Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 71

Hi Vijay, Itz really a very gud topic 2 discus!
I dont know whether U ppl were supporting them 4 there step or not! But I really supported! Coz, I believe dat HIMANI was d best singer of d show! It was really tough 4 me 2 grasp d truth dat Himani is out of d show!!
Do U remember wat himani had sung d day b4 her gud-bye? It was 'der na ho jaye', & she was supperb! Debojit sang d worst dat day!! How can 1 tolerate dat he gets d highest vote,& Himani out of d show!!!!? At least Himani knew how she hd sung in dat episode as she is a singer,rite? Sreemoyee

Can someone please say if vinit is voted out? I hope he is Hemachandra should win.

I think the true winner is Nihira, she is a great singer compare to all these untrained (except Hemachandra) street singers or train singers who are left behind, I think Indian public been so unfair with Nihira. God bless Nihira. Among last 4, I would like to see Hemachandra winning. If it's not him then this show really sucks 😛 😛 😛

Hi Everyone. I am from the UK and as such I am unaffected by any regional, cultural, caste-based or tribal alliances. I have been watching the same singers and listening to the same songs as all of you in India and I am struck by the amount of bias which is colouring the public's judgement. Might I suggest that when listening to these fine challengers that every one close their eyes and just listen? Let their looks be irrelevant; their love interest be immaterial; their childhood, background and geography be of no consequence.
Here is my objective and yet entirely subjective view of their talent.
Vinit: Excellent singer,wonderful voice control, excellent Hindi pronunciation. Very smooth voice which is perfect for soulful ballads. However he is only 17 and this is evidenced by the lack of the deeper registers in his voice. Sometimes he simply sounds like a boy particularly when attempting a delivery with energy.
Hemchandra: Superb singer with truly excellent control. Good vocal range which is very well suited to playback singing. Sometimes a little reticent in his delivery but can deliver a powerful performance. Pronunciation can sometimes be a little suspect.
Debojit: Immensely gifted singer with a breathtaking vocal range. Voice quality is silky smooth and perfectly suited to playback singing. Has no shortage of control and power and can raise the hairs on the back of your neck. On his day he is the best of the male trio. However it is not always his day and he can be inconsistent.
Himani: Stunningly talented singer with flawless control. Voice quality is superb and delivery is choc-full of emotion and drama. Can send a shiver down your spine or make you cry at will. The only flaw I can pinpoint is her relatively limited vocal range. The upper octaves are beyond her reach and this may limit her choice of songs.

I cannot make the split between Debojit and Himani. Both are simply superb singers and it does not feel right to make a loser out of one. I wish all four challengers the best of luck and I feel sure that they will all make their parents proud.

Originally posted by: catwoman99

Hi Everyone. I am from the UK and as such I am
unaffected by any regional, cultural, caste-based or tribal alliances. I have
been watching the same singers and listening to the same songs as all of
you in India and I am struck by the amount of bias which is colouring the
public's judgement. Might I suggest that when listening to these fine
challengers that every one close their eyes and just listen? Let their looks
be irrelevant; their love interest be immaterial; their childhood,
background and geography be of no consequence.
Here is my objective and yet entirely subjective view of their talent.
Vinit: Excellent singer,wonderful voice control, excellent Hindi
pronunciation. Very smooth voice which is perfect for soulful ballads.
However he is only 17 and this is evidenced by the lack of the deeper
registers in his voice. Sometimes he simply sounds like a boy particularly
when attempting a delivery with energy.
Hemchandra: Superb singer with truly excellent control. Good vocal range
which is very well suited to playback singing. Sometimes a little reticent in
his delivery but can deliver a powerful performance. Pronunciation can
sometimes be a little suspect.
Debojit: Immensely gifted singer with a breathtaking vocal range. Voice
quality is silky smooth and perfectly suited to playback singing. Has no
shortage of control and power and can raise the hairs on the back of your
neck. On his day he is the best of the male trio. However it is not always
his day and he can be inconsistent.
Himani: Stunningly talented singer with flawless control. Voice quality is
superb and delivery is choc-full of emotion and drama. Can send a shiver
down your spine or make you cry at will. The only flaw I can pinpoint is
her relatively limited vocal range. The upper octaves are beyond her reach
and this may limit her choice of songs.

I cannot make the split between Debojit and Himani. Both are simply
superb singers and it does not feel right to make a loser out of one. I
wish all four challengers the best of luck and I feel sure that they will all
make their parents proud.

I like your analysis. I am not the biggest fan of Himani but you were right
on target IMO on the males.

Can anyone give url to read post for this weeks elimination? is Vinit really out? coz now rumprs are that hemu is out :(

Originally posted by: catwoman99

Hi Everyone. I am from the UK and as such I am unaffected by any regional, cultural, caste-based or tribal alliances. I have been watching the same singers and listening to the same songs as all of you in India and I am struck by the amount of bias which is colouring the public's judgement. Might I suggest that when listening to these fine challengers that every one close their eyes and just listen? Let their looks be irrelevant; their love interest be immaterial; their childhood, background and geography be of no consequence.
Here is my objective and yet entirely subjective view of their talent.
Vinit: Excellent singer,wonderful voice control, excellent Hindi pronunciation. Very smooth voice which is perfect for soulful ballads. However he is only 17 and this is evidenced by the lack of the deeper registers in his voice. Sometimes he simply sounds like a boy particularly when attempting a delivery with energy.
Hemchandra: Superb singer with truly excellent control. Good vocal range which is very well suited to playback singing. Sometimes a little reticent in his delivery but can deliver a powerful performance. Pronunciation can sometimes be a little suspect.
Debojit: Immensely gifted singer with a breathtaking vocal range. Voice quality is silky smooth and perfectly suited to playback singing. Has no shortage of control and power and can raise the hairs on the back of your neck. On his day he is the best of the male trio. However it is not always his day and he can be inconsistent.
Himani: Stunningly talented singer with flawless control. Voice quality is superb and delivery is choc-full of emotion and drama. Can send a shiver down your spine or make you cry at will. The only flaw I can pinpoint is her relatively limited vocal range. The upper octaves are beyond her reach and this may limit her choice of songs.

I cannot make the split between Debojit and Himani. Both are simply superb singers and it does not feel right to make a loser out of one. I wish all four challengers the best of luck and I feel sure that they will all make their parents proud.

Nice analying there 👏 but just a bit late for himani as she's out. she was a superb singer. now the fight is between Debu, Vinit, and Hemu. all of them are soo gud. i want either hemu or debu to win. vinit is very arrogant.

Originally posted by: djpagal

exactly when vinit was crying he should have let him be .. dont need to announce it to the world they know whats happening .. they see it too but he is ruining vinits emotions ... and yea why did ID have to walk out .. remeber monkey see monkey do ... they kids were upset so they wanted to leave .. ID set the example they thought it would be okay to do or something

YOU ARE SOOOOOOOOOOO RIGHT I AGREE 100000000000000000%

Originally posted by: 54321

YOU ARE SOOOOOOOOOOO RIGHT I AGREE 100000000000000000%

very well said! ID set the example by walking out...or staging a walk out..y blame kids for following ID?

I m in US watching Sa re ga ma pa....
well, People in India should realize....British policy of "Divide and Rule" caused MESS in INDIA...
than why on the earth ....This show has the SATATE WISE voting policy.......
Dude, that means THE BEST ONE WILL LOOSE!!!
O' my dear peeps! in INDIA....Forget this STATISM.....BE INDIAN....JUST A SICNERE INDIAN ....AND WE ALL WILL WIN!!!