Raja pips Amanat & Aneek.... - Page 3

Sorry... I do not agree with you. Raja is ok but my definition of X factor is having feel and immersing yourself in that song. If you forget lyrics after lots of rehearsals I would not call that "feeling" the song. Versitality is important as well and Amanat does it the best. I think he truly deserves to win.

We should wait for a few years and then see the X factor of which contestant plays the most role in their success.

Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja Rocks
Raja RocksRaja RocksRaja Rocks

agree with person who started this topic...but at this stage, its by voting and not by perf or by versatility or anything else... by now all have their own favorites and they will vote them...whoever's fans vote most, he wins...,ay best man wins...

RAJA ROCKS....

Lemme Explain.

Suppose 3 People are Sitting in a Room and Amanat ,Aneek & Raja Going to Sing Infront of Them.

Amanat Stars 1st and Sing Mitwa. 1st Listener Say You Sang Very Well.2nd Says You Sang Very Well But 3rd one Says " My God You are Too Good ,fab,i cant believe,You Had To Sing The Orignal One"

It Means The Genre of Amanat is Really Liked By Third Listener BUT 1st and 2nd Listener comments were Just ok.

Raja Sing Piya Haji ALi: For Listener one and Third Raja Was ok But For 2nd Listener Raja Was Out of This World.It Means Raja,s Permomance Appealed the 2nd Listener The Most and Amanat,s Song Appealed Third Listener.
Now For Example Aneeks Song Appealed To 1st Lisner Most.



After this Whole Session you just sit back and think that no one is Better than eachother cuz this is the Prob of Genre.

Piya Haji Ali is Tottally Different with Mitwa and Aneeks Song is Tottaly Different with the others in Singing.

To Compare different songs in Different Genre will be a Big Folly 😆 .

on The Whole They are Superb in Their Genre.You Cannot Compare Them with eachother.even i Believe someone sings his best and you say to Him" i Give You 10, or 9 ,WHATS This?

Dont Ever Try To I.M.P.O.S.E your Views to anyone that who is better or not 😊 .

So Chill out.they have very Good Future ahead in their own Typical Genre including MUSSARAT.i Missed him the Most in Ghazal Episode. 😭

agree...raj has some kind of 'charm" : )

i agree raja does bring that electrifying energy on stage whenever he's in the form but for sume reason i still prefer Amanat cuz amanat can sing any kind of song so beautifully 😛

ur perfectly rite mate..u culd take himesh's place as judge it wud do better 2 da show..as 4 callin raja a besura some1 seriously needs an ear transplant..lolzz

at this point, all the singers are excellent but i agree with you, i personally found raja set fire on stage with his mindblowing performance 😃

Originally posted by: Mokshda

Raja isnt consistent or versatile- he's been bashed so many times when he tried to do other genres

"So many times"....Errm,Do we both watch the same show??🤔

Raja was panned only once,for Pardesi Pardesi...That again wasn't AS bad as HR made it out to be...

Agreed there were days when Raja's performance wasn't the "best of the evening",but that doesn't mean his performance wholly was bad only because someone else was better.....

Originally posted by: emancipation

Lemme Explain.

Suppose 3 People are Sitting in a Room and Amanat ,Aneek & Raja Going to Sing Infront of Them.

Amanat Stars 1st and Sing Mitwa. 1st Listener Say You Sang Very Well.2nd Says You Sang Very Well But 3rd one Says " My God You are Too Good ,fab,i cant believe,You Had To Sing The Orignal One"

It Means The Genre of Amanat is Really Liked By Third Listener BUT 1st and 2nd Listener comments were Just ok.

Raja Sing Piya Haji ALi: For Listener one and Third Raja Was ok But For 2nd Listener Raja Was Out of This World.It Means Raja,s Permomance Appealed the 2nd Listener The Most and Amanat,s Song Appealed Third Listener.
Now For Example Aneeks Song Appealed To 1st Lisner Most.


To Compare different songs in Different Genre will be a Big Folly 😆 .


Dont Ever Try To I.M.P.O.S.E your Views to anyone that who is better or not 😊 .

Imposing my views,am I???..You see,I'm not coercing you to agree with me,I've said you can disagree with me,but that wouldn't necessarily make my opinion to be a wrong one and vice versa...😊

Besides,If you had bothered to read my post carefully,you'd probably realise that I haven't compared "Mitwa" to "Piya Haji Ali"...I juxtaposed Aneek's racy item number performances to Raja's...I didn't deem it necessary to compare Amanat's item songs to Raja's....Amanat's "Koi Mil Gaya" and "Tu Cheez Badi Hai Mast Mast" were low on energy and zeal,IMHO...Amanat might be a better Ghazal /classical singer than Raja(And by pronouncing this,I'm only setting too much store by the comments of Jagjit Singh and Pandit Jasraj and some of the forum members who have better knowledge of classical singing than I do)...Infact I prefer Amanat to sing soft romantic numbers,or soulful ones which he pulls off with tremendous aplomb👏

X factor,in my lexicon is defined as the undefinable singularity which people lap up...A unique attribute or characteristic in his singing which compels people to vote for him EVEN when he isn't perfect....I've already admitted,Amanat might be a shade better than Raja technically,but Raja's rich voice texture,his throw,the contagious ebullience..All these add extraordinary zing to his singing and makes his dulcet tones more appealing than the others'...This is strictly my personal opinion,you are entitled to disagree,but please do not accuse me of "imposing".

PS..The first four paragraphs of your post can be summarised in one line..>To each his/her own😛