Is Himesh losing his Midas touch? - Page 11

Originally posted by: s.priya

Great idea. Why not.

If you ask me, we should be able to conduct a debate on any topic - any topic includes HR - in a good manner and in a entertaining manner.

The first and foremost premise being that no one here HATES anyone or for that matter specifically HR and therefore, it is a set of people arguing pro and cons the virtue of the artiste.

1) No personal attacks on any member.
2) No personal comments on HR - i.e. no talks of his personal life, or his personal prefereances.
3) Comments to be in clean taste.

If we adhere to this, why not?

Can we "strongly dislike" someone?

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

I cant say about other forum, but here we can debate on Debo/ID or anybody. Start the topic on Debo If I will feel I should debate then surely will debate otherwise will be quiet.

Okay jadoo lets start….

where from Debo originally belongs to, what is his mother tongue, what is qualifications. Is Debo married if yes than how and where did he met his wife.hmmmmmmm

Originally posted by: ankita31

rules of the debates are..remember which forum you are in..know who your oponents are...

in the FG forum bhool kar bhi QAZI ko critcize nahin karne ka..samjhe

in the II2 forum if you utter a word against AMEY DATE you have had it..

in the SRGMP forum..DEBO ko bura bhala kehne ki gusthakhi ki hai to bhugto...

Ankita ji, I dont know if you are joking or serious, but I take it it is in good humour and pun.

As I see it, if it is a serious topic of discussion, I dont see why I should not be allowed to critisize Debo.

I did not follow the Challenge series, so dont know too much on either Debo or Vinit, but in II, when Abhijiit sawant won, there were many who had constructive discussions on the merits of Abhijeet savant vs. Amit Sana vs. Rahul Vaidya. I have been a part of those debates and except for stray occassional comments, the majority of the debates were good.

Originally posted by: juggyE

Can we "strongly dislike" someone?

Why not??

If you are seriously asking this for the purpose of debate, why not?

If a pun 😆 then the answer is .... mmm.... maybe ... maybe not.... depends on a lot of factors 😉

Originally posted by: jayc1234

Well - I didn't even say that he is a good MD - so I guess I can state what I said without any contradiction 😃

One song from Banares was actually pretty good - the one by Pt. Sanjeev Abhyankar. Hmmm... that makes it 1 out of how many so far???

Also as a reply to someone who said SLB praised Tere Naam - he/she forgot that the same episode, SLB also said that it reminded him of LP. Didn't HR admit then that Tere Naam was all LP...

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Ankita.. you know whatever you are feeling is really not good sign for forum. I personally want HR/Vinit supporters to open topic on Debo/ID or anybody else. And we can debate under the rules and regulations of forum. We really need members from all group to co-exist with each other with agreement and disagreement. I feel that is the main motive of this forum.

I support you there Jadoo ji.

We have to be able to discuss anything and everything in the forum, sticking to the forum rules, so that all of us can co-exist.

This forum is intended for all. If not, we will have splinter groups or fan clubs where only praises come in plenty and at the end of the day, we can only praise so much. Sacharine when consumed in plenty can lead to diabeties.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

The success that HR received over the past one year was written in his fate. And it will be his fate that will determine when the downfall comes. If we were to realize that, we'd spend a lot less time cribbing about his success or praying for his downfall.

Thomas Edison once said - If we spent less time thinking about other people, and more time thinking about things, we'd have a lot more inventors in this world.

I'd like to modify that - If we spent less time thinking about other people, and more time thinking about ourselves, we'd have a lot more happy people in this world.

Dont agree... 😉

I think we want more Bill Gates' in this world and less Dick Cheney's...

j/k Shady bhai, just couldn't resist...

Originally posted by: s.priya

I support you there Jadoo ji.

We have to be able to discuss anything and everything in the forum, sticking to the forum rules, so that all of us can co-exist.

This forum is intended for all. If not, we will have splinter groups or fan clubs where only praises come in plenty and at the end of the day, we can only praise so much. Sacharine when consumed in plenty can lead to diabeties.

cool points Priya...

But looks like at the moment, we dont have anyone to debate against 😕

All present here will speak for one side of the camp 😃

Originally posted by: Bhaskar.T

👏

Too true...... The list is too long. And frankly speaking a list can be made of concerts which have been always much more better than the ones you are talking about. And I am sure the list will be quite long.....

But where's Appa. I want to see his expert comments here 😃

Sorry , I should be more clear about my comparisons. I realized it after writing it. I was greatly impressed by the other singers I mentioned definitely. BUt, I went with a friend who was not really a fan of Hr, but I think HR even converted him.

What I was trying to say about his connection with the audience was something you need to experience. He spoke to the audience and he didnot sing his songs conventionally. What I mean is that for example He sang songs as to involve the audience. It was a unique experience from all the songers I have seen. Your right that Ghazal singers are different from a singer like HImesh. But, still you can still involve the audience and talk to them and involve them.

Why do we go to concerts. IF we wanted to just hear the music then we can listen to it at home. We go to interact with the singer and person we hear on the radio. It was his involvement with the audience that impressed me. That one felt that the man wanted us to all feel like one. He said things that were really great. Like once he said when he was trying to get us to sing with him that "remember, we all can sing" Many talented singers just come and sing and do not involve the audience at all. So you feel somewhat like your listening to them on Tv. Or that they sing their song like as it is exactly in the album with no changes.

I have no problem with people who don't like his music. What rocks my boat may not rock yours. But, if I didn't express my opinion about the fact that I was highly and greatly impressed and enjoyed his concert. If I didnt defend someone who I enjoy just because the majority opinion is against mine, I feel I would be wrong.

I enjoy all types of music. As you can see I have been to all types of concerts. When I want to relax , I will put Ghulam Ali on. But, If I want to dance with friends at a party , for sure, I am not embarassed to say that there is nobody better than HR.

I dont want to make anyone feel that I dislike their opinions against HR. I just feel that sometimes we should try to appreciate his success. And...Has anyone ever felt that criticism against him is a little much. Maybe not, maybe I'm the one who can't see it.

Originally posted by: s.priya

I support you there Jadoo ji.

We have to be able to discuss anything and everything in the forum, sticking to the forum rules, so that all of us can co-exist.

This forum is intended for all. If not, we will have splinter groups or fan clubs where only praises come in plenty and at the end of the day, we can only praise so much. Sacharine when consumed in plenty can lead to diabeties.

The problem occurs when we become overtly emotional about something and loose reasoning... If we can detatch ourselves a bit from the person and focus only on the aspects of the debate, I guess we can carry out a healthy conversation.