ID analyses Hema/Debo/Vinit - Page 2

BTW what AS/HR would have said about Debo, Raghav...??

Originally posted by: N Sinha

Raghav I also think that his opinion has changed drastically on last few weeks after Nihira ouster probably.

yes, I agree. After Nihira's exit, all our opinions changed too.

I think he gave up on the stage, and doing to avoid conflicts, but here he is saying what he feels

If thats true ID has to answer this..

During Nihira's elimination(one of the worst elimination)t danger level,He said "Aap log yahan kaise aa gaye"?

He liked Himani very much so it was very clear that He dint want her to b out..

Now he is telling that Debu is equal to kishoreji and is comparing Hemu to SPB,Hariharan.. So whom did he want to be out?

ID is on the mark again ..... wish he could get his 50 Rupees back...

Originally posted by: N Sinha

BTW what AS/HR would have said about Debo, Raghav...??

Leave it your imagination.😆😆

From the beginning i have been mentionaing on the forum that debojit can be a good playback singer and now ID also said it.

I think Hema , nehira, himani can also be a good playback singer and about vinit, he needs to improve his voice quality and needs more tranning but he has talent and i am sure after 3-4 years he can also sing contineously for bollywood films.

All the best to them

Thanks

Pradip


Download debojit's wallpaper and songs here: http://silchartoday.com/debojit/debojit.html

Originally posted by: Surpremi

ID is on the mark again ..... wish he could get his 50 Rupees back...

Hmmmmmm}}

I still think he speaks from his heart Sunil ji.
I don't know the truth entirely like you but my assumption is that his opinion has changed a lot after Nihira's elimination.
God only knows.........
But atleast he is praising Hema is heavens, I don't expect same treatment from AS/HR.

Sinhaji, a lot of things have changed since the walkout drama. HR and AS were earlier on oppo sides. But suddenly they started behaving like long lost buddies 😕 Maybe they realised they have so much in common. 😉 As for ID, I think he started warming up to this natakbaazi and started behaving little politically himself. Earlier he was always alongside of HR in praising Vinit, if I am not wrong. Now suddenly he claims that Hema is better? Does it imply he was not giving all those marks bcz Hema was from AS's Gharana?
Plz how could he compare Debo with KK? Debi is good, no doubt, but is this not taking things a bit too far?
ID is a simpleton, and should not have participated in this circus. He started out very well with very good intentions and has done thousand times better as mentor than AS or HR. BUt now I think he is confused. What to do, what not to do? ID SAab, forget SRGMP, we would love to have another masterpiece from you.PLZZZ.

My question always has been how Vinit got away with 9s and 10s from ID
and Hema got only 8 for great performances like Vande Mataram and
O'Mitwa. The only reason I could think of is that he was put off with Adesh
for giving low scores to Debojit for certain songs. The comments he is
making now about Hema and Vinit contradicts the mentometers points he
gave them.

I am happy that he is at least acknowledging Hema's talent openly now and
another point I hope ID remembers that his own walk-out affected other
contestants!!