknown song so simply loved listening to it. Too Good!!! 👏

By response I hope you meant posting my reaction and not the song itself 😛😆😆 Atleast I know that song... I don't think I have even heard the farmaish songs for Ashish & Seema. Right now I have a break for about a week in between switching jobs ... who knows just might end up singing the song 😆

😆😆😆 Rupadi....if you are so adventorous, how about a Maiyya Maiyya?😆

Originally posted by: AG

By response I hope you meant posting my reaction and not the song itself 😛😆😆 Atleast I know that song... I don't think I have even heard the farmaish songs for Ashish & Seema. Right now I have a break for about a week in between switching jobs ... who knows just might end up singing the song 😆

aparnadi this song is just a farmaish😊if u dont like the song dont sing it.i just thought that i had never heard u attempt something of this sort so there was no harm in trying

btw i think i wrote my requests without thinking.i wanted seemaji to sing a rekha bharadwaj song but phook de is really bad😆.so i change my farmaish.seemaji can u sing namak issk ka from omkara.

and raju ji if u dont like bheegi bheegi u can choose alvida.

but i think labon ko will suit anaverkar ji's voice very nicely

FINALLY, listened to almost all of them!!😳 Here's my feedback, short but I have less words to say each round :P

Classical/Semi-Classical

Ashish ji - Wow Ashish ji, fantastic feel and emotion in your voice, very nice vibrato in your voice as well... really liked the feel in this song, fantastic!!!👏👏

Seema ji - This song really suited you I think, I really like the way you sang it, there was one small spot I thought sounded just a bit different, but wonderful job Seema ji👏

Aparnaji - Kya kahoon, you did full justice to this song!! Beautiful Aparna ji, classical really suits you cos you have the perfect voice for those type of songs... great👏👏

Raju ji - I really like this song Raju ji, could hear your smiles here... :) very nicely done👏👏

Second Section

Ashish ji - Fantastic, fantastic!!! The yodelling was too superb, and it was just fantastic... great job Ashish ji!👏👏

I couldn't listen to the last three but will and post those after😳

As was decided with the mentors we will also hv feedback from one classicaly trained person for the songs of this round more because we hv classical songs in the round. Here's the feedback...he is the Disciple of Pt Bhimsen Joshiji and his name Samar Majumdar.

Aparna - As far as the classical song goes she is perfect...so correct technically. but in the other song she lacks the actual feeling....she could not bring that feel into the song. She is very very good with classical songs and soft songs and so best if she sticks to those. If she gets proper training can go really far.

Ashish - What he lacks most in his singing is openess...he was good with the classical song and fantastic with the masti one....but in the classical he is supressing his voice...When he is taking the alaap he should remember that in bairavi it should come out from inside. that needs lot of practice and thats what he lacks....he does not do regular riyaaz. If he can do it then he can get into this "Khulke Gaana" thing which he lacks in his singing at times.

Seema - Has made mistake in the taan...She has recieved classical training is evident from her singing of the classical song.....but lack riyaaz...also i feel she over uses her voice but in turn does not take care of it...thats evident too. She missed lot of scales in the classical song but managed to do quite well. even in the other song she missed scales...because of lack of riyaaz she has a breath problem too in her singing. Plz take care of your voice...its really very good. but lack of care and overuse may cause lot of damage.

Raju - He really needs lots and lots of practice...he has no idea about what he is singing.... he is just learning them and then singing. I doubt if he even does riyaaz....he has done badly not only in the classical song but even the other song.

He also sang two songs on request....here are the links to those songs.

Jo Bhaje Hari Ko Sada - This is the famous bhajan of Pt Bhimsenji...

Thumak Chalat Ram Chandra

Wow, Barnalidi,

The special Judge's comments are really bang on target.He has brought out each ones strengths and weaknesses so well....👏

Rupadi ... You should seriously persue classical music.

Seemaji - first and foremost you have to take good care of your voice.You have such a soothing and melodious voice, it will be such a waste if you let it get affected this way.

Ashishda - you also have an excellent voice bus sirf gala kholke gaana hain...and best to practice that gala kholoing in on bhabhiji...subah subah riwaaz shuru kar dijiye..😆

Raju - Your performnces were better when you had started. You also have a fantastic voice, but lately the feel in the song is a little less. Your na huindu banega na musalman banega in the kids round was great. may be you are not connecting with the lyrics or the soul of the song...Please cut down on the long pauses when there is no background music to fill up the time.the song continuity gets affected.May be you should take the feedback of Guruji seriously and try working on the improvable areas and then there will be no stopping you.

Best of luck to all. In the eyes of an expert ( Guruji) you all have fared so well, hats off !!!👏

Now awaiting the final results...best of luck to all...

Adi,

agree 100% that guruji's comments are bang on. Barnali ji, thanks for enlisting his services. He has detected the plusses and minuses in everybody so well. Khulke gaana, I agree. Yaar, kya kare. Some just have that khula awaaz (Kishore, Udit) and some don't (Kumar Sanu, myself :-)). I do make a concerted effort these days to try and sing more khula. Bhabhiji pe abhi aur music daala to ghar ke baahar kar degi. She feels I devote too much time to it anyway.

BTW, I know riyaaz would help a great deal. To let all of you in on a secret, I have never had any formal training at all. One of my friends who has had 19 yrs. of training in classical music has offered free sessions to a bunch of us. Going to finally start getting some formal training.

Originally posted by: advil

Wow, Barnalidi,

The special Judge's comments are really bang on target.He has brought out each ones strengths and weaknesses so well....👏

Rupadi ... You should seriously persue classical music.

Seemaji - first and foremost you have to take good care of your voice.You have such a soothing and melodious voice, it will be such a waste if you let it get affected this way.

Ashishda - you also have an excellent voice bus sirf gala kholke gaana hain...and best to practice that gala kholoing in on bhabhiji...subah subah riwaaz shuru kar dijiye..😆

Raju - Your performnces were better when you had started. You also have a fantastic voice, but lately the feel in the song is a little less. Your na huindu banega na musalman banega in the kids round was great. may be you are not connecting with the lyrics or the soul of the song...Please cut down on the long pauses when there is no background music to fill up the time.the song continuity gets affected.May be you should take the feedback of Guruji seriously and try working on the improvable areas and then there will be no stopping you.

Best of luck to all. In the eyes of an expert ( Guruji) you all have fared so well, hats off !!!👏

Now awaiting the final results...best of luck to all...

Originally posted by: anarvekar

BTW, I know riyaaz would help a great deal. To let all of you in on a secret, I have never had any formal training at all. One of my friends who has had 19 yrs. of training in classical music has offered free sessions to a bunch of us. Going to finally start getting some formal training.

Originally posted by: Anu.Rad

Aashishji,

If even without formal training you can sing so well, then you will do wonders if you really take the formal training.. Please do take training and do riyaaz and dont let this voice which is gift of god!! Not everyone can sing.. Its an art and god's gift..

And ya.. Khulke gaane ke liye - you can do riyaz in early morning.. What happens is the voice in the early morning around 4 or 5, is not open and when you practice at that time, then your voice starts opening.. I have also heard that singers used to go to ponds or rivers and do riyaz standing in the cold water..