Raja pips Amanat & Aneek....

By common consent,all the three singers are exceptional...More or less equally talented and gifted and each of them is a great singer in his own right...

But,personally,I'm of the opinion that Raja pips the other two...X factor!!...By X factor,I'm not referring to the Qazi-esque characteristic which transcends the basic purpose of the show and shrouds the lack of talent...What makes Raja stand out is the fact that he oozes X factor,and he is a terrific performer....I'm afraid,I cannot say the same for Amanat...Amanat is technically brilliant,perhaps even a shade better than Raja,but there isn't a whit of X factor.....Even when he attempts racy item numbers,his energy and performance cannot hold a candle to Raja's exuberance..Amanat is the quintessential textbook singer,he can sing any song melodiously,but he lacks the star quality/X factor or whatever you call the inexplicable trait in the singer which appeals to the audience....I can cite names of Karunya,Arijit Singh and Hemachandra who are as good as Amanat and in the same mould,but I cannot name another Raja Hasan..Neither Amanat's nor Aneek's singing imbues such sense of exhilaration as Raja's vocals succeed in achieving....

Raja sings with wild abandon...His voice powerful and energy infectious.Agreed he has had a few low to middling performances,but nothing undermines his memorable performances..When Raja is in form,when he is in his element,he is simply the best ..Raja makes one want to groove along on his music,something Aneek nor Amanat hardly manage to achieve....Aneek's voice is immensely mellisonant,but lacks the throw..Aneek's voice needs to mature a bit more....Even when Aneek chooses a racy zestful number,he fails to match up to the brilliance of Raja...Raja's "Dard E Disco" and "Let the music play" were more powerful,more resounding than Aneek's "Ek Main Hoon", "Mahi Ve".and "Mast Kalandar" Anyone concurring with me??

PS...Now the aforementioned were plainly my views and opinions...You might not agree with me,but that doesn't necessarily make my opinion wrong...😊

omg, i agree 100% ! very very very nicely said... you stole the words out of my mouth.

Same here I agree with you well said 👏 👏 👏

absolutely true..raja is not only a good singer but a great performer and humble person too..

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

Amanat is technically brilliant,perhaps even a shade better than Raja,but there isn't a whit of X factor.....Even when he attempts racy item numbers,his energy and performance cannot hold a candle to Raja's exuberance....Neither Amanat's nor Aneek's singing imbues such sense of exhilaration as Raja's vocals succeed in achieving....

-----

-----

Anyone concurring with me??

PS...Now the aforementioned was plainly my views and opinions...You might not agree with me,but that doesn't necessarily make my opinion wrong...😊

I concur and then would add this😛.....

It all boils down to personal preference. For me technically strong, versatile singer with original voice is what I expect from srgmp platform. My definition of X-factor is also that.

yep all the three singers are very good in their own right....but RAJA has some sort of charisma/charm 😛...he can set the stage on fire..

Sorry. After watching 28th sept prgm, when Poonam gets eliminated, I was sad to see Raja still in the competition and her leave. His Zanak-2 was pathetic. His 1st Ghulam Ali's Gazal, there was no continuity. It seemed to be broken in 100 pieces. Worthy singers like Sumedha, Poonam have had to go because of Raja.

I can definitely say he will win, what with besure singers winning the competitions every time. In fact with that in mind he is the winner already. He is the worst of the top 5.

Whatever you said about Raja is true, he is in fact a wonderful singer. However, my personal opinion differs ... and I find the X-factor in Amanat. It may not be his performances that get him his X-factor, but his soul in his voice is enough to make him the winner. But I do respect your opinion, and I will say ... very well said. 😃

Very well put. Raja is a great performer and his voice has a certain rustic khanak to it but then I prefer Amanat. He sings well and he has his own style of performing, more quiet and soulful.

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

and he is a terrific performer....

yea so is Aneek

how many people can dance and jump on stage and still sing without missing as single note? not many😉

Raja is a great singer, yet Aneekz voice is not matured, but when it does he will be a great singer....

Aneeks voice is sweet and meoldious...and he also has an X factor