Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 10

I just finished watching the episode. thanks to monika.goel for uploading the video.


I think, that was the most foolish thing one can do. they let down their Parents, their Gurus, their Mentors,all their relatives and all the people who have been voting and spending their money on the SMS and other calls. They are getting money without any mehnat, thats why they don't have respect for money and how it is earned.

It was a great example of cowrdness and jealousy. Shaan was right that from past seven months they are doing challegne challenge and when the real challenge has come, they are quitting. Debojit got the votes, because he keeps trying. his sachai is reflected in his work. He respects his Mentor.

They should be Thankfull that they got a platform to show their talent. agar na hota tu kya kartye??? nobody would even know about them. Mentors of all three have been teaching them, spending time with them, so much has been given to them, and thats the feedback by them?? they should be ashamed of themselves.

Ismail Darbar is an intelligent person, and loved the way he laughed when all three said they are quitting. lol. He knew this was coming. And his questioning was great. Sahi baat kar raha thye woh. why be so proud to be # 1?? He was right that if they decided to quit a day before, then why did they come to the show?? Once when Ujjini was feeling down, she didn't come to the studio. woh bhi na aatye.

I strongly believe that they have a stong support. or it was a kidish act, as all three are 17 years old, and at a young age they got more, which is not handled by them. They made a good show into K Serial. 75% of the things they said in their "reason" didn't make sense. Why bring Nihira. She didn't even said anything. Didn't even complain. that why she is voted out.

Jaab uss ko tension nahain tu why are u worrying about her. why not try to win, and give half of your prize to Nihira??? Show the big heart na, which you have. They say they all are freinds?? This is what freinds do?? Instead of showing happiness for your freind, you decided to quit??

Now I strongly beleive that Debojit should win, he is the most deserving canidate right now. with a clean heart.

oh, I forget the regional part.

It started from the day Raktima was eliminated. The reason which Shaan (or GS) gave was that both Ujjini and Raktima are from Calatta, so their votes might have split. and Raktima had to leave. and from that day on, all the contestants used to force their homeground to vote for them.

It was not Debojit who started it. it was already in the scripts of the show.

A comment one lady made in the episode that they want a voice of India no Assam. Ask her, where is Assam??? Why wasn't their any shor sharaba when others were getting high votes from their homeground??? why only point fingers on Debo?

In conclusion, this all walking out was bad decision which showed us, that those three don't trust their talents and have no trust in themselves and in God.

LISTEN GUYS,
THE FACT IS THAT AADESH SHRIVASTAV IS A MORALLY BANKRUPT PERSON WHO IS BEHIND ALL THIS NON SENSE.
I WOULD GO A LITTLE FURTHER WITHOUT HESITATION & CALL HIM A ************************************& HE CAN'T HIDE HIS TRUE COLOR EVEN ON A GENUINE MUSIC SHOW.

****NO Personal attack Tolerated on the Forum***Edited By The Mod****

ok my views on this odd episode or generally the voting system. SaReGaMaPa is a well known institution for Music and people who genuiely want to become singers. It has built its standards that only the best wins. Generally a very high caliber of students are selected.
But some how the marketing team thought it would be better to change the format n use the popular indian idol format of voting n multiple rounds.

I think as viewers who have watched fame gurucul have seen that a not very talented singer but an exellent dancer has surpassed all rounds due to voting n inspite being in the non surakshit side. We all know that there is multiple votings involved and that one vote do to get the best talent forward. This makes us greedy and vote a number of times.

This voting system does not come free. fans, family n friends are spending money in hope that their child wins. but this is not the best way of choosing a talent. I believe the mentors know ten million times more than me about their aptitude and flair to become a varsitile singer, and personally i find the voting system a waste.

Ok now about what those three did today. What were they trying to prove. I didn't get it. Just because the first time you got lower votes than usual does mean you stop and quit. the process is to be determine. I saw pure determination in Paresh. It was something extrodinary.

Till a limit I took all the drama between Vinit and HR lightly as they wanted the best to win and the mentors were scared that the public will choose the wrong one. I mean they know who is the winner and what happens if the wrong person wins.

