SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 62

Punjabi ke gaane dete ho ..hindi gaate ho ..telugu kyun nahin? This whole thing is due to the problem of people like you thinking India is made of only 2/3 states. Who is testing the pronunciation? It is not about Hindi ..it is about Sur ok? That way did you listen to Vinit's voice? it is a tired voice since 3 episodes. How did he get 10? Leave this at some point this southie thing. How dare you used that southie word? it is indecent ok? It s not that I can't use such discriminatory words. It is that it is out of place in our decent ambience. Watch your language. Ok if so then how did he get 10, 10 with others? Were they from south? You should apprecaite talent period. Whether it is from south or north. You can argue that it is a hindi program ..but bachche phir pujbai kahan se aa gaya mere laal?

So you would give less marks coz they couldnt pronounce Punjabi well? None other than Prasoon praised his punjabi diction even. And there were some hard core urdu songs. Do you think all the pariticpants would have done justice to such a language? I will have to hear that again to feel that what you are saying is truth. i didn't feel any "hai". And for me that was a song with so many ups and downs all knew it was done justice. According to you desiboston, I must ask my southi friends .. so we now are southies and northies? 😆
Take your feelings somewhere else. Even your own decent friends wont buy your southie word (though I doubt if you will ever have any decent friends)

http://www.mumbaimirror.com/nmirror/mmpaper.asp?sectid=10&se ctname=Entertainment&sess=143772991

proves God Is Great.....

Well, let me give you a better word "Madrasis". Funny thing is am myself from north but I dont subscribe to such ideas or concepts. For me talent is all matters. Whether Vinit is from Bihar or Debo from silchar or Himani from Haryana or hema from AP

hahahahaha.. this is excellent.

http://www.mumbaimirror.com/nmirror/mmpaper.asp?sectid=10&se ctname=Entertainment&sess=143772991

chalo ..the party is over. BuBye.

I have just watched the episode where Ismail Darbar walks out and think its a really sad day when sportsmanship goes out the window. His behaviour, regardless of all the "emotions" running rampant was most unprofessional and inexcusable. Surely there is more than one way to skin a cat. If he believes so much in Nihira's talent than go ahead and give her a break yourself. It's not the end of the road and don't ditch Debojit in mid journey??? Is that what he calls mentoring?

Everyone has favourites, there is no disputing that, but ultimately someone has to win. I just hope that whoever the person is that wins, wins on talent alone and not on emotional blackmail. I pray that the Indian public does not get swayed by the theatrics of Ismail Darbar and Himmesh Reshmiya.

Originally posted by: criticaleye

Well, let me give you a better word "Madrasis". Funny thing is am myself from north but I dont subscribe to such ideas or concepts. For me talent is all matters. Whether Vinit is from Bihar or Debo from silchar or Himani from Haryana or hema from AP

I agree with you 100%. I did not mean any harm. I was trying to justify why he got 8. And I personally feel at this level these small things do matter. I am sure he is very soothing to listen for you, but for me when such small errors of pronunciation are present, I can definately not ignore it; not that it has to be punished. I have to say that he is the most non-influential identity for "begging" votes so far. Everybody has tried to influene the audience based on ethnic/racial backgrounds. He has done it based on pure talent.
I just noticed from the other post that Debu is no.1 and all others have walked out with ULFA allegations...LOL very funny that ULFA has time to watch SA RE GA MA PA . Gajji should get one of them as guests....😉

Desiboston..My problem is with HR judging it. I am more than 100% sure he didn't give him 8 coz of the reasons you quoted. I would be more than happy if he did so coz that would indicate heis judging him on parameters related to music and language then. But from HR I don't beleive it. He gave 8 just coz he wants to give less. He is surely not a bigger musician than Jatin (or was it Lalit..I always get confused between the brothers) and AS. If you had seen HR touched the feet of Jatin. Anyways chodo yaar ..ab in baaton mein rakha kya hai ..udhar to program reboot nahin reformat hone waala hai .. this Gajji created all polarization without his knowledge and now he is paying back. India is emotional ..still not ready for such programs. I dont know if that is coincidence, there are participants left out from North, South, East and West. 👏

on mumbaimirror news -i do not think th ULFA factor alleged by vinit and company is real. all i can say the teenagers are acting as teenagers (spoiled brats).

These comments are about Sa Re Ga Ma Pa episode that was telecast in USA last evening.

It is such a big shame how AADESH SHRIVASTAVA tried to play smart and keptbelittling Mr. Darbar.It is hard to beleive he comes from a such a good family of singers.His actions are so cheap.By regularly giving other contestants low marks 5,6 etc even when they sing well knowingly he has fallen to the lowest limits.Even Himeshji tries to play the 'Love story' card although he is always fair as far as the marking is concerned. But Darbarji has always supported talent and the way he was frustated by Aadesh and the way he made audience beleive differently- we pity him.