Music Lovers vs. HR - Prosecution Case - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

729

Views

34.3k

Users

38

Frequent Posters

deepboy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

I would like to request the court and the prosecution to change the reference to the case. It is not Reshammiya v/s Music. My client is not fighting Music or against it. Music is a world-wide phenomenon and everyone has a right to it - no one person or group can claim to represent Music solely.

This is a case that has been brought by a particular group of people. If you have a name to represent yourself, kindly use it in place of Music.

Shady from Htown
Assistant to Defense Counsel



I object my MOD.What this man is doing is something against the interest of Music and the country's music is in wrong hands.To justify our stand i have provided the relevant documents in the form of direct links to songs that according to the accused has been dumped as archaic and irrelevant.
His one line..'Aaj kal Rafi ko kaun sunta hain..' says it all.I would request my learned defense councel to think twice about this as this so called 'Sufiana' can ruin our future.

Let me also clarify my learned defense councel that this not a protest aginst Himesh the man..but the 'school' he symbolizes..So i would like to stick to my point that this is a fight between Himesh and music.According to MTV charts and what not 'chats',Himesh can qualify for an embodiment of Music.So treat it that way and carry on with your points.
Bhaskar.T thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: shadyhtown



Shady from Htown
Assistant to Defense Counsel

Shady who is the defence counsel BTW 😆

Would love to know the name...

advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

I am the defence counsel.😆

Is this a re run of HR Music Club ????😆

Whatever happened to rahul & qwerty??? Are they the jury???

paljay thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#34
[Quote=Jaadoogar]

No it is not Music club, it is music court. My client ko back mein headache ho gaya aisa case file kar dia Deep Das Mukherji ne. Abhi hum chhote attorney hi kaafi hain. Me and Shady are in defense counsel.



😆
manjujain thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#35
Hello jadoo ji

sabse pehle to taliyan bajani padegi aapki or shady ki himmat ki daad dene le liye ki aap aur shady ne yeh case liya.

aapki dallelein bhi badi solid hain. par ab aapke client ki back mein headache ho gaya hai sunkar dukh hua, ab to bus bhagwan hee malik hai, par hamari duayein aapke saath hain.

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

No it is not Music club, it is music court. My client ko back mein headache ho gaya aisa case file kar dia Deep Das Mukherji ne. Abhi hum chhote attorney hi kaafi hain. Me and Shady are in defense counsel.

Bhaskar.T thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: adi_0112

Is this a re run of HR Music Club ????😆

Whatever happened to rahul & qwerty??? Are they the jury???

😆

😆

advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#37

Prosecution and defence counsel ko dekhke even I am inspired and mujhe ek poem yaad aaya hain.. can i please share it???

deepboy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar




Me Lord: This is the 21st century, age of globalization. If western people can adopt our Yoga then why not we adopt the western things. Time and tides do not wait for anybody, if you are not changing with time, you will be left behind. This world is just a global village. Woh zamana gaya jab america 7 samundar door thaa, now america is just 12 hours away (Are you talking about super sonic jets here????) from Delhi. Mr. Reshammiya is a progressive person, he can not sleep in 20th century.

<>Its good that they adopted our Yoga.What if they started promoted our begging and child-labour???There is no harm in adopting something good.
The west has a lot things which we can adopt.The westernisation of music had started long back and i have mentioned about that in my post.Wearing a unwashed jeans and a baseball cap and some lifted drum-beats is not westernisation.Let Himesh learn something from Pancham da or even ARR.Even Rabindranath Tagore adopted western tunes in some of his songs.But our objection is against blind aping and not accepting the finer aspects of the west.

2)

Abandoning is relative thing, Even a son follows the their great culture but parent will always say their son had bandoned their culture. It is just a generation gap. It is universial concept not only for India. And nobody can define which culture is superior or inferior. A person always feel his or her culture is superior. Mr. Himesh is not forcing anybody to change the culture, It is personal choice to listen his songs. It is duty of parents to prevent their kids from listening Himesh's songs. My client has respect for all kind of culture/gender/religion/race.

