Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 6

in the begning for preliminary rounds they bought the expert for judgeing and in the final round they made public voting system....which is not fair,
90%dosent now what is sur and taal.....they r just enjoying what they feel good in lesining and about reginol voteing this is not the first time .....
only cos of this regional voting nihira suffer ....
as mumbaikar very busy in their day to day work....
and what u thig ..since begning it is TAPAKONDA....
so they the programe orginazer r at fault.....
cos the title is INDIA ki voice not AP or ASSAmM or haryana.....

it is stupidiety of hemani hem and vinit iff u dont have guts to face defeat the can not take part like this standred shows .......this is disgusting....

they should have declared theire dicision before the start of the show and not after knowing debojit getting higest vote ....still they where waiting till the 2 position was declaired... its not hem or hemani or vinit
they had all this plan b4 mey b some one is guiding them...

NOW THE BEST THING GET BEST PEOPLE TO JUDGE BUT AFTER ELIMINATION OF TODAY ROUND SO THEY SHOULD B 3 PEOPLE THERE AS SOME ONE HAS TO GO AS PER THE SET UP FO THE GAME SHOW ...

Originally posted by: masterstroke

debojit in the qawwali round was terrific. i would request the three singers to sing that song on stage & let all of them be judged by an independent group of music stalwarts, like HPChaurasia, Rashid Khan, Amjad Ali, SKSharma & so on.

pls organisers, dont make a mockery of this show. it has given many singing stars.

you are right. Debojit sang a tough song comparing to Hema.. It is not a commonly heard song sang by participants.... but it was his mentor's choice of song, he tried but missed couple of notes. Ishmail Darbar also knew that and he was sure people would vote out Debojit based on the night's performance and he would not be coming again. Nihira was just an excuse. She was already out the previous week.

Debu sang the song "Tadap Tadap Ke" on the previous night brilliantly. I'm not anti-Debu. I'm just talking about fairness. In the Qawali episode, Himani and Vineet definitely rocked with 10/10 performance and Hemachandra did better than Debo but Hemachandra had easier than Debo's song to sing. So.. the statement here is not that Debo is bad.. but people are not voting based on the performance...

~memsaab

Hi everyone, my name is Gagan and this is the first time I have come to this forum to add my comments. So please pardon me if you think I am off the mark or writing too much. I guess to begin with I would totally agree with the comments made here by Vijay and supported/added/amended by others. I am seriously concerned about the quality of this show and its results. It appears to me (as mentioned by many of you) that regional forces on account of multiple voting are driving this show. This is absolutely ridiculous. I think giving full credit to all the participants, I would like to state that first and foremost the director of the show should take some charge. I mean what kind of non sense comments are being made by Himesh all the time. Whenever a question is asked or he gets an opportutnity to speak he only talks/ praises Vineet. Fair thing you should do for your contestant but in this manner, seems absoultely unacceptable to me. His question from Vineet on who would he choose between his mother and love, and then praising him by saying "mid blowing" is absolutely ridiculous. I am sorry but in front of entire world who is watching the show, at least in India I dont think I would find a guy, who would have answered otherwise. I guess this show has lost its charm and good singers such as Nihira, Himani are just being out classed by regional sentiments.

I honestly feel out of the remaining 3 atleast the best prevails.

Have a good day everyone.

Cheers

i think all five(nira too) r good but now if judge is public then all three(hema, himani,vinit) have to be accept public judgement.

Wht nira did last time. else i think nira is the best among all four.

if these three(hema,himani,vinit) are judge then why they not made the decision to go out and nira is winner. So if Debo is wining then public like him who want to listion him, Whatever be the issue, Now i feel all All three are looser and Debo is winner.
Else I like Hema after Nira's elimination.
But i never voted her or him.

And Gujji i want to request that use the time by introducing the other rounds to judge the singer. not show theses all show bazi, love seens and other issues.
I will watch it on Monday in USA.
Thanks for reviewes.

I don't know how many of you have heard the song which Debojit sang "Na to Karavan ki Talash hai". Hats off to anyone who even attempts to sing that song.

