SAATHIYAAAAAAAAAAA - Page 14

Originally posted by: srianne

I know... it so complex that as much as we like Hema as a singer, we also appreciate Nihira's, Debo's, Vinit's and Himani's singing too. I wonder why??? 😛

appreciate toh hum bhee karte hain. par "tadap" ek-doh ke liye hee hota hai😉

Originally posted by: chatbuster

yaar, ek complex sa program hai. when i feed in the inputs, it has an uncanny knack of prediciting people's preferences, their likes and dislikes when it comes to singers. bas, dont ask me how it works. 😛

agree totally .......even i think i can predict how people will react and what they say if we mention certain names........😛

Originally posted by: adi_0112

If we were to compare then i think Vinit is better than Hemu..Hemu after learning music , being a part of a musical family sings this well but Vinit without any training sings so well.👏👏

His Tera jadoo chal gaya was soooo good !

Had it not been for that stupid walk out incident and HR overhype.. I would have gome for Vinit any day..!!He has immense potential..

So truly said Adi ,I like HR but still believe that his overhyping has costed Vinit his victory he has hyped Vinit till the extend of irritation

Originally posted by: sreejan

totally agree ......tera jadoo chal gaya was really good .......it was his bad luck that Hype from HR never really helped him ........😊waise its nice seeing you appreciate vinit 👏👏.......

Vinit was superb in 'Tera Jadoo Chal Gaya' - He could have done lot better without all the controversy and hype that was unnecessarily created around him! Also its unfortunate for him now that he is totally restrciting himself to one MD. He needs to be open to all, or otherwise, he can just end up being on the losing side - something that will be very unfortunate for the singer within him

Originally posted by: sreejan

agree totally .......even i think i can predict how people will react and what they say if we mention certain names........😛

maybe we shld go into joint production together? kya boltee tu?😆

😆 😆 sure CB ....but if we use this on us then gadbad hojayega na ....scorpio vs scorpio ...we have to make a rule that we will never use it on us.......only on others 😉

Let me clarify Jaya ji. See the highlighted comments (you might have missed it the first time)

Originally posted by: jayc1234

You mean to say - Sonu did not sing Saathiya well! 😕 As I understand, a song is sung well, when it is pakka on sur, taal, diction and most importantly feel... these are pretty standard parameters for judging a song to say whether it is sung well or not!.. The moment we get our personal angle to it, we are not judging it strictly from the musical quality perspective, which I think we should all do as music lovers!

okay enough of these fightings yaar 😆 😆 don't pull it so much ......

hey i don't know if its posted but did you hear sonu on radio city .....if you did, ignore it ......if not here is the link......

http://sify.com/radiocity/

Sonu's version was better, acc. to me. I heard him perform it live a couple of years ago. 👏

Btw, why are ppl getting hyped over others saying that they liked Hema's version better? Its a matter of taste isn't it?

For example:

Aadesh said Paresh sang "Na tum jaano na hum" better than Lucky Ali

There was a poll on this forum where people said that Vinit or Sharib sang "Aashiq Banaya Aapne" better than
Himesh

Comparisons will always happen with the original singer, whether you like it or not. Be it an established singer with an amateur or vice versa. Without comparison, there is no judgement.

And in the end, this is music. So judgement is completely personal.

Originally posted by: bhale

Sonu nigam saathiya

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMtulEGHpks&search=Hemach andra%20saathiya

Hemachandra saathiya

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXsxhW8PGp8

Which one u like?

Hema's version sounds better to me. Not just this song, but most of the songs he sang he sounded better than original to me, let it be Manna Dey's Aaoo twist kare, Sonu's Saathiya, Hari's Nahi Samne, Hai Rama, ARR's Vande Mantaram. He sings with great soul and he has this god gifted great voice.

I just love this kid. Feel really bad when so many people insult such a talented kid. After success anybody will tell that the person is a great artist. But what is the use when u cant see and appreciate the arstist in a biginner. Hema is very highly potential and talented singer but not sure if he is as lucky as the established singers. May god bless him. Success or no success he has won the hearts of many people and all our blessing will be with him.