SAATHIYAAAAAAAAAAA - Page 12

Originally posted by: ab_srgmp

In Saathiya, I liked Hema's flawed version better. In Tumse Milke Dil ka... then Hema wasn't that good. So we can't analyse songs/singers renditions anymore? That doesn't make us music lovers? Then as music lovers we should like all the singer in EMET then, because the songs are good right? Well, if it is not sung well (according to my tastes/evaluation), I don't like it (Please do not apply this statement to Sonu's Saathiya...as I said it was flawless, but didn't touch me). So am I not a music lover? Au contraire, I think.

You mean to say - Sonu did not sing Saathiya well! 😕 As I understand, a song is sung well, when it is pakka on sur, taal, diction and most importantly feel... these are pretty standard parameters for judging a song to say whether it is sung well or not!.. The moment we get our personal angle to it, we are not judging it strictly from the musical quality perspective, which I think we should all do as music lovers!

Originally posted by: adi_0112

To each his own..one man's meat is another man's poison..we should love the songs not the singers..when one loves a good song his called a music lover but when someone likes the song only because somebody he/she likes has sang ,then it is called fanaticism !!🤢

how well do we know sonu or hariji or hema to love them personally ????????..........i enjoy music created by these singers .......i never like to be in any fan clubs or be fanatic .......i enjoy vinit,debojit ,himani and all other new talents when they give good performance .........i never degrade anyone or make fun of them or call them names or go into the fan clubs and make fun of them becasue they like someone ......i think all of them are talented in their own way and if they come this far thats becasue of people who like their singing .......i don't know what gave you the impression that i am being fanatic ?????.....i appreciate all singers..........i even like some of kumar shanu songs ......😉😉...........so hang me 😆

You want to be hanged?? Your wish is my command !!OK done !! You are hanged !!

Na rahega baans ... na bajegi baansuri😆😆😆

Bechara hariharan,Sonu...yeh din bhi dekhna tha..😭😆😆

Originally posted by: sreejan

how well do we know sonu or hariji or hema to love them personally ????????..........i enjoy music created by these singers .......i never like to be in any fan clubs or be fanatic .......i enjoy vinit,debojit ,himani and all other new talents when they give good performance .........i never degrade anyone or make fun of them or call them names or go into the fan clubs and make fun of them becasue they like someone ......i think all of them are talented in their own way and if they come this far thats becasue of people who like their singing .......i don't know what gave you the impression that i am being fanatic ?????.....i appreciate all singers..........i even like some of kumar shanu songs ......😉😉...........so hang me 😆

please guys you sound as if though i hate sonu nigam ......don't take it personally .......i like sonunigam ......everyday when i workout sonunigam is the one i listen to first.....and please don't brand me as someones fan ......i hate to be in one corner .......i even don't hate HR 😆 😆 .....

Originally posted by: adi_0112

You want to be hanged?? Your wish is my command !!OK done !! You are hanged !!

Na rahega baans ... na bajegi baansuri😆😆😆

Bechara hariharan,Sonu...yeh din bhi dekhna tha..😭😆😆

arrey itna serious bhi mat hojav ki jail jana padey😉😉.........mein maroongi tho marronji sath mein tumey bhi le marungi😆😆😆.....

Sonu Nigam any day is the best he is one of his kind people like sonu are born very less such great talent and such versatality and such sweet voice is rare to find agree vinit hema himani nihira are good but they are fresh and new and have a long long way to go before reaching to sonu's level please dont insult sonu by comparing him to hemachandra

Kya baat hain..👏👏👏

Ise kehete hain deewangi...ek ubhadta huya singer ke liye do do jaan jaane ki afat!!😆😆

Agar mar gaye to usse famous kaun banayega??😆😆😆

Originally posted by: sreejan

arrey itna serious bhi mat hojav ki jail jana padey😉😉.........mein maroongi tho marronji sath mein tumey bhi le marungi😆😆😆.....

Originally posted by: ab_srgmp

The Huh was not meant to be a personal attack. 😕 It was in response to your question about whether u can express your opinion about Hema. I was confused why u were asking me that? You quoted me, so I thought that was meant for me. So, if that is what is classified as a "comprehension issue", perhaps it was as such.

Can your statement be construed as a personal attack? Or is that also another comprehension issue?

i dont think so- but it does seem to be a comprehension issue again. i have qualified with "given that" and have specifically used "i dont find...". i am not saying "you are not"... Technically, the problem cld be an issue with my comprehension or with urs in regards to this specific post, or how intelligible it seems to the other. In any case, the comment is directed to the post, i am not calling YOU unintelligent. No reference to you or anyone else. That is not the case with bindiqueen's post. That is calling certain people "low".

eg. someone writes gibberish (not saying you do that)- how wld one say that? that it is unintelligible to me. an "attack" wld be if someone says "you are unintelligent" because of the the way you write.

btw, this differentiation is useful to understand- will be happy to elaborate if needed. it might not be relevant in this thread but wld serve us well going fwd.😊

Originally posted by: srianne

Adi & Jaya, I don't understand what is wrong if someone says they preferred Hemu's rendition over Sonu's in one particular song. No one ever said Sonu is a bad singer. I love Sonu's songs myself but Hema's rendition of Saathiya touched me the most. That doesn't mean Sonu didn't do a good job, that's not the point at all. He probably was better or gave a perfect rendition, but it didn't appeal to me as much. We all understand Hemu has his own flaws and he needs to work on them before make it big in the industry, no one's ever denied that. But, that also doesn't mean whatever he sings is not supposed to touch our hearts, right??.

well said Sri.................

Originally posted by: adi_0112

Kya baat hain..👏👏👏

Ise kehete hain deewangi...ek ubhadta huya singer ke liye do do jaan jaane ki afat!!😆😆

Agar mar gaye to usse famous kaun banayega??😆😆😆

kisey famous karna hai humen ?😕..........kumar shanu is retired isn't he ???????😆.........i said hang me for liking some of kumar shanu songs ......arrey teek say pada karo adiji ......ab aap mujhe kiski fan bananey pey tuley hain ........😛i said i don't like to be anyone kaithan fan ........abh panka ban ney ka age gaya ........college mein koi aur bat thi ........abhi duniya alag sey dikhti hai ........life is short .....appreciate everyone and everything .......