My favorite Judge: Ismail Darbar

My order of the most Talented Singers as per their performances:

1) Vinit
2) Himani
3) Nihira
4) Sharib
5) Debojit
6) Ujjaini
7) Paresh
8) Hemachandra

Here is the story as I see it...

When Nihira got eliminated ID was really shocked. However, although Nihira is an amazing singer she does not perform well under pressure. Remember her song after she was eliminated? It was the best I have heard anyone sing.

Anyway, Debojit is not such a good singer. But Ismail Darbar is an amazing Mentor. Debojit's performance of the famous Rafi Qawwali was out of this world. Far Far better than the other three. And HR and AS were really pissed off. Their contestants had already been rated and they got the perfect opportunity to slam ID and Debojit. Specially because Debojit used the Lyrics. So what! It is impossible to perform that song without lyrics. That song has been sung by 3 great singers.

ID was perfectly right to Quit. 6,7,9 INDEED! ID has always given his opinion without bias. Jatin Lalit and AS always used to underrate ID's singers. However, when Sharib was eliminated ID was the only person to come forward and offer him a song with Lata Mangeshkar.

Today's Episode

Everyone new that Debojit would get max. votes today. So AS and HR hatched this new plan of their singers quitting. I don't believe Himani, Vinit and Hem had anything at all to do with this. Poor kids they were cajoled into doing this by their mentors. It was the wrong thing to do simply because, What ID did was done on the spur of the moment. It was a reaction to horrible rating by AS and HR. What AS and HR did today was planned.

I have nothing against public voting or multiple voting. It's great! The more you love your singer the more you can vote for them.

I don't mind anything that is happening on Sa Re Ga. It's a great show. I also don't have anything against HR and AS. They are far better judges than Sonu Nigam and company on Indian Idol. The comments the judges give on Indian Idol are totally not about the performance! Then again Sonu did a great job on Indian Idol 1. He was also great on Sa Re Ga Ma but thats off the point...

Gaj Ji you are doing an incredible job by showing a true reality show with real emotions. Keep it going !!!

Hello,
After reading the current topic I feel like we are blaming wrong people. Neither contestants nor mentors should hold responsible for this. The main problem lies in the idea of public voting. And everybody knows who is the conceiver of this GREAT idea of public voting!!!

From the beginning, contestants are being selected on the basis of singing performance (and not any other factors like dancing and personality) by mentors and the gurus in Indian music. When top 10 contestants got selected and when judgment plays very crucial role in deciding the performance, the decision has been given to public. I was amazed by this logic. Top 10 contestants need to be judged by right personalities who really know Indian music, who can point out very minor mistakes.

The reason behind this GREAT idea is not to judge the contestants by their real talents but to gain popularity for the show by involving the public. I must say that they (SRGMP producers) are succeeding. So who is suffering.......
1. Contestants - They think their talent should be appreciated by public, which is not happening. So they are fighting among themselves.
2. Mentors - They think talented contestants should win, (again) which is not happening (Nihira and Himani are out of the contest). So they are fighting among themselves.
3. Public - They got emotionally involved in this show, they want their contestant should win.

For SRGMP this is a win-win situation. Whatever happens, whoever wins or whoever fights, show is getting more and more popularity.

From the day they have given power to the public to vote and decide among the Top 10 contestants, this show became a GAME and not contest. Only lucky person can win this game and not necessarily the talented one. So Nihira and Himani's results were not shocking at all (I personally believe both these girls should have won the contest).

well i think public voting does not get the best of results on these reality shows. if we take the examples of earlier reality shows like indian idol(where hopeless singers like ravindra ravi continued on public sympathy)or fame gurukul(qazi fame jodi...insult to music) nach baliye(where inspite of poor dancing rajeev and delnaaz stayed till 5th round.
the examples are many...and conclusion just one that the public voting is not the right mode. they should have followed what starone did in the great indian laughter challenge- called an expert like johnny lever rather than rely on public voting.

Originally posted by: memsaab

you are right. Debojit sang a tough song comparing to Hema.. It is not a commonly heard song sang by participants.... but it was his mentor's choice of song, he tried but missed couple of notes. Ishmail Darbar also knew that and he was sure people would vote out Debojit based on the night's performance and he would not be coming again. Nihira was just an excuse. She was already out the previous week.

Debu sang the song "Tadap Tadap Ke" on the previous night brilliantly. I'm not anti-Debu. I'm just talking about fairness. In the Qawali episode, Himani and Vineet definitely rocked with 10/10 performance and Hemachandra did better than Debo but Hemachandra had easier than Debo's song to sing. So.. the statement here is not that Debo is bad.. but people are not voting based on the performance...

~memsaab

I was beginning to get a little worried that there weren't too many sane folks remaining on this message board. Thanks for proving me wrong 👍🏼

Originally posted by: txn70

Hello,
After reading the current topic I feel like we are blaming wrong people. Neither contestants nor mentors should hold responsible for this. The main problem lies in the idea of public voting. And everybody knows who is the conceiver of this GREAT idea of public voting!!!

From the beginning, contestants are being selected on the basis of singing performance (and not any other factors like dancing and personality) by mentors and the gurus in Indian music. When top 10 contestants got selected and when judgment plays very crucial role in deciding the performance, the decision has been given to public. I was amazed by this logic. Top 10 contestants need to be judged by right personalities who really know Indian music, who can point out very minor mistakes.

The reason behind this GREAT idea is not to judge the contestants by their real talents but to gain popularity for the show by involving the public. I must say that they (SRGMP producers) are succeeding. So who is suffering.......
1. Contestants - They think their talent should be appreciated by public, which is not happening. So they are fighting among themselves.
2. Mentors - They think talented contestants should win, (again) which is not happening (Nihira and Himani are out of the contest). So they are fighting among themselves.
3. Public - They got emotionally involved in this show, they want their contestant should win.

For SRGMP this is a win-win situation. Whatever happens, whoever wins or whoever fights, show is getting more and more popularity.

From the day they have given power to the public to vote and decide among the Top 10 contestants, this show became a GAME and not contest. Only lucky person can win this game and not necessarily the talented one. So Nihira and Himani's results were not shocking at all (I personally believe both these girls should have won the contest).

I agree with your comments. But the show had to go for public voting coz other realtiy shows were more popular. It was a business decision. And how can you choose between great singers? Can you say that Rafi is better than Lata or Lata is better than Jagjit singh??

Once the judges have chosen the cream it's ok to let the public decide... what say? :)

Originally posted by: MysticaMagic

source: wikipedia.org

The ULFA considers itself a "revolutionary political organization" engaged in a "national liberation struggle" against the "occupation by India" for the establishment of a sovereign, independent Assam. It does not consider itself a secessionist organization, as it claims that Assam was never a part of India. It claims that among the various problems that people of Assam are confronting, the problem of national identity is the most basic, and therefore it seeks to represent "independent minded struggling peoples" irrespective of race, tribe, caste, religion and nationality.

========================================

ULFA's main aim is to get Assam liberated. How does Debojit Saha's (a Bengali) winning SA RE GA MA PA have anything to do with their goal?

Btw, you should read the latest Mumbai Mirror article on this controversy. Gajendra Singh himself has defended Debojit against any linkages to the ULFA.

We are talking about the poor kids here. I think they might not even know what is ULFA or any other terrorist organizations. If somebody calls them and tell them that they will kill them, naturally they might have got frightened. I too feel that ULFA has nothing to do with this and I feel that some shameless fans of Debo might have done this. Debo also doesn't have anything to do this.. he is an average middleclass guy and does not have that many connections.

This is all because of the Natak Baazi that has been done by ID last week. But what surprises me allot is, if Nihira votes are converted into Debo Votes, how can Debo get 80% from North East States. If everybody from NorthEast have been voting to Debo from the beginning why suddenly there will be so much percentage increase?

Infact, if only North East States are voting Debo, statistically he should get less votes this time as Nihira's votes might have been distributed among the other three.

Behind the scene we don't know what's happening. There might be many reasons why these young guys walked out. This may be a big drama purposely created by Zee TV. It's a pity that an entertainment show is becoming so violent.