I think the defense councel has consciously avoided the last word and that is AGE.As per his statement..'My music is targetted at the 23 year olds'.. clearly discriminates the section of the society he targets...So this falls against the assumption that the accused has respect towards people of all ages.



3)

<>Me Lord: There is no depression, everybody is happy, majority are happy and enjoying my client's music. You can see the face of those people who listen my client's music. They are all happy, and literally they are Jhooming. Me Lord: mujhe yeh bataye ab kaon si cheez asli hai, Main yahan baithe sabhi logon se poocchtaa hoon, tumne ek glass doodh subah piya hoga batao woh doodh cow milk tha ya buffallo milk tha ya powder milk thaa? Usmein kitna water thaa? Tumne roti khayee subah kaya woh wheat pure thaa, woh bhi hybrid thaa. Tumne sabzi khayee hogi kaya woh sabzi pure thaa? Arrey jab tum khaana nahin pure khaa rahe ho, jo ke blood mein jata hai, to music agar pure nahin hai to kaya problem hai? woh to blood mein bhi nahin jata. Judge saheb yeh sab log desh ki badhti tarakki ko rokna chahte hain? Agar music pure chahte hain to inhe un sabhi cheez pe rok lagana chahiye jo pure nahin hai. Agar rok lag gaya to jeena mushkil ho jayega. Judge saheb mera client ekdam nirdhosh hai, woh is desh ko improved version mein music de raha. Ek hybrid wheat seed banane ke lie government kitna money lagati hai, aor mera client apne kharche se improved hybrid music banaya to bechare ko katghare mein laa dia.

I object Me Lord: Main yeh nahin kehta ki hamara doodh impure hain ya hamare sabji khaane layak nahin hain.Par main is baat ko saabit karna chahta hoon ki jo pure nahin hain is aadmi use pure banana chahte hain.Raag ki R bhi naa hote hue is aadmi use simplified raag kehna chate hain.Apne aapko Nusrat ji se tol rahein hain..yeh sarasaar galat hain..jhoot hain..agar yeh apna jurm kabool karte hain aur kehte hain ki woh simplified raaga nahin balki pure jhalakiya dhun se hamare 23 saal ke naujawano ko behosh karte hain toh mujhe koi pareshani nahin..khali woh apna jurm kabool karle ki yeh raaga nahin..keval 'tadkaa maar' music hain jo ki nashili haalaath mein kisibi aadmi ke durbal dimaag pe zyada asar karta hain aur woh usmein kho jaate hain...




4)

Judge Saheb,

India is no more a developing country, it is already a developed country. India is moving faster than lot of developed country. Our economic growth is more than 8%. Can you imagine how did you come so far? You can not grow by confining you in a container. We need to compete with developed country like USA not to compete with Bengladesh. We need to improve our economy to 10% not go back to 2% growth. If my client can give 27 hits in 6 months then what is the problem. All revenue coming from these 27 hits are not going to my client. So many people at different leves share that revenue. And ultimately it is going to share in country progress.

Music koi deewaron pe sajane ki cheez nahin rahi, music koi almiraah mein rakhne ki cheez nahin rahi. Music aaj hawaaon mein hai, music aaj chaurahe, chaubare, gali aor sarkon pe hai. Jis tarah se hamara desh grow kar raha hai waise hi music grow kar raha. Our country is moving away from socialism to capitalism. In capiltalism, individuality is very important. If each individual take care of themselves then it definitely reduce the burden of country. Himesh is not forcing his music, but he is giving the option and it is individual choice irrespective of anything. Himesh is just part of current economic growth of India. He is contributing to the growth of India in whatever way he can.



a) 'Aajkal Rafi ko kaun sunta hai' –

Judge Saheb:

Mere client ka yeh bahut hi true observatin thaa. At one point he is saying the truth that he loves Md. Rafi, he respect Md. Rafi and Md. Rafi is his inspiration. His other statement is also truth. Aajkal "Rafi saheb ko kaon sunta hai?" Mera client majority of people ki baat kar rahe then, minority of people ki nahin. Latest example: Everybody know how big was Mughal-e-azam movie, usko color karakar laya gaya mujhe bataye yahan baithe kitne logon ne jaakar dekha? If anybody got demorlized by his statement, then it is his problem, not my client's problem. Judge saheb yeh sab dosh be-buniyaad hain.

b) 'Yeh gaana to aapke south ke SPB aur Yesudas bhi nahin gaa sakte' –

He was just fan of Hemachandra, It was the appreciation for Hema. Even we here in this forum support our favorite singer irrespective of his/her singing quality, then why not a Hemachandra's fan like my client praise Hemachandra. And above all nobody is perfect, he my client felt Hema sang better than SPB and Yesudas then there is no problem in that.