I was extremely disapointed when Sharib was voted out a number weeks ago. But then i saw beyond and found vinit n hema a better singer between the rest. I can judge alittle. but when you have someone from your own family, place, country you feel like out and out supporting him/her. and you dont listen to the other singers properly. I dont have any partial reasons to choose someone it just depends on how they sang that day.

Drama was required till a perticular degree. but what happned now was beyond the limits. and should have not been aired as the shows are not live they are prerecored.

Here is my view and suggestion. I 100% agree with the previous couple of comments about voting. If possible here is what they need to do now: start again from top 12 candidates and put judges over mentor as they did before and go on......until top 4 will be remained.....then give public chance to pick the winner from there so that at least on of the top 4 challangers will be the winner ....also good for singer community....i think Zee should do that right now.

Thank you for starting this new thread.I will not be able to see the episode until Saturday, as am in US but I keep track of whats happening.I agree with most of you that walking out of any competition is not fair. Himani, Hema and Vineet did not walk out when they got the maximum votes and neither did they walk out when Vineet's personal affairs were used to overhype the show and fetch votes for him. It is too late in the day to realize the flaws of multiple voting.
Besides Hema's father himself mentioned once about Hema getting all the South Indian votes.
Look forward to more comments.

I agreed with rajarani, je hunuthiyo bhaisakyo, this is flaws of public voting like in Fame Gurukul and sometimes in Indian Idol. They should continue as it is if they can't go back to 12 challangers and start again.

Among the mentors, Aadesh and Ismail are fair in some extent but Himesh.

Awesome topic .. Was surpirsed to see Vijay post in the first place .. ! 😛

Now coming to the topic .. I haven't yet watched the episode yet .. But from what I have read here this is what I think ... Firstly, I still dun understand how North-East alone is able to pull 80% of the votes for Debu which makes him lead with a huge margin ... Considering the small states and everything .. but oh well, I guess that part of the country has some really wealthy people to spend Rs6 for every SMS just to see someone succeed .. bravo ! 👏

I am not against Debu ... I really like him .. But in the last episode I dun think he sang the best .. But people still voted and that's fine ...

Secondly, I see there no reason for the other three contestants to have walked away .. They should have done that when Paresh sang the worst of the lot yet got voted in .. They should have also done that when Swananda, Raktima or Sharib got voted out .. I very well believe that Sharib is much better singer than Debu, but that's my personal opinion .. And Nihira tops all these people ...

So them walking out was just B.S ... They just wanted to create drama ... Now I feel it's all scropted although Gajji Singh says that it's for real and very unlike other reality shows .. (off-topic: why the hell does he have to compare his show to others .. ?? 😡 and this has happened EVERYTIME he spoke ... ugh !anyways)

And what justice is it that Himani is now eliminated ??? Every gharana has to go one day or the other ... So what if Vinit got least votes??? He should very well go out .. That's the part of the game .. There were many who went out due to this Public Voting who shouldn't have .. And it was Vinit's turn ...

Why was Himesh asking Hemu to go out ?? 😕 Who is he to ask the contesants to go out .. ? Everything so far was fair when Ujjaini and Paresh left ... What's so special about Vinit that Himani was asked to leave ??? 😡 Everyone's in for one thing .. and tht is to win the competition .. Now it's winning it BY HOOK OR BY CROOK .. Coz Public voting is faulty as Vijay rightly pointed it out .. There should be no multiple voting in order to get an unbiased result ...

No! why would they do that ?? What about the TRP ??? In the end it all comes to that .. It's all BS when Gajji talks about finding the "true talent" ... It's all TRP !! and nothing but that .. ! 😡

True Talent was GONE when Swananda got eliminated ... when Sharib went out .. When Nihira went out and now Himani .. ! 😡

________________________________________________________
This is all my personal opinion ! No offence meant !

I am agree with Shivani's suggestion that they should recall top 12 contestants and make a pannel of atleast 5 judges (same like any beauty contest) and start from there and go on ......until top 3 or 4 candidates left.....then give public chance to pick the winner from there so that at least on of the top 3 or 4 challangers will be the winner ....also good for singer community....i think Zee should do that right now.