Originally posted by: adwarakanath
Why should you be scolding Appa in PM, Anolda? Did he say anything wrong? Aren't all songs of Tere Naam copies and rehashes of L-Ps and Odhni directly lifted from a Pakistani song? Isn't the whole of ABA album copied? Isn't Gela Gela copied from R Kelly? It is our opinion that HR is a copy cat and is dumb. And we're very well allowed to express our opinions.
Wasn't this the same lady who used to badmouth ID and Debo and Assam in every other thread? Wasn't she the one who started picking fights for simple little things and spoiling the atmosphere in many threads relating to musical topics? WHo's she to act as moral police and that too with a marshallah track record that she has?
I had made a statement that the MDs and Singers of Bengal and NE are a cut above the rest in Bollywood Music. I was accused of being regional, no knowledge nonsense etc. The thread, which uptil then had comprised only of Articles on MDs and musical discussions was turned into a war zone and he whole atmosphere got spoilt.
Then there was the thread asking who do you think is the Greatest MD. I had, in jest, requested that HR's name not be mentioned here (and it is a valid question). I was attacked for that by this same lady and the atmohsphere of that thread also got spoilt.
Now this thread. Now Appaji and I are being accused of copy-pasting, info and being no-knowledge nonsense people. And that too by a member who's done nothing but attack mentors, contestants, forum members. No musical post to her credit. She's creating trouble for the sake of creating it. And that's why Appaji isn't getting scolded by anyone. He's absolutely right. It's his thread and he has the right to express his opinions. If we think HR is musically dumb, then it is our opinion and we have proof.
Khel khatam, tamasha band. Quoting my dad again - The dogs keep barking in the distance, but the caravan moves on undeterred.
Isi baat pe, LEST RACK!. How about we discuss the genius of Salilda?
For starters, which movie do you think is his best in Hindi?
Thanks Abhi.