Me Lord..agar Subhas Jha ji yeh padke chilla uthe ki 'aisa lekh mujh se kahaan hoti??'Toh kya aap mujhe unse aage baitha dete???

c) 'Yeh SPB ka hangover nahin gaya abhi bhi tumhara' –

Me Lord:

It was not the criticism or against anybody, it was just to help his favorite contestant in showing his versatility. If ID can choose different kind of songs for Debo/Nihira everytime, then why not Himesh can suggest his favorite candidate to sing different kind of songs knowing that Hema can sing. And Hema proved in tha later stage of C2005.

d) 'Investing in my contestant is like investing in the country' –

Of course investing in Vinit wa investing in country, We know for the progress of economy money should move not to be stagnant. If public vote for Vinit then public money moves and ultimately it will help in country growth even in negligible quantity. But still it is the investment in the country.


e) 'Please vote for my contestant's love' – my question is - Was it a Sur sangram or a sawamvar program???

This is also related with marketing, picchle 20 years se main colgate ka add dekh raha woh kahte hain daant chamak jayega, aaj tak nahin chamka. Agar marketing point of view se love story banaya to kaya problem hai. Kaon jhooth nahin bolta hai, Prime minister jhooth bolte hain, Same press waalon ko shimla mein jo kahte hain woh delhi aate aate statament change ho jata.

keval ek line kehna chahta hoon...toothpaste daaton ke liye hote hain..to woh log daant chamkne ki baat kehte hain...ab maan lijiye agar Colgate waale apne ad mein daant ko chor ke baal ke baare mein baat karne lage to use aap sahi kahenge..is abhitukt nein sangeet ke kshetra mein kuch aisa laye hain jise sangeet ke saath koi taalukat nahin....yeh bahut bara gunaa hain my Lord.Aur is jurm ke liye abhiyukt ko kadi se kadi sazaa milna chahiye.Kam se kam jis public ke bharose ko isne thes pahuchaya...use maafi maangna chahiye.

f) 'Assam ki voice is not India's Voice' –

It was the policy of decenteralization, Centralization is not a good thing. It may be Debo get more recognization as Assam Ki Voice instead of India's voice.

Yeh sarasar bebuniyaad hain my lord....yeh desh ko aur todna chate hain.. uska sou tukre karna chahte hain...Toh is decentralisation ko agar itna badhawa dete hain to LTTE ya ULFA ke peeche haath dhoke kyun pade hain..Unhe bhi toh decentralize karne ka maksad.Shakti todne main nahi jodne mein hoti hain...

Till now Itna hi.





Maine bhi apna soch bayan ki hain...adalat se mujhe teh gujarish hain ki bharatiya sangeet ko is abhiyukt se bachana hain toh aap zaroor hamare paksh mein hi raai denge..
Edited by deepboy - 19 years ago
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Arrey haan ekdam, irshaad ho. to tum public mein ho ya hamari taraf? Kyunke defence mein ek poet ki bhi zaroorat hai.

Hum to reporter hain... jo hoga wohi batayenge.. ab depend karta hain kaun humme hire karte hain..!!😉😆😆

advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#40

My situational poem to felicitate this fine moment 😛😛😛

Believe it or not

One fine day in the middle of the night

Two dead men got up to fight!!

Back to back they faced each other

Drew their swords and shot one another!!!

A paralyzed donkey passing by…

Kicked one dead man in the eye

Who flew through a wall 6 feet thick

Without moving even a single brick !!!

And fell into a well which was completely dry..

Found that the water was six feet high !!

If you don't believe this tale to be true

Ask the blind man .. he saw it too !!!!

Edited by adi_0112 - 19 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".