Ek Gaane Alag Andaaz - Page 4

Shady, i agree with you..

I have an idea.. why not do this... post the song name and those who can find the song can post the link... now, everyone can listen to this and post their own views too.. So, that will heat up the discussion 😊

very nice topic priya di
i can't really think of many song and i think all song are unique even if it's being sung by different singers so sab ache hai 😛

nice topic priya... 👏
although almost all songs which were sung both by male and female singers like 'zindagi bhar nahin bhoolegi' and countless others...the male versions were bigger hits and had better impact, except rarely like

"aji roothkar ab kahan'jayega"(aarzoo)

lata's version was better than rafi's

this song"tu is tarah se meri zindagi mai shaamil hai"(cant remember the film name-starred rajbabbar,music by usha khanna)
was sung by 3 singers-by Rafi,manhar and i think hemlatha...manhar and hemlatha were terrible!!

Very interesting topic Priya ji, It is good topic to compare different singers. It tells you which singer you are biased towards. It gives you a shocking realization that some other singer may sing the song better than your favorite singer.

I think the comparisons are interesting but may not be fair.The most important thing is what is genre of the song and which singer is known to be good in that genre and obviously will have a huge advantage to sing it.

I recently heard this song carefully to make comparisons

The song is

Hum ko tum se ho gaya hai pyar kya karein, bolo to jiyen bolo to mar jayein.. (film: Amar Akbar Anthony)

This is one song sung by Kishore Kumar, Mohd Rafi, Mukesh and Lata Mangeshkar

Kishore Kumar is known to sing this genre of song too well, So obviously Kishore Kumar breeze through the first stanza of the song effortlessly

Than come Mukesh for whom this genre is completely alien but he surprized me by taking his voice to such a high. So I would say he met the expectations.

In between there is Lata ji singing, I must say for some strange reason, my mind would wander away..probably has heard this voice sooo much and a point comes when you find the voice stale..

Than comes the mighty Rafi. I would say it is not the best genre in which he sing songs at his best.I would say he far exceeded all the expectations.

It is hard to say who sang the best.But it is easy to say I didn't like the lata lines too much..Mukesh was trying hard at this out of genre song.

Kishore Kumar voice made me feel that it is sung by some macho man and Mohammad Rafi voice made me feel it is sung by some very handsome romantic person.To tell you frankly, I like both Rafi and Kishore but I am more of a Rafian..

Very interesting topic Priya.....

I will come back and post something... For now, I am tooo shocked and sad to write anything...

Hrisikesh Mukherjee was the director for me 😭

Originally posted by: srgmp

Hame tumse pyar kitna, Ye hum nahi jante, magar ji nahi sakte hum tumhare bina....

Sung by parvin sultana ji ( thumri style) and Kishor Kumar ji , loved both versions , 😊

This one came to my mind when I read the post.

Song from Mirza galib sung by many singers but I like the one sung by Talat Mehmood & suraiya

Song: Dile nadan tuze hua kya hai

i see we are talking alot on legends, and songs, who sang itbetter. Now moving to Present time take 4 instance Ya Aliby Zubeem. Its highly popular, yet as some mentioed its rip off of another singer. My question is who sang itbetter him or the previous singer?

P/S

Also there is an Arabic group who sang this songbefore Zubeem.

nice topic