SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 63

Originally posted by: kunmoh

I just read on Mumbai mirror that Himani has been ousted and 😡 Debu got maximum votes. Himani, Vinit and Hemachandra walked out. It serves everyone right. The voting by public should be eliminated. We know how Debu performed in last two episodes. How can he still be on the top? SAREGAMAPA was best judged by the excelled judges they invited earlier who knew what singing is about. Voting is a pure reflection of how much resources (money, regionalism) used. Please bring back the glory of the show. Himani is the best and does not deserve to leave. The result should have been just the opposite. I will have to stop watching the show now (if it stays like this) if it resumes .... as per the article they are still not back.

You are concerned about himani's ousting, and debo's top rank. Have u heard himani's hujurewala [black and white pic round] song sung by her it was so horrible . This song was a hit in 1970 [like kajarare song of bunty and bubli] sung by ashaji and kamalbarot composed by op nayyar. When a good singer like nihira [better than himani] is ousted himani's oust is nothing before that. As regard to debo he sang such a tough song sung by three male singers in different sur in qawali has given a good performance and debo deserves to be in top rank. [ remember public were very unhappy the way AS and HR gave marks to debo as 6 and 7 respectively. public has punished AS for giving purposely less marks to debo though he performed well..

Originally posted by: ProudlySA

I have just watched the episode where Ismail Darbar walks out and think its a really sad day when sportsmanship goes out the window. His behaviour, regardless of all the "emotions" running rampant was most unprofessional and inexcusable. Surely there is more than one way to skin a cat. If he believes so much in Nihira's talent than go ahead and give her a break yourself. It's not the end of the road and don't ditch Debojit in mid journey??? Is that what he calls mentoring?

Everyone has favourites, there is no disputing that, but ultimately someone has to win. I just hope that whoever the person is that wins, wins on talent alone and not on emotional blackmail. I pray that the Indian public does not get swayed by the theatrics of Ismail Darbar and Himmesh Reshmiya.

Your comment on ID is not fair.He is the only mentor who is having the sportsmanship by praising every challenger irrespective of any gharana., . He did not ditch debo as u mentioned. he was waiting for debo's chance and when he saw the marks in mento meter given by AS and HR as 6 and 7 respectively he was very upset and he cannot tolerate another injustice to his challenger . so he left with a huff before they oust him . It is very natural. and emotional feeling and a biased judgement by AS and HR on debo who really sang very well such a tough qawali song sung by three different singers [male ]in different sur. he performed very well. I support ID for his strong support for his challenger. Atleast he was decent enough to express his views very openly but look at HR's drama and the way he play mimicry pleading support for vinit.shame on HR..

Since this program has decided to go with public vote and therefore they must respect public decision. This politics started by Hinesh from very first day itself, his shameless publicity for Vinit, some of the classic example like "Vinit's Love Story" etc really created damage for Vinit. Debojit many not performed consistently always but one must not forget the fact that Himesh and Adesh both have always created mental pressure on him by unnecessary criticizing his performance, giving low scores.
Every participant enjoys regional vote bank including Hemachandra, even Vinit and Hemani. Debojit represents North East and hence he gets most numbers of votes from there and also being a Bengali, he also enjoys a major vote share from West Bengal, mainly from Kolkata. Needless to mention here that the negative attitude from Himesh and Adesh towards Debojit really created positive public sentiments for Debojit and hence they are voting for him and they will

The Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJITThe Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJITThe Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJITThe Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJIT

The Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJITThe Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJITThe Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJITThe Voice of North East...Vote for DEBOJIT

Himesh and Aadesh profess to be fair and just, but in fact they are very unfair they have both at all times put down other candidates. They both have always played to the gallery and have made their singers pick up popular (new and old) songs and not the ones that can showcase the real range of those singers. Ismail on the other hand has always gone to pick up old/classic numbers. The public is not a music connosieur and is easily swayed by the popular numbers. Himesh seems to have made his life's mission to promote Vinit and Aadesh does the same for Himani and purposely gives a poorer score to others. The loss of Nihira and others will always weigh on their conscience. Stop saying Jai Mata di, if you can't be just.

Vote for DEBOJIT and be true to music and humanity. Can't keep a good man down for too long.

Originally posted by: ProudlySA

I have just watched the episode where Ismail Darbar walks out and think its a really sad day when sportsmanship goes out the window. His behaviour, regardless of all the "emotions" running rampant was most unprofessional and inexcusable. Surely there is more than one way to skin a cat. If he believes so much in Nihira's talent than go ahead and give her a break yourself. It's not the end of the road and don't ditch Debojit in mid journey??? Is that what he calls mentoring?

Everyone has favourites, there is no disputing that, but ultimately someone has to win. I just hope that whoever the person is that wins, wins on talent alone and not on emotional blackmail. I pray that the Indian public does not get swayed by the theatrics of Ismail Darbar and Himmesh Reshmiya.

I watched the show yesterday in Canada too and I could not disagree with you more. If you are blind, deaf and stupid enough to think that ID walked out *only because* Nihira was voted out then I don't know where to begin with you. Adesh Shrivastav is an A-hole and has been taunting ID and treating Nihira and Debojit unfairly for the longest time. There is only so much abuse a person can take (especially from a sore nobody like Adesh) and there is only so much infustice a person can tolerate- I support ID for walking out on an idiot like Adesh S and not putting up with his BS anymore. Well done ID!!!

I think Ismail should not have left the stage. This is highly unprofessoional. Ultimately there is going to be only one winner. Nihira is a good singer but she has done some bad selection of songs which did not appeal to lot of people and which is why she is not in the show. Debojit is alright not a great singer, he does not have his own identity. However, Ismail should stick with him until the end. He should not become partial with candidates like HR does. Vinit is a good singer and no doubt it. He has all the qualities of playback singer like Nihira and their voice suits lot of actors/actresses. Himani and Sharib is my favourite because they have distinctive voice which makes them special like Sukhwinder Singh and Sunidhi Chauhan. Hemachandar is very good but he has same limitations like himani and Sharib as his voice will be limited to certain actors. For me, Its very difficult to pick one because I like different singers for different reasons. However, some songs of Himani like kache Dhage song and Kalyug song made a special place for her. I would have been happy if Vinit, Himani, Nihira or Hemachander can win this contest together. They all are stars and have bright future ahead. HR need to knock off his "Pyar ke liye Jeetna hai" bullshit and get more professional.

I agree with mandeepsingh85 100%