letsrock123 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Let me start off with saying that I am big Vinit supporter but yesterday being a lazy Sunday for me I went trhough the old Sa Re Ga Ma Pa episodes and I must admit that these 3 r indeed deserving finalists. Now, I know that there could have been some arguments here that Shabir, Nihira or Ujjaini should have been here. But then some people would have argued had there been a Shabir here instead of any of these 3 we would have said that 1 of these 3 shoud have been here.

What I have noticed is that everyone has their own opinion and everyone is elligible of that. I must also add that we are looking for a voice that can sooth a common Indian (be it in India or abroad), make him/her forget the daily worries and enjoy music. I have noticed that alot of people go to classical touch of music, I dont think that is the criteria here as we are looking for a voice that can suit actors in bollywood. My favourite Kishore Saab was 1 of them where his energy and voice bowled over the whole of India. On the other hand the great and legendary Manna Dey Saab was a pure classical legend, now who was more successful in Bollywood? I guess we all know Kishore Saab was. So if we talk about classical singing then I am sure there are plenty 14 year olds classical students who will be better than these 3 or even the entire crew.

So I request all to please stop throwing personal comments on each other and enjoy the music. I know I have been 1 of them who had gotten personal, I will not pass any personal comments and enjoy the show.

Once again Debu is good, may be he will get the songs Vinit or Hemu cant do , Hemu will get songs that Vinit or Debu cant and Vinit will get songs that Debu or Hemu cant. So i guess they all will make place for themselves in the industry. Also I appreciate Debu's mother's dreams, his ailing father's desires and also the oldage people's blessing. In the same token I appreciate Vinit's love, his cry for his mother and his new year's resolution of helping kids. Hemu is just too cool for everything. I am sure he will have a huge female fan following.

As for the mentors they are all good and I think we should respect the fact that they have been with these finalists for past 7-8 months, so there has to be some biased opinions now. I wish them luck and I think they are all good in what they do. If u notice they are ambassodors of different type of music and are very good in their own brand.

With that I must thank all for reading this.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1k

Users

6

Frequent Posters

ScarredLife thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
That was nicely put... thanks for you thoughts.. 👏
cutegirl10 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: letsrock123

Let me start off with saying that I am big Vinit supporter but yesterday being a lazy Sunday for me I went trhough the old Sa Re Ga Ma Pa episodes and I must admit that these 3 r indeed deserving finalists. Now, I know that there could have been some arguments here that Shabir, Nihira or Ujjaini should have been here. But then some people would have argued had there been a Shabir here instead of any of these 3 we would have said that 1 of these 3 shoud have been here.

What I have noticed is that everyone has their own opinion and everyone is elligible of that. I must also add that we are looking for a voice that can sooth a common Indian (be it in India or abroad), make him/her forget the daily worries and enjoy music. I have noticed that alot of people go to classical touch of music, I dont think that is the criteria here as we are looking for a voice that can suit actors in bollywood. My favourite Kishore Saab was 1 of them where his energy and voice bowled over the whole of India. On the other hand the great and legendary Manna Dey Saab was a pure classical legend, now who was more successful in Bollywood? I guess we all know Kishore Saab was. So if we talk about classical singing then I am sure there are plenty 14 year olds classical students who will be better than these 3 or even the entire crew.

So I request all to please stop throwing personal comments on each other and enjoy the music. I know I have been 1 of them who had gotten personal, I will not pass any personal comments and enjoy the show.

Once again Debu is good, may be he will get the songs Vinit or Hemu cant do , Hemu will get songs that Vinit or Debu cant and Vinit will get songs that Debu or Hemu cant. So i guess they all will make place for themselves in the industry. Also I appreciate Debu's mother's dreams, his ailing father's desires and also the oldage people's blessing. In the same token I appreciate Vinit's love, his cry for his mother and his new year's resolution of helping kids. Hemu is just too cool for everything. I am sure he will have a huge female fan following.

As for the mentors they are all good and I think we should respect the fact that they have been with these finalists for past 7-8 months, so there has to be some biased opinions now. I wish them luck and I think they are all good in what they do. If u notice they are ambassodors of different type of music and are very good in their own brand.

With that I must thank all for reading this.

now this is what i call a purely unbiased post!!

i am also a huge vinit supporter

i also try to be unbiased towards other contestants but somehow my vinit fixation doesnt permit me

but hats off to u for bieng so unbiased and positive

👏

letsrock123 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
Thanks
I hope we all enjoy the show now 😊
amukta thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
good article.i enjoyed reading it.but we all have views as we all are driven by passions.
whocares thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
That was a very good unbiased post. Thanks for posting it.
letsrock123 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Thanks and I guess people shud concentrate all the rivalry for India Pakistan matches if any not in music... I wish India all the best for the series
shreya13 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Hats off to you. 😛

I too believe that every singer has his/her own weaknesses and strengths and should be appreciated for havin'made till here. No point trying to prove the superiority of ur favorite by criticizing someone else's.

Go Vineet 😛 😛 😛
letsrock123 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: shreya13

Hats off to you. 😛

I too believe that every singer has his/her own weaknesses and strengths and should be appreciated for havin'made till here. No point trying to prove the superiority of ur favorite by criticizing someone else's.

Go Vineet 😛 😛 😛

Thats exactly it ... i hope we will c sum good show from here onwards 😊

letsrock123 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Is Vinit out? I mean how? Is he disqualified?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".