ID analyses Hema/Debo/Vinit - Page 5

Originally posted by: N Sinha

Comparison to Kishore da ,.......... 😉

I agree Debo's voice quality is similar to Manna & Hemant da, I think Kishore da was in a league of his own, there won't be another like him.

Sinhaji, there won't be another Mannada or Hemantda tooHemantda had the best voice in all male singers till date, and the less said abt Mannada , the better😃

Originally posted by: simranlaks_2005

You are correct, he was the only mentor who has given standing ovation
to Hema, other two were just sitting there. QUOTE]

To give them some credit, I think the other two AS & HR were tensed since
they didn't know whether their respective gharana contestant were in or out!
ID was relaxed as Debojit was already in.

Were AS and HR tensed when Nihira got out?

i agree with musci pulse, he was very transparent...he criticised vinit, debo and every body when it comes to faults...but he is the one who was the most confused..and doesnt knwo what to say when it comes to drive a point..

one slip of tongue, ( that too int he entire SRGMP) was , when he said to appeal to audience in response to DEBO "Yeh bura nahi gaata" 😊

An example of AS's hatred to ID.
just rerun any of the episodes whenever he addresses all the mentors, he would say jatinji, lalitji , himeshji and ismail, notice no "ji" for ID. hatred....reeks.
It has something to do with being professional rivals too. AS started career in 1994, while ismail long after that, he played violin in JL's orchestra and made it big and even bigger than AS.

Originally posted by: raghav64

Well ID gave Hema 8 for his Lagaan song while giving Vinit 9 for the other Lagaan song. You are telling me he was being fair? Gimme a break!! They are almost all the same. If he gave him a standing ovation, it was because of Subhas Ghais' gesture.... MY Humble opinion

How much AS's friend HR given to Hema for that song? We know ID was a changed person after Nihira's exit. AS has given 6 or 7 to Debo, there might be ID taken revenge.

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

How much AS's friend HR given to Hema for that song? We know ID was a changed person after Nihira's exit. AS has given 6 or 7 to Debo, there might be ID taken revenge.

Exactly, So how is he different from the other two?

my 2 cents about ID is , that he is a genuine person but the problem starts when he tried to get smaat on things which he shouldn't be. Like when tried to get in HR's teritory of canvassing his candidate, peppy talks , he failed miserably...and the problem is that, he feels that he very knowledgable in the field of music..which is 100 % true..good to have that confidence..he is one of those gifted person , who can understand music even though they are not formally trained..He might have got some training but he learnt about music on the job. so whenever he speaks about music, that arrogance



Nope uselogic Ji

ID is extensively trained, music runs in his genes. He is a fully trained Violinist and his father Mr Hussain was a noted Saxaphone player, who could play several wind instruments at his will.
He has imparted a lot of training to his son, and then ID also had a guru for classical training in Mumbai, now Im forgetting is name........hmmmm
Not to mention that he was a lead violinist for both ARR & Jl at one point.
It takes helluva to reach the musical sense he has.

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

Were AS and HR tensed when Nihira got out?

they were jubiliant and desperately trying to hide thier glee.

Originally posted by: uselogic

i agree with musci pulse, he was very transparent...he criticised vinit, debo and every body when it comes to faults...but he is the one who was the most confused..and doesnt knwo what to say when it comes to drive a point..

one slip of tongue, ( that too int he entire SRGMP) was , when he said to appeal to audience in response to DEBO "Yeh bura nahi gaata" 😊

that was pathetic and unpardonable. BTW that must have fetched Debo half of the votes😉Both HR and AS acted patronising to Debo.

Originally posted by: raghav64

Exactly, So how is he different from the other two?

Close your eyes, think about bhagwan and ask this questiohn to yourself , you will get the answer. There is no need to share the answer with us.