Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 38

One more thing, has anyone noticed that the results are shown on a "mento" meter shouldn't this be "mentor" meter...

LET'S SUMMARIZE
THE MOST ORIGINAL VOICE HEMA IS STILL THERE.
HIMANI WAS THE SECOND MOST ORIGINAL VOICE.
NIHIRA WAS THE MOST PERFECT SINGER.
IN TERMS OF APPEAL PARESH HAD IT. HE CAN BE GREAT IF HE COMPOSES HIS OWN SONGS.
VINIT AT BEST IS A POOR VERSION OF SONU NIGAM
DEBU IS A GOOD GUY BUT IT DOESN'T MATTER, ONLY ONE WILL BE INDIA'S CHOICE.

FOR ME HEMA HAS ALWAYS BEEN DIFFERENT AND NO MATTER WHAT HE WILL STAND OUT WITH MUSIC DIRECTORS; DIRECTORS WILL CHOOSE ASHA BHONSLE OR SONU NIGAM RATHER THAN THE OTHER GUYS. LET'S NOT BE EMOTIONAL AND VOTE FOR THE ORIGINAL

i COMPletly agree with dkulkar

verybody has watched debu's performance at its poorest level from past few weeks , his voice crashed two-three times , he's getting UlFA support,multiple votes,sms---- vradhhaashram creep story(just to win), wife struggling(well she's doing so to get flat in MUMBAI 👎🏼)

hema chandra go to south ,your voice too cracked in some of your performances , you were too arrogant and over-excited like your father,"I remember him saying "he will definately win",I say back off, we don't welcome you here in the north , there are many movies popping up out everyday so leave space for vineet ,he is the deserving candidate

himani ,you don't have any nihira competeing against you ,otherwise you would have eliminated pretty early,by the way proove yourself better than Vineet by selecting and singing a very high pitch song,
"chitthiya ni dard firaq waliyaan " song from movie heena and the other song "der na ho jaaye kahin" were very high scale songs but you started from a very low scale - why???????

Vineeet , all the best , and don't give up , we are , with you,you really deserve the no. 1 position, better from the rest of the lot but when you step in the music industry ,do keep-on brushing your god-gift.
someone in the forum pointed out that you imitate sonu-nigam , but I think sonu nigam immitates Late Mohd. Rafi ,and your voice resembles that of Mohd. Rafi,good job Vineeet,cut this creep aside of your girlfriend and topi ,once -twice it was okay but on and on it has become boring , ask himesh not to do all this.

Assam is not a crappy little state! who ever said that doesnt know what they are talking about!

Well said Vijay,

I too feel "Multiple" voting is not a good one. This may stop a genuine candidate.

I donot want to speak about DEBOJIT, VINIT, HEMU and HIMANI. As we already saw their performances and their QUALITY.

Moving forward, Once the winner of the show (any music show) is decided, later on "we have to BEAR his/her album or songs,.." or "we can ENJOY his/her album or songs,..". The choice will depend on the QUALITY of the winner.

We have an recent example from FAME GURUKUL. I(we) did not enjoy the album made by winners!!!! Even judges liked other participants from the show as winners, based on the QUALITY.

If we vote by craze, like based on person or AREA, after they become champions, they will suffer (as they MAY not produce QUALITY music) and evantually we have to suffer, because of the LACK of quality music to enjoy.

So, I think, we have to think twice before VOTE.

I am sorry if this hurts anyone.

Thanks,

A music lover.

<i>We encourage some serious discussion on this so please do not drop ONE liners or try to deviate from the topic and please be Rational!</i>

I voted Yes, that is in favour of the three contestants walking out. I appreciate the tone of this thread and the call for serious discusison and rational debate, so let me explain that vote clearly.

What I support is not the walkout as such but the contestant's right to do that if they feel that this is what they must do.
I have been following SRGMP for so many years now and really have loved its tone. This particular season was markedly different - there were good singers as usual but the respectful decent tone was spoilt by squabbling mentors who frequently argued and lambasted each other. I remember quite a few judges were very shocked.

Anyway, as the show went on the voting became very significant. I don't approve of people asking for votes on the basis of ANYTHING OTHER THAN SINGING - no matter who does the asking - Debo or Hemachandra.

These people are singers and they KNOW who sings how well and the idea is for the best singer to win. So we need basic honesty here. For instance Himani always says "Agar mera gaana achcha laga to please vote kijiye" I appreciate that very much.

If Debo had been the best singer I would have voted for him. I'm from the south but I vote more for Himani because I think she's the most complete performer of them all. I expect that everyone should vote on that basis.
Unfortunately with all tis hype created by the show, the mentors, and the participants - one region has outvoted the rest of the nation. Their loyalty to their man has exceeded their musical judgement. Which may be democracy but still something I don't like because music suffers in the bargain.
About the walkout: 'The show must go on' is a principle in the show business, I appreciate that but there are bigger things than this show and that is each person's integrity to themselves.
My feeling is the three who walked out also felt this very strongly. They may eventually come back and wind up the show, but they registered their protest against this kind of bias - and I support that.

MAY THE BEST SINGER WIN!

😛

An individual can be a good artist if only he is a good human being ( as often mentioned by the gr8 Mentors ) . For being a good human being one should always respect the opinion of others irrespective of the caste creed or sex . The contestants in this show do not show any such inclination towards respecting the people's voice or may be they and their mentors think that NE does not understand much about music . To remove this false notion from their mind let them be informed that the NE also has a vibrant and rich culutural heritage that can compete with any part or province of the country .

Hence till this immature brats do not develop a sense of respect towards other communities present in the country , they do not deserve to participate in any national forum . Let them create their own albums and sell them to people of their choice . They are for sure not the choice of the public .

Though I am not from the NE still I strongly condemn such attitude and shall voice my protest by voting for DEBOJIT .

firstly,i think the concept of public voting itself is wrong!!specially for a show like sa re ga ma pa which has always shown high quality of music and is considered to be the greatest talent show for 10 years. sometimes i feel they should not revel which stae the hail from and also asking for votes in ur mother tongue is completely unwanted.the public(including me)always get emotional and sentimental when it comes to voting for a person from ur state or caste.just like it happened with ravinder ravi of indian idol1.saregamapa has been a genuine talent hunt for many years,it has given india talented singers like shreya goshal,kunal ganjawal,sunidhi chuahan,etc and i really hope that it goes back to being a show which people watch for good music and not get involved in any kind of political games

Originally posted by: sharu16

firstly,i think the concept of public voting itself is wrong!!specially for a show like sa re ga ma pa which has always shown high quality of music and is considered to be the greatest talent show for 10 years. sometimes i feel they should not revel which stae the hail from and also asking for votes in ur mother tongue is completely unwanted.the public(including me)always get emotional and sentimental when it comes to voting for a person from ur state or caste.just like it happened with ravinder ravi of indian idol1.saregamapa has been a genuine talent hunt for many years,it has given india talented singers like shreya goshal,kunal ganjawal,sunidhi chuahan,etc and i really hope that it goes back to being a show which people watch for good music and not get involved in any kind of political games

i agree with u.