twogudanos thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Before voting for Diwakar, please consider this:

No matter what type of song it is.. he can sing that song only in monotone. There is no versatility like Abro, Pawni, Sanchita, Sameer.

All those who are voting for Diwakar need to listen to what judges are saying.. listen to music..
in short you the public voter.. don't be deaf and dumb.

Abro's rendition of sufi song 'Teri Diwani' is outstanding. Tell Diwakar to sing that. He butchers most songs. It has become politically correct to keep praising Diwakar when it is painfully obvious he can't sing at the level other little champs.

Enough is enough.. call spade a spade.

I like Gajji a lot. I respect him. But not for orchestrating return of Diwakar. It is slap on face of all sensible, level headed music loving people all over the world. Gajji, we can see thru all of your moves. Even 10,000 miles away.

We all want to make money. There is a right way and there is wrong way. Destroying dreams of little champs for SMS money is disgusting.

If you felt sorry for Diwakar's visual impairment, you should have brought him back under a separate category - and given separate recognition...and let normal judging continued. Top four should have been Abro, Pawni, Sanchita and Sameer.

Abro, Pawni, Sanchita, Sameer.. you are all big stars in making. We will always remeber you.

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

4k

Users

22

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

punjini thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
A little harshly put, but there is truth in what you say about Diwakar getting more praise and votes than he deserves. I don't agree about Sameer being in top 4 though. He should have been eliminated earlier.
vickosh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I feel that people with disability have a life that is harder than most. But what is a disability? If you ask a runner with just one foot to run with others who have two feet than it is not fair. If somebody who has speech impairment is asked to speak than that is unfair. If you feel it is unfair than you should participate with equally able people with similar diability.

Now with Diwakar his disability is his vision. He is in a contest for singing, where his disability does not prevent him from being compared with kids who have vision and are in a singing contest.

Unfortunately, the judges, and the audience seem to not want to judge him fairly and hence say things that in their mind might make it appear that they are discrimnating him for his diasbility.

I have watched Diwakar from the start. I have seen his family, I have heard Diwakar speak about life, I have seen the things he has achieved outside of this competition(a movie on him, his photos with politicians etc.)and I have heard him sing. I feel that his parents have made him or rather his disability a commodity. He knows what to say, when to say that can have an impact on the audience. They have made suckers of all the other contestants. Gajji has also used Diwakar to make the show popular. He had decided to bring a contestant back the moment Diwakar was eliminated. I have watched Bappida give false praise or never say a very harsh word to Diwakar.

Diwakar has no business to even be in the final 10 in this contest. He is an extremely poor singer......
seelu thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
i agree with all of u....diwakar doesn't deserve to be in top 10...same goes for sameer too.....
Melvee thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
who cares what u guys say ...diwakar is my fav...I am so happy he is in top 3.... well i dont mind if he gets eliminated now coz at least he will be runner up...
shefali_123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
How have his parents made his disability a commodity?? 😕 😕

I dont think that. They have brought him up well andgiven him the confidence. As for speaking the right things he is an intelligent boy and can speak very well. That is inborn not to make an impression on others.

If you do not like him dont undermine his other achievements and his parents.
JanetDsouza thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
I agree shefali, you have written very well. I am really amazed at how some of us on this forums can come up with judgements and predictions. It is simply amazing. Diwakar is singing what he feels, he is trying to express himself, he is trying to say what he feels, and yet we find all this a sale. Amazing!. I am not sure if i feel amazed or depressed on the fact that our younger audience is so rude and so arrogant. If you do not like his singing, please express that, but you should not judge or belittle anyone. That is very very hurtful.

Again how would one understand Diwakar and his parents feeling unless one did not face this situation themselves. It is a shame, I am again requesting all of you on this forum to be humble: "the world is round, what goes around has to come around". If you go around with hatred that is what you are going to receive and if you go around with love then that is what you are going to receive.

If you feel that Diwakar should not be in this competition simply state that, there are some of us who do not like Sameer at all, I do not like his voice, it does not appeal to me, but no I do not go around accursing him, his parents for making him look a certain way or talk a certain way to win the audience. So please keep your posts specific. I am not saying this because I feel sorry for Diwakar, but because I feel you should not face any issues by belitting someone else. Hope you all understand

*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
I think stating that Diwakar's parents have made him a commodity and are exploting his disability is not a comment in very good taste... Everyone has their personal liking and all these kids have their strong and week points... I agree that Diwakar is not the best and does not deserve to be in top 3.. And so is Sameer... Both of them should have been eliminated earlier... Infact after Diwakar got eliminated, he should not have been brought back.. If anyone, it had to be Aishwarya or Neha...The top 4 line-up should have been Sanchita, Abhro, Pawni and Neha/Aishwarya... That would have been a complete win-win contest for music...
san2471 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jayc1234

I think stating that Diwakar's parents have made him a commodity and are exploting his disability is not a comment in very good taste... Everyone has their personal liking and all these kids have their strong and week points... I agree that Diwakar is not the best and does not deserve to be in top 3.. And so is Sameer... Both of them should have been eliminated earlier... Infact after Diwakar got eliminated, he should not have been brought back.. If anyone, it had to be Aishwarya or Neha...The top 4 line-up should have been Sanchita, Abhro, Pawni and Neha/Aishwarya... That would have been a complete win-win contest for music...



Very well said. I agree that Diwakar is not a great singer but since he has not experienced nature, never seen the world some feelings do not come naturally to him, how can a person sing songs of mirth when he cannot even freely run, dance and enjoy the world. As regards Sameer, he is overhyped and the judges are at fault for this specially Alka Yagnik for unnecessarily praising him. They have killed the prospect of the talented Neha and Aishwarya in this contest and should stand up and take the responsibility. I am praying that Sanchita wins the contest so that it will be a royal snub on Alka who has reluctantly given her A+ on certain occassions and more often than not said..kich kamiya thi...

All the best to Pawni/Abhro/Neha/Aishwarya ...they will go places.
arun_8687 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: twogudanos

Before voting for Diwakar, please consider this:

No matter what type of song it is.. he can sing that song only in monotone. There is no versatility like Abro, Pawni, Sanchita, Sameer.

All those who are voting for Diwakar need to listen to what judges are saying.. listen to music..
in short you the public voter.. don't be deaf and dumb.

Abro's rendition of sufi song 'Teri Diwani' is outstanding. Tell Diwakar to sing that. He butchers most songs. It has become politically correct to keep praising Diwakar when it is painfully obvious he can't sing at the level other little champs.

Enough is enough.. call spade a spade.

I like Gajji a lot. I respect him. But not for orchestrating return of Diwakar. It is slap on face of all sensible, level headed music loving people all over the world. Gajji, we can see thru all of your moves. Even 10,000 miles away.

We all want to make money. There is a right way and there is wrong way. Destroying dreams of little champs for SMS money is disgusting.

If you felt sorry for Diwakar's visual impairment, you should have brought him back under a separate category - and given separate recognition...and let normal judging continued. Top four should have been Abro, Pawni, Sanchita and Sameer.

Abro, Pawni, Sanchita, Sameer.. you are all big stars in making. We will always remeber you.



Thats bluntly put,But you've made a valid point.
Diwakar does sing in a single tone,no voice modulation at all 😕
And if Diwakar is competing with normal kids,I think we should judge him the way we judge others.There's lot of unnecessary romaticism attached

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".