Banjyotsna vs Twinkle

After seing them both sing I really felt that Banjyotsna was far better than twinkle singing wise. Yes Twinkle is a good preformer and looks quite nice but hey her singing at the moment sounds like if I was sitting in a bar listening to a dull hot looking female singer sing. Banjoythna doesn't sound as good as the likes of Ujjani but after reading critisism i felt that she should atleast be seen as a singer that is better than Twinkle. But hey this is India and the public is bound to bring twinkle in the top 3 or 4.

Originally posted by: bluemangos

After seing them both sing I really felt that Banjyotsna was far better than twinkle singing wise. Yes Twinkle is a good preformer and looks quite nice but hey her singing at the moment sounds like if I was sitting in a bar listening to a dull hot looking female singer sing. Banjoythna doesn't sound as good as the likes of Ujjani but after reading critisism i felt that she should atleast be seen as a singer that is better than Twinkle. But hey this is India and the public is bound to bring twinkle in the top 3 or 4.

i have to agree with u on this.. banjyotsna is a better singer than twinkle..

I agree with you, I don't like Twinkle's singing at all, she doesn't have any connection with sur nor she has a good voice. Banjyotsna is ok and compared to Twinkle she is way better.

i have noticed every time twinkal sings, she tries to put sensual feel in the sings. pata nahi kyon woh har baar har song to melodious karne ki bazaaye sensous kar deti hai apni tarah 😆

Twinkle has unfortunately deteriorated in her singing... She had a few good performances in Challenge, but lately she has not impressed me at all.

my two cents on twinkle.. she puts in too much emphasis / emotions in some of her words while singing... she can definitely star in a serial... model but no she can't sing these days.. bonjoytsana yes though the poor girl is not a perfect singer but she atleast she gives it her best shot.. which is quite obvious.. she needs much more training of course to level with ujjani .. etc.

i am agree with sima samuel

Originally posted by: shesthebest

Twinkle has unfortunately deteriorated in her singing... She had a few good performances in Challenge, but lately she has not impressed me at all.

You are right she is not even singing 10% of her previous performances in rounds before agnipriksha in C2005. In those round she was one of my favorites.

Mangos, you are absolutely right that Banjyotsna is singing far far better than Twinkle.

Originally posted by: ritusahu

i have noticed every time twinkal sings, she tries to put sensual feel in the sings. pata nahi kyon woh har baar har song to melodious karne ki bazaaye sensous kar deti hai apni tarah 😆

So true!

I cannot agree with those people saying that Banjyotsna is better then Twinkle.

Twinkle has not been consistant enough in the competition but she had performed certain songs very well which cannot be forgotten but due to those classic performance she can be recognised as a good singer.
Banjyotsna cannot sing atall although this lady has a good voice. Twinkle concentrates maximum on glamour and performing and theres where she goes wrong. Otherwise certain songs which twinkle has rendered cannot be forgotten.
She has a very good modulation of voice.
Gives good expressions to the songs.

Afterall who can forget that song from CARVAAN
"Daiyaan yeh mein kaha aa phansi".

Banjyotna despite her good voice doesnot have a sense of sur.

This comparision is ridiculous.