Why is Sameer performance going down? - Page 5

Originally posted by: chatbuster

good that u finally understand the point that was being made about 10 lakh people being wrong. high-time.😛

and of course, these aspects are applicable for all three. true again that it is my opinion only as to who is the best. others are welcome to whatever erroneous opinions they might want to hold on to. no sweat off my back😊

as for musical judges, i dont need no alka to tell me that sameer shld not get an A+ for a performance that sucked IMO when she is giving an A to someone else for a performance that rocked. i trust my own ears more than alka's tricky fingers on the dial. 😉

well if u consider others opinions as erroneous just because they are different then urs and u trust ur ears then in that case ,i'll say i think the same about ur opinion.No point in discussing now.What can u discuss with someone who has a preconcieved notion that whatever he says is correct and everyone else is wrong.Well I have no shame in admitting that i am wrong at times,after all i am not God.😊

Originally posted by: chatbuster

it probably aint 10 lakh people in any case. for all we know, it could be a thousand characters each voting a thousand times.

I don't have any daubt on this... Have you noticed fanatic followers who will retaliate with abusive message on slightest mention of flaw in sameer singing and such.

Originally posted by: ani11

U don't know me,i may have been out of India for a long time but my roots are still there,so don't even go there.

Well what would u say if I said that a few people are voting for sanchita because she is the only girl left there,because no girl has won a reality show so far.

people have their own reasons and what u can be sure of is ur own reason not for anyone else's.

What ever the reasons are they stand for all the three contestants,don't single out sameer.

i think the anecdotal evidence here in this forum wld go against sameer by comparison. if u look at most of the stated reasons for supporting him, most refer to non-musical reasons (cute, naughty, age). if there are musical reasons, these seem to be mostly the grandiose unfathomable magical mystical kinds. and that coming from his own supporters 😛

Originally posted by: srgmp-fan

I don't have any daubt on this... Have you noticed fanatic followers who will retaliate with abusive message on slightest mention of flaw in sameer singing and such.

It is'nt the same number for anyone,how many times have people mentioned on this forum that they are voting day and night for sanchita😊that means multiple votes.

Originally posted by: ani11

What ever the reasons are they stand for all the three contestants,don't single out sameer.

Thats fair, I accept. And thanks for accepting there are reasons above and beyond good singing that are in play-- and play really strongly in this perticular contest.

(I had just responded to the above highlighted assumption from you.)

Originally posted by: ani11

It is'nt the same number for anyone,how many times have people mentioned on this forum that they are voting day and night for sanchita😊that means multiple votes.

good that u see this. perhaps u cld explain this math to one AznDesi. he seemed to suggest there were 10 lakh people who had voted for sameer😊

Originally posted by: srgmp-fan

Thats fair, I accept. And thanks for accepting there are reasons above and beyond good singing that are in play-- and play really strongly in this perticular contest.

(I had just responded to the above highlighted assumption from you.)

Of course there are and no one can deny that,thats why I used the word assume because that is what we can do.I like sameers voice and singing and i am thinking the others voting for him must be liking it too.

I myself want sanchita to win not only because she is the best but also because I want a girl to win this time,we are all humans and we cannot go past these factors.But to say that everyone who is voting for sameer is just voting because he is cute,naughty and young is totally wrong,we have to accept that there are people who like him for his singing and voice.

Originally posted by: chatbuster

good that u see this. perhaps u cld explain this math to one AznDesi. he seemed to suggest there were 10 lakh people who had voted for sameer😊

Why would'nt i see it? is'nt it obvious?

And i am not azndesi's teacher that i have to explain it to him,do it urself.

The whole reason that we do get shockers in talent hunt shows is that people vote for more non-musical reasons that musical... Earnest request to all, vote for the most musical kid please... Do not vote because someone is cute and has a naughty smile, neither vote for someone as she is the only girl finalist and never vote for someone on sympathy.. Believe me even those kids want the votes to be cast just on the basis of music....

Vote for the one whom you think is the most pakka on sur, who has the most trained voice, who is the most versatile, who can carry all songs with ease... Listen to the songs with your eyes closed and concentrate just on the song... You will see, its not very difficult to find the one who is the best 😊

Originally posted by: ani11

Why would'nt i see it? is'nt it obvious?

And i am not azndesi's teacher that i have to explain it to him,do it urself.

AznDesi is talking about the ten lakh. that Sameer got when votes were counted by Shann in the last episode! Chalo, saab shaant ho javo aur lets cheer whoever is our fav. It will be real exciting to watch the Grand Finale!! We should be pr oud of all the 3 as I am sure they will all rise to the top. Cheers👏