Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 8

omg. I'm not in India but I watch Sa Re Ga Ma Pa everyday. How did this happen?? 😕 I can't really say if Vinit, Himani, and Hema made the correct decision, but one things for sure... Debu didn't deserve to be the top contestant. After everything that happened in the previous episode, I knew that Debu was going to get the most votes, but I don't think he should have. Himani, Vinit, and Hema are all much much better singers than Debujit, and I guess if they chose to walk out, it's not a wrong decision. If Debujit won, it would be kind of an insult to their singing capabilities. If Nihira was in place of Debujit, I'd understand the highest votes thing and stuff, but Debujit.. no. I guess if Hema, Vinit, and Himani chose to walk out of the competition they are right on their part... but they did commit themselves to the competition from the begining. It is kind of like they backed out, and it isn't exactly good to back out of competitions that you have decided to compete in. I can't really say much about what has happened until I get to see the episode, but I don't really think that Himani, Vinit, and Hema were too wrong on their part, but they certainly weren't 100% right either.

Excuse me,
but debo doesn't only get votes from nei but from around the world and why do people call him assam singer,isn't assam part of india or some people lost their geographical knowledge and those of you who think that debo is not a good singer then maybe you guys vote the ones with good looks. wouldn't and why wouldn't debo want votes,every participant says that they want votes then why doesn't debo has right to say that?poor guy gets humiliated every episode.and u guys don't vote because debo is from assam and assam is poor, am i right? 😡 just admit that DEEBOJIT IS THE WINNER!!!!!!!! 😛

i completely agree that there should be judges in this phase as there always used to be in this show who have an understanding of music. public voing has really corrupted the show. how can we give the fate of these singers into the hands of people who seem to be voting on the basis of everything other than musical talent? also, i think that the mentors (especially himesh) are really trying their best to turn this musical talent show into an election campaign. who the hell cares whether vineet is in love or not? we should be judging these people solely based on their singing. i also think that gajendra singh has alot of this pre-planned to add masala in the show and put it under the spot-light. you never know, maybe the awkward results which we blame the janta for may not even be the true results. what say?

i think it was extremely worng in their part to have walked out .They knew the rules from the beginning and that it was going to be by public voting then why protest now?
forget the whole regionalism and debu's singing ranking,even then their walk out doesnt make it right.If u are a participant and know the rules from the beginning then its wrong for u to walk out when the decision is not favourable on ur side.
there was no restrictions on voting any number of times and nor was there any rule stating that a contestant's home state/town shldnt vote .I also feel that debu is an equally good singer maybe he didnt have his best day in the previous episode and that happens with everyone even the best and he has got the highest votes in the previous rounds too ,dont know why they protested this time.

I also feel that it was planned by one of the mentors to insigate them so that they could prevent/avoid their student from losing or getting eliminated.

all said and done,its a big loss for the music lovers.

Originally posted by: marvelous.malks

Sharib did not deserve to go out. I thought he was an excellent singer, if not winning the compition he would have atleast been in the top 5 or something.

Exactly!!

Originally posted by: arkaghos

A good singer . Good doesn't means only good voice or singing it means good at heart. Ready to accept defeats , ready to respect the elders not the spoiled brats like the other 3. I always thought hemu was different but now no he is also spoiled with the company of others.

some People were having problem with paresh bcos he is from UK [though he is an indian origin] so voting percentage was less and he was eliminated. Now some people are having problem with debo also that he is an assam singer but not a indian singer. what do u mean by that . Is assam not one the state of India.? hema was getting more votes from the south ujjaini was from kolkota etc. right from the beginning debo was getting good voting from NE. .now at this stage we cannot blame that debo is an assamee and not a indian. rajeev used to get only from champa. so what. only vinit,hema and himani are indian is it so. only they r entitled for top two or top one whatever may be.

Debojeet iz tyyte!!! Im like lil bit Nepalii like him hehe

So who was voted out if Debojit was safe?

Originally posted by: desi gurl

omg. I'm not in India but I watch Sa Re Ga Ma Pa everyday. How did this happen?? 😕 I can't really say if Vinit, Himani, and Hema made the correct decision, but one things for sure... Debu didn't deserve to be the top contestant. After everything that happened in the previous episode, I knew that Debu was going to get the most votes, but I don't think he should have. Himani, Vinit, and Hema are all much much better singers than Debujit, and I guess if they chose to walk out, it's not a wrong decision. If Debujit won, it would be kind of an insult to their singing capabilities. If Nihira was in place of Debujit, I'd understand the highest votes thing and stuff, but Debujit.. no. I guess if Hema, Vinit, and Himani chose to walk out of the competition they are right on their part... but they did commit themselves to the competition from the begining. It is kind of like they backed out, and it isn't exactly good to back out of competitions that you have decided to compete in. I can't really say much about what has happened until I get to see the episode, but I don't really think that Himani, Vinit, and Hema were too wrong on their part, but they certainly weren't 100% right either.

I agree with you that debu does not deserve to be on the top. but i do think that all this is pre-planned and written on some script. i mean, why would these three walk out like that all of the sudden. it is not the first time debu has gotten the most votes and it is not the first time that himani or hemachandra have gotten less votes. i also haven't seen the episode but reading all this does not seem realistic to me. if those three have really done that then i sure think they are being poor sports but still one of them only deserves to win because debu is simply NOT the best.

Originally posted by: moonlight

Is it possible that this is all scripted to boost the popularity of the show and increase the TRP's?

They could have easily edited all the argument parts and if all this really happened, they could have reasoned with the participants in the studio instead of recording it and showing it to everybody...

Please comment on why this is not possible...

Editing is not possible. even if they try to edit it ,the public who were in gallery post the information in the discussion forum. even the results are leaked before thursday bcos those who have witnssed in the gallery they give the information. it is a good think we come to know.what happend behind the scene.