Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 59

It was a bad move on their part to walk out.

Guys one thing I still don't understand if this guys are mentors or jokers and what is that mentor meter is for. After all the drama Ismial darbaar had face to say oh these guys want to walk out , they want to copy me to bag more votes. ofcourse the kids want to copy you cause you moron is mentor. OR till the defination of metor has change recently.
Like a college guy he is keeping his hand on Vineet's shoulder and saying aa dekhe tujhe kitna aata hai. tu debojeet se achaa gata hai.
Now entire world knows that debojeet is worst among all the four, he is there cause of vote bank and that is fine cause that is the rule of saregamapa. No hard feelings for Debojeet, he deserves to win cause as per rule he is able to generate that kind of vote.
I am sorry for hemani and more for nihira.
But what is this chimpanjee doing in there.
He publicly abused Indian masses by saying yeh public khokli hai. How can they air that, he should have been thrown out, it is so anti indian statement. Why people are ignoring that. It reflects the attitude of Ismail darabar. And the worst comes in the second episode where every one is saying sorry to ismail. So what he gave some good music. He is lucky to get way with it.He should be arrested for this.
Today he did it and tomorrow some one else will speak like that. It is not a dialogue in a movie or a serial, it is talking to public through Zee TV.
Seeing all this I still feel we still dont teach self respect to our coming generation, Vineet shouldnot have taken that shit. I agree the kids did wrong but Mentors did not handle the situation well either.

Originally posted by: mademoise11e

It was a bad move on their part to walk out.

Agreed

After all, it is a challenge/competition. One has to be voted out. All are great singers, but from this point on, it just depend's on one's luck.

After so many years of Independence we are still having communal fights, whenever 4 Indians meet anywhere in the world they will start Tu South Indian, Mein North Indian. Get over with it, we all are Indians right. Secondly, all the great singers of bollywood did not play Sa Re Ga Ma to make their career, its just a platform to show your talent to the world. Wether one wins or not if he/she is a good singer, he/she will be recognized and would get a break anyways. Sa Re Ga Ma was a nice show for 10 yrs cause there was no public voting. When you introduce public opinion this is bound to happen and its just another reality show, got to see reality shows in US where people throw furnitures at each other and would need security on the stage to stop the fight. There is nothing new when Nihira or Himani got voted out cause of poor votes, its more visible and a big deal just because we are in final rounds. The contestant who got voted in earlier rounds were also good but didn't have a good vote bank. How is this different from Congress I or BJP coming to power cause one party has a stronger vote bank than another.

Originally posted by: seepja

I think all the 3 did right to walk out of the stage. Atleast they deserve much better than this. Gajendra Singh has made SA RE GA MA PA a tamasha stage. It seems he staged all this .

I was impressed by Himani when she apologised to Ismail Darbar but he didn't even acknowledge it. This shows his character. He's the one always saying to vote for best. If debo is what he think is best, then I do doubt his judgement and his musical background. Mentors should act as mentors and not fight for their pride.

😆 They apologized (contestents and their family members) only because Gajendra singh made them to do so, and all of them offended Debu in front of entire nation and and they should have apologized to him.

We (my wife and me) have been watching SA RE GA MA PA from Canada with great interest for last several months. By the way we are not Indians or NRI.

We blame SA RE GA MA PA authority for inviting the trouble by providing breakdowns of the votes. Does it really matter if votes are coming from Seven Sister States or Hariyana or somewhere else, as long as Indians are voting?

Lets us be fair. People have different opinions on the contestants walking out. Let us leave it there. Gajendra Singh was very upset. He blasted them right in front of the camera. His reaction at that time is understandable.

The good thing is that the candidates later apologized to the public and to the mentors. Their parents too apologized.

Let us all live with the assumption that the candidates were all alone in deciding to walk-out.

Interesting questions:

1. Why didn't we have a heated discussion of this type when ID walked out. Though his reaction (for the reason he quotes) is UNDERSTANDABLE, isn't there an age difference between him and the kids wherein one expects more maturity in a person of his calibre. I pity people who term him 'poor ID'.

2. Strangely GS didnt shout at him as he did in the other case. Instead he had DETAILED DISCUSSION with ID to convince him back into the show.

Again, I don't want to support or oppose the candidate behaviour in this message. Also, if Debu finally wins this contest on the basis of votes, let it be that way as this format is pre-defined.

But ID's walk-out can cause a heavy damage to the show with people divided as pro-Debu and anti-Debu. You will now see Himani's fans vote for Vinit or Hem not because of their performance but with an anti-ID feeling.

I think Vinit, Hema, and Himani all three of them should be kicked out of the show 😡 they have given a bad name to the show and they don't deserves to be in the show anymore, Gajneder singh is too nice to have these three still performing in the show. It's a shame that they have no respect for their mentors and the public. Debu is the true winner in the show and his Mentor Ismail ji . Debu has proved himself that he is not only a good singer, he is a good human being too, Debu hang in there, you are going to be the winner at the end, my support is all with you, Debu you need to kick the ass of this stupidest kid VINIT 😛 he thinks too much of himself, so arrogant and no respect what so ever 😡 I didn't like Vinit's parents as well, when they were fighting with Debu's wife. Himani's mum is so pathetic, who didn't even apologized to the public and mentors, these people have brought the show down, basically they have ruined their own carrier before it even starts. Himesh is the big fag ass. Excuse my language. He is acting all gay with Vinit, giving him all the hype for nothing 😡

[quote=mskanth
]Posted: 25 January 2006 at 3:49pm | IP Logged

------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------

Lets us be fair. People have different opinions on the contestants walking out. Let us leave it there. Gajendra Singh was very upset. He blasted them right in front of the camera. His reaction at that time is understandable.

The good thing is that the candidates later apologized to the public and to the mentors. Their parents too apologized.

Let us all live with the assumption that the candidates were all alone in deciding to walk-out.

Interesting questions:

1. Why didn't we have a heated discussion of this type when ID walked out. Though his reaction (for the reason he quotes) is UNDERSTANDABLE, isn't there an age difference between him and the kids wherein one expects more maturity in a person of his calibre. I pity people who term him 'poor ID'.

2. Strangely GS didnt shout at him as he did in the other case. Instead he had DETAILED DISCUSSION with ID to convince him back into the show.

Again, I don't want to support or oppose the candidate behaviour in this message. Also, if Debu finally wins this contest on the basis of votes, let it be that way as this format is pre-defined.

But ID's walk-out can cause a heavy damage to the show with people divided as pro-Debu and anti-Debu. You will now see Himani's fans vote for Vinit or Hem not because of their performance but with an anti-ID feeling. [/quote]

I am not agreed with that point of yours. IS had quite a good reason to walk-out unlike the 3 contestants. After the performence of Debu himesh gave 7 and adhesh gave 6 but Jatinji gave 9. Isamailji was always upset with the marking of the other 2 mentors. If you want to really understand the situation then watch the last 10 episodes carefully. Or you can read in the forum about it.

Another reason was is that Ismailji clearly explained his reason for walking out and no one opposed to it. In matter of fact Gajji went himself to bring Ismail ji back. And when the contestants declared that they are going to walk-out, they had no reasons to give. They hesitated. And In the next episode they apoligised.

Ismailji is a neutral man. A real man. Ek Sachaa Musulman. I have great respect for him.


Sagar
Canada, montreal

Originally posted by: supersag_200x

[quote=mskanth
]Posted: 25 January 2006 at 3:49pm | IP Logged

------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------

Lets us be fair. People have different opinions on the contestants walking out. Let us leave it there. Gajendra Singh was very upset. He blasted them right in front of the camera. His reaction at that time is understandable.

The good thing is that the candidates later apologized to the public and to the mentors. Their parents too apologized.

Let us all live with the assumption that the candidates were all alone in deciding to walk-out.

Interesting questions:

1. Why didn't we have a heated discussion of this type when ID walked out. Though his reaction (for the reason he quotes) is UNDERSTANDABLE, isn't there an age difference between him and the kids wherein one expects more maturity in a person of his calibre. I pity people who term him 'poor ID'.

2. Strangely GS didnt shout at him as he did in the other case. Instead he had DETAILED DISCUSSION with ID to convince him back into the show.

Again, I don't want to support or oppose the candidate behaviour in this message. Also, if Debu finally wins this contest on the basis of votes, let it be that way as this format is pre-defined.

But ID's walk-out can cause a heavy damage to the show with people divided as pro-Debu and anti-Debu. You will now see Himani's fans vote for Vinit or Hem not because of their performance but with an anti-ID feeling. [/quote]

I am not agreed with that point of yours. IS had quite a good reason to walk-out unlike the 3 contestants. After the performence of Debu himesh gave 7 and adhesh gave 6 but Jatinji gave 9. Isamailji was always upset with the marking of the other 2 mentors. If you want to really understand the situation then watch the last 10 episodes carefully. Or you can read in the forum about it.

Another reason was is that Ismailji clearly explained his reason for walking out and no one opposed to it. In matter of fact Gajji went himself to bring Ismail ji back. And when the contestants declared that they are going to walk-out, they had no reasons to give. They hesitated. And In the next episode they apoligised.

Ismailji is a neutral man. A real man. Ek Sachaa Musulman. I have great respect for him.


Sagar
Canada, montreal

I respect your opinion. I dont understand how it is linked to being a musalman. Anyway, let me not deviate the topic.

1. In the episode Nihira was out, Debu made a small mistake similar to the one in Qawali round. The judges gave them similar points (less) while Nihira bagged very good points in the round.

However, we all know the result. It shows judges feedback has little impact on votes or voters.

2. ID made a comment 'they sent nihira out, they are trying to do the same to debu' referring to the judges. How could 'they' be implicated in Nihira's exit when 'they' clearly gave good points to her.

3. Agreed that Debu attempted a difficult song and hem opted a simple one. The point is, at that level one cannot afford to make a mistake.

Again, this is only my opinion. ID's walkout still sounds unreasonable